User: Klem531, Location: Indiana USA
Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 3:40 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:31 am EST
Question: Hello, 25 year IBEW Journeyman here. Currently working in the office of a small contractor estimating jobs. Anywho, I came across a head scratcher today whilst doing a take off. There is a spec that states: "In order to reduce short curicuit, the electrical contractor shall route 30ft of #12awg wire for each power and lighting branch circuit connected to the lighting control panel. Run wire from panel, up to joist space, loop and route back down to the L. C. P. ".Has anyone come across something like this? Thanks.
Wow, that's definitely a head-scratcher! As a 25-year IBEW Journeyman, you've probably seen a lot, but this is a new one. Here's a breakdown of why it's odd and what might be behind it
Why It's So Strange:
Counter-Intuitive
The idea is to increase the impedance to limit short-circuit current. However, adding 30 feet of #12 wire in a loop increases impedance only slightly, and in most cases, insignificantly. Modern breaker technology is incredibly fast and effective at clearing faults. The small amount of impedance added by 30 feet of #12 AWG isn't likely to make a noticeable difference in the AIC (Ampere Interrupting Capacity) rating of the breaker needing to be used.
Not NEC Compliant (Likely)
The NEC (National Electrical Code) is prescriptive in many areas, but not generally in this way. Adding conductors to achieve a specific impedance outside of a listed and labeled device like a reactor/inductor is extremely unusual.
Safety Concerns
Looping wire like this could lead to excessive bundling in the joist space, potentially affecting heat dissipation. It creates a large inductive loop, which could become problematic in certain fault scenarios, although the #12 AWG is unlikely to carry enough fault current to create a significant inductive heating issue.
Wasted Material and Labor
It adds significant material and labor costs for very little, if any, demonstrable benefit.
Panel Space
The amount of space that the 'service loops' created would occupy inside the lighting control panel is tremendous, depending on the number of circuits. It's very likely that the control panel would need to increase in physical size to meet the requirements of the spec, increasing cost.
Possible (Though Unlikely) Explanations
Misunderstanding of Inductance/Reactance
Someone might have confused inductance (which is a factor in AC circuits) with resistance and mistakenly believed adding length would significantly reduce short-circuit current. While longer wire does increase inductance and impedance, the effect of 30 feet of #12 is negligible in most scenarios.
Faulty Application of a Valid Concept
There are specialized inductors (current-limiting reactors) used in electrical systems to reduce fault current. Maybe someone saw this concept but applied it incorrectly.
Trying to Meet AIC Ratings
In situations where the available fault current at a panel is higher than the AIC rating of the branch circuit breakers, you might see specifications requiring impedance to be added. However, this is usually done with specifically designed current-limiting reactors, not by adding wire.
Placebo Effect
Perhaps someone had a problem once, added some extra wire, and mistakenly believed it fixed the issue.
Typographical Error
This is a long shot, but maybe it was meant to be something else entirely, like "route wire through conduit for 30ft" or "provide 30in service loop in joist space" etc.
Specific Equipment Requirement
Very rarely, some specialized equipment might have a specific grounding or wiring requirement that involves a certain length of wire, but this would be highly unusual for standard lighting and power circuits.
What to Do Next
Clarification is Key
Absolutely reach out to the specifying engineer or architect for clarification. Politely explain that this specification is unusual and that you want to ensure you understand the intent behind it. Ask: "Could you please elaborate on the reasoning behind the 30-foot wire loop requirement for each branch circuit?" "Is there a specific performance characteristic you are trying to achieve with this design?" "Are there any specific calculations or studies that support this requirement?"2.
Document Everything
Keep a record of your communication with the engineer.3.
Alternative Solutions
If the engineer insists on the specification, you could politely suggest exploring alternative, code-compliant methods to address short-circuit current, such as:
Current-Limiting Breakers
Using breakers with higher AIC ratings or current-limiting features.
Current-Limiting Fuses
Using current-limiting fuses in a fused disconnect.*
Series Reactors
Installing a series reactor at the source of the power.4.
Change Order
If the engineer is adamant about the spec, make sure to clearly document the additional labor and material costs associated with this requirement in your bid. You will most likely need a change order that explains the requirement, and the added cost.
In summary, this specification is highly unusual and likely flawed. Getting clarification from the engineer is crucial. Document everything, and be prepared to suggest alternative solutions. Flag for review