User: Grouch1980, Location: New York, NY
Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 1:02 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:30 am EST
Question: Section 430.63 tells you how to size the OCPD for a feeder protecting a lighting, appliance, and motor load.It tells you to follow certain sections, depending if you have:1) a single motor (refers you to section 430.52)2) a single motor compressor, sending you to article 440 (section 440.22)3) two or more motors (section 430.62)How come it doesn't state for two or more motor compressors?
You've pointed out a valid observation. Section 430.63 does lack explicit guidance on calculating the OCPD for a feeder with two or more motor-compressors. Here's why, and how to handle the situation
Why the omission?
The NEC (National Electrical Code) often relies on the principle of applying the most restrictive rules when multiple requirements are present. The rules for multiple motors are often designed to provide a conservative OCPD sizing to ensure adequate capacity for simultaneous starting and running currents. Because of that, they often omit very similar but more specific instances.
How to size the OCPD for two or more motor-compressors
Since Section 430.63 doesn't directly address multiple motor-compressors, you would apply a combination of relevant sections, leaning towards the most restrictive:1.
Treat as multiple motors
Use the requirements of Section 430.62. This section provides the general rules for multiple motors and is a good starting point. You'll need to calculate the FLC (Full Load Current) of all the motors/compressors.
2.
Consider motor-compressor specifics (Article 440)
You will need to apply 440.22 for each compressor, as the individual branch circuit OCPD for each compressor is based on Article 440.
3.
Combine and Adjust
Sum the largest motor/compressor branch OCPD with the sum of the other motor/compressor full load currents and all other loads.
In summary, to find the feeder OCPD for two or more motor compressors, you need to
1. Treat all the motors/compressors like regular motors, and reference Section 430.
62.2. Treat all the motors/compressors like motor compressors, and reference 440.
22.3. Choose the highest result of the two methods above.
Example
Let's say you have: Two 5 HP motor-compressors (FLC = 15 amps each, let's say largest OCPD is 25 amps each using 440.22). Some lighting and appliance load totaling 10 amps.
Method 1 (430.62)
Largest motor FLC = 15 amps Other motor FLC = 15 amps Total Motor FLC = 15 + 15 = 30 Apply 430.62: OCPD = (1.25 15) + 15 = 33.75 amps Total Load: 33.75 + 10 = 43.75 amps
Method 2 (440.22, and 430.62 to apply for motor load)
Largest motor OCPD = 25 amps Total Motor FLC = 15 amps Total Load: 25 + 15 + 10 = 50 amps
Final result
You would need to provide a breaker that is at least 50 amps.
Important Considerations
Coordination
Ensure your OCPD selection allows for proper starting current of the motor-compressors without nuisance tripping. Consider using time-delay fuses or inverse-time circuit breakers to accommodate inrush currents.*
Voltage Drop: Verify that the feeder conductors are adequately sized to minimize voltage drop during starting and running conditions. Excessive voltage drop can damage motors and compressors.By using this combined approach, you can ensure a safe and compliant installation that protects the equipment and complies with the NEC. Flag for review