User: arnettda, Location: Roughly 5346 miles from Earls Court
Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 3:42 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:32 am EST
Question: I was contacted by my School System to redo the service for the Baseball Field Lighting system. The building is old and they want to replace it or get rid of it and I will build a service pedestal of some type. The service is attached to the building. The service is a 480/277 CT cabinet with two Fused Disconnects used as both a service disconnect and the switch that turns the Lights on and off. One for the infield and one for the outfield. Each Service rated disconnect feeds a breaker panel at the base of each pole which then feeds up the pole to the group of fixtures at the top of the pole. The panels at the bottom of the poles are daisy chained together. The Light fixtures have never been converted to LED and I am working on finding there exact wattage.I believe this is a Legal installation. Maybe not the proper use of the service disconnects? What are my options for redoing the service and is the use of the Service disconnects like a switch code compliant or how would you do it now?Thank you
Okay, this is a classic situation. Let's break down your options for redoing the baseball field lighting service and address the code compliance concerns.
Current Situation Analysis 480/277V CT Cabinet
This is common for large loads like field lighting, especially older installations.
Fused Disconnects (acting as Service Disconnects AND Switches)
This is likely the primary point of contention from a modern code compliance perspective. While possibly grandfathered in initially, it doesn't conform to current practices. It could be considered compliant if there is another disconnecting means within sight, but this is unconfirmed.
Breaker Panels at Pole Bases
A good practice for overcurrent protection and individual pole control.
Daisy-Chained Panels
This isn't inherently illegal, but it can present challenges for fault isolation, maintenance, and future expansion.
Non-LED Fixtures
Inefficient and ripe for replacement!
Unknown Fixture Wattage
Critical information you must determine before designing a new system.
Code Compliance Concerns1. Service Disconnect as a Switch
While fused disconnects can be used as switches, it's generally not the intended or best practice, especially when they are also the service disconnect. Here's why it's problematic:
Wear and Tear
Frequent on/off switching of a fused disconnect can prematurely wear out its components. They are designed for infrequent operation.
Safety
Arcing can occur when switching under load, potentially damaging the disconnect and creating a safety hazard.
Modern Code Focus
Modern electrical codes heavily emphasize separating service disconnect functions from control functions.2.
Maintenance Disconnects for Each Pole
Having breaker panels at the base of each pole acts as the required disconnect withing sight of the equipment and the overcurrent protection of each individual pole.
Options for Redoing the Service
Here's a breakdown of your options, from simplest/least expensive to most comprehensive/best practice, with my recommendations
Option 1: Upgrade within the Existing Framework (Least Recommended - Band-Aid Solution)
Keep the 480/277V Service
Assuming it has sufficient capacity.
Replace Existing Fused Disconnects
If they are damaged or unsafe, replace them with new fused disconnects of the same rating. Critically, add a separate switching means.
Add Contactors
Install appropriately sized 480V contactors after the fused disconnects but before the existing breaker panels. Use a separate control circuit (e.g., 120V or low-voltage) to operate the contactors via a push-button station, timer, or building automation system.
Replace Fixtures with LED
Absolutely essential for energy savings, improved light quality, and reduced maintenance. Calculate the required wattage and choose appropriate LED fixtures.
Re-evaluate Breaker Panel Ratings
Ensure existing breaker panels at the poles are adequately rated for the new LED loads.
Pros
Lowest initial cost, utilizes existing infrastructure.
Cons
Doesn't address the underlying issue of using the service disconnect as a switch. May not be the most reliable long-term solution. Daisy-chaining remains. Still potentially non-compliant.
Option 2: Improved Service and Control (Recommended - Middle Ground) Keep the 480/277V Service
Assuming it has sufficient capacity.
Install a Service Disconnect
Install a properly rated and listed Service Disconnect.
Install a new Panelboard
Install a new distribution panel after the service disconnect.
Install a Time clock or Controller. Install a time clock or controller to energize the lights automatically. Home Run to each Pole
Run individual homeruns from the service distribution panel to each pole, removing the daisy chaining of the existing wiring.
Replace Fixtures with LED
Absolutely essential for energy savings, improved light quality, and reduced maintenance. Calculate the required wattage and choose appropriate LED fixtures.
Re-evaluate Breaker Panel Ratings
Ensure existing breaker panels at the poles are adequately rated for the new LED loads.
Pros
Provides a more compliant and safer service disconnect. Separates switching from service disconnect function. Can improve reliability. LED upgrade is essential.
Cons
Higher initial cost than Option 1. Still uses existing breaker panels at poles.
Option 3: Complete Service and Lighting Overhaul (Best Practice - Most Expensive) Keep the 480/277V Service
Assuming it has sufficient capacity.
Install a Service Disconnect
Install a properly rated and listed Service Disconnect.
Install a new Panelboard
Install a new distribution panel after the service disconnect.
Install a Time clock or Controller. Install a time clock or controller to energize the lights automatically. Home Run to each Pole
Run individual homeruns from the service distribution panel to each pole, removing the daisy chaining of the existing wiring.
Install new lighting poles and heads
Replace all of the lighting pole infrastructure and heads with new equipment. This is a time to select proper location and aiming that best fits the needs of the school system.
Pros
Provides a more compliant and safer service disconnect. Separates switching from service disconnect function. Can improve reliability. LED upgrade is essential.
Cons
Highest cost of all, new Lighting poles and heads will be expensive.
Key Steps and Considerations (Regardless of Option Chosen)1. Load Calculation is CRITICAL
You must determine the actual wattage of the existing fixtures. Don't rely on nameplate data alone; measure the actual current draw if possible. Use this data to calculate the total load and size the new service components appropriately. Account for voltage drop.2.
LED Selection
Work with a reputable lighting supplier to select LED fixtures that meet the desired light levels and color temperature requirements for the field. Consider glare control and light spill.3.
Overcurrent Protection
Ensure all breakers and fuses are properly sized and rated for the circuit they protect.4.
Grounding
Verify that the grounding system is adequate and meets current code requirements.5.
Conduit and Wiring
Inspect the existing conduit and wiring. Replace any damaged or deteriorated components. Use appropriately sized conductors for the load.6.
Permitting and Inspection
Obtain the necessary permits and schedule inspections with the local electrical authority. This is especially critical for service work.7.
Documentation
Keep detailed records of all work performed, including wiring diagrams, load calculations, and equipment specifications.
How I Would Do It
I would strongly recommend Option 2, The new panelboard and removal of daisy-chained wiring improves reliability and safety while addressing code concerns and facilitating easier maintenance. The LED conversion is a no-brainer for long-term savings and performance.
Answering Your Specific Questions "is the use of the Service disconnects like a switch code compliant?" Highly unlikely, especially under current code. It's generally not permissible. "How would you do it now?" As described in the recommended Option 2, separating the service disconnect function from the switching function with a panelboard and homeruns would be ideal.
Important Notes
Local Codes Reign
Always consult with and adhere to the latest edition of the National Electrical Code (NEC) as adopted by your local jurisdiction, as well as any local amendments or requirements.
Qualified Electrician
This type of work must be performed by a licensed and experienced electrician.
Engineering Stamp: Depending on the scope and complexity of the project, you may need to involve a licensed electrical engineer.Good luck with the project! Flag for review