User: artist43050, Location: Ohio
Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 4:48 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:32 am EST
Question: We have a 400 amp service and are going to add solar.Currently the service feeds Two 200amp panels in the house and a 150 amp panel in the barn with the taps to accomplish that in the meter base.The contractor is saying we need to eliminate the feed to the barn and pull the barns electric out of one of the house panels as the total of the breakers feeding off the meter equal 550amps (200+200+150).It seems as though the electrician who did the upgrade to 400 amps explained how he was able to feed the 3 panels directly when he put it in but I cannot find the NEC he sighted at the time.Does anyone have any insight into this?
You're right to question this. It's a common point of confusion and often leads to unnecessary and costly rewiring. Let's break down why your original setup likely complied, and why your solar installer is being cautious.
Understanding the NEC and Diversity/Demand Factors
The NEC generally requires the sum of breaker sizes to not exceed the service rating. However, it also acknowledges the concept of "diversity" or "demand factor." This recognizes that not all circuits will be loaded to their maximum amperage simultaneously. Service Load Calculation
The NEC requires a calculation to determine the actual load the service will experience. This involves considering the square footage of the dwelling, appliances, HVAC systems, and other loads. Standard methods apply demand factors to these loads to determine the service size.
Non-Coincident Loads
When dealing with multiple panels, the NEC considers whether the loads they serve are likely to be used simultaneously. For example, a barn might have a welder that pulls a lot of amps, but it's likely not running at the same time as all the kitchen appliances in the house.
Why Your Original Setup Likely Worked
Based on your description, the original electrician likely argued that the combined load on the three panels, after applying appropriate demand factors, was less than 400 amps. Here are potential arguments he might have made:1. Diversity Between House and Barn
The barn's electrical usage is likely different from the house. It might be primarily for tools, equipment, or agricultural purposes, with peak loads at different times of the day or year.2.
Limited Barn Load
A 150 amp panel in a barn isn't necessarily fully loaded. If the actual loads (lights, outlets, specific equipment) in the barn are low enough, and the barn is not expected to expand load, the demand factor could justify its inclusion.
Why the Solar Contractor is Being Cautious Simplification
The simplest, most conservative, and safest approach is to keep the total breaker amperage equal to or less than the service size. This avoids any potential for exceeding the service rating.
Liability
Solar contractors are often more risk-averse, as they are signing off on the entire system's safety and compliance. They might not want to rely on the previous electrician's calculations, which they didn't perform.
Future Load
The contractor might be concerned about future increases in load in the barn or the house. Adding solar can sometimes trigger closer scrutiny of the service capacity.
NEC Change
The NEC has become more stringent in recent years about load calculations, particularly when it comes to solar. It's possible that the contractor is applying newer interpretations of the code.
The Code and Your Situation NEC 230.71(B) - Maximum Number of Disconnects. This section states that the service disconnecting means shall consist of not more than six switches or six circuit breakers mounted in a single enclosure, in a group of separate enclosures, or in or on a switchboard. It does not state that the total breaker sizes must be under the main breaker size. NEC Article 220 - Load Calculations
This is the key to understanding the situation. It outlines how to perform load calculations for dwellings, farms, and other structures. It includes demand factors for various loads and allows for non-coincident loads to be considered. If the original electrician performed a load calculation and it showed the combined load was within the 400 amp service rating after the application of all demand factors, then it was a perfectly compliant install.
NEC 705.12(D)(2)
This section deals with load calculations specifically when connecting solar to existing service equipment. It involves considering the existing loads and the output of the solar system. This is where the contractor is likely focusing, to ensure the combined load (existing + solar) doesn't exceed the service rating.
What You Should Do1. Ask the Solar Contractor for a Detailed Load Calculation
Request a written explanation of how they arrived at their conclusion. Ask them to provide the load calculation they performed, specifying which sections of the NEC they used and what demand factors they applied.2.
Find the Original Electrician's Documentation
If you have any documentation from the original electrician (permits, invoices, etc.), look for any mention of load calculations or the specific NEC sections they used.3.
Get a Second Opinion
Consult with another licensed electrician who is familiar with solar installations. Show them the original electrician's documentation (if you have it) and the solar contractor's load calculation. Ask them for their opinion on whether the existing service is adequate.4.
Consider the Cost
Relocating the barn's electrical feed to one of the house panels will likely involve significant cost. Weigh that cost against the potential benefits of keeping the original setup (e.g., keeping the barn's circuits separate from the house).5.
Upgrade if Necessary
If the load calculations clearly show that the service is overloaded, or if there are concerns about future load growth, consider upgrading the service to a higher amperage.6.
Compromise
Ask the solar contractor if there are any cost-effective ways to mitigate the risk, such as adding a load monitoring system that can disconnect the solar if the service approaches its limit.
Important Considerations for Solar Backfeed Current
Solar systems can backfeed current onto the grid. The NEC limits the amount of backfeed current to prevent overloading the utility transformer.
120% Rule
The NEC contains a "120% rule" that limits the combined rating of overcurrent devices connected to a busbar or conductor. This rule can be a factor when adding solar to an existing panel.
Permitting
Be sure that all work is properly permitted and inspected to ensure compliance with local codes.
In summary, your original setup might have been compliant based on load calculations and demand factors. The solar contractor is likely being cautious to ensure safety and compliance. You need to get a clear understanding of the load calculations and consult with multiple electricians before making a decision. Flag for review