User: Greg1707, Location: Alexandria, VA
Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 6:21 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:32 am EST
Question: I have a HVAC/Plumbing contractor that provides me with considerable amount of work. When their customer needs electrical work for a new AC unit or mini split I get the call. They are working with a customer to install a tankless electric water heater. The unit needs 3 forty amp circuits.The house is an all electric (200 AMP) very large townhouse with two heat pumps, hot tub, electric range etc. I can make space in the panel by using piggy back breakers.The run from the panel to the water heater will need 250' 8-2 NM.This is a town house community so a 400 amp service is not possible.Should I have any concerns about this project?
Yes, you should have several significant concerns about this project. Installing a tankless electric water heater in an already heavily loaded, all-electric townhouse with a 200A service presents a high risk of overload and code violations. Here's a breakdown of the issues and what you need to consider
1. Load Calculation:
Critical Importance
You
must perform a proper load calculation according to the National Electrical Code (NEC) Article 220. You need to account for all existing loads plus the tankless water heater. This isn't just a "gut feeling" situation. It's a code requirement and a safety issue. Existing Loads
Carefully consider all the existing electrical loads, including: Two heat pumps (heating and cooling loads) Hot tub (heating load) Electric range (cooking load) Electric dryer Lighting and general receptacle circuits (consider square footage) Dishwasher Microwave Refrigerator Any other significant electrical appliances
Tankless Water Heater Load
The tankless heater requires 120 amps (3 x 40 amps). That's a substantial increase. Remember, electric tankless heaters are often continuous loads, which means you must derate your circuit capacity (80% rule).
Demand Factors
The NEC allows demand factors for certain loads (like ranges and dryers) when calculating the service size. Be sure to apply these correctly based on the NEC.
2. Service Capacity
200A Service Limit
A 200A service may be insufficient to handle all these loads especially the tankless water heater. Even if you can physically fit the breakers, the service entrance conductors and the main breaker are the limiting factors.
Overload Risk
Overloading the service can lead to: Nuisance tripping of the main breaker Overheating of conductors Potential for fire Damage to appliances
3. Conductor Sizing and Voltage Drop
250' Run with 8-2 NM
A 250-foot run with 8-2 NM cable for a 40-amp circuit is highly likely to have excessive voltage drop, especially under the high current demand of a tankless water heater.
Voltage Drop Calculation
Calculate the voltage drop. Use a voltage drop calculator or the formula provided in the NEC (Chapter 9, Informative Annex C). Voltage drop should ideally be no more than 3% on the branch circuit (and 5% total, including the feeder). Excessive voltage drop can cause: Poor performance of the water heater (reduced heating capacity) Damage to the water heater elements Other appliances may experience issues.
Likely Solution
For a 250-foot run, you will probably need to upsize the conductors significantly to minimize voltage drop. You may even need to use copper instead of aluminum. Consider using a larger gauge like #4 AWG or #2 AWG copper. You could also consider running the wiring in conduit, which gives you more wire options (THHN/THWN in conduit allows for higher ampacity).
Code Compliance
Voltage drop calculations and conductor sizing must comply with the NEC.
4. Piggyback Breakers (Tandem Breakers)
Panel Compatibility
Ensure the panel is specifically designed and labeled to accept tandem breakers. Not all panels are.
Limited Space
Using tandem breakers to make space is a common practice, but only if the panel is designed for it. Simply stuffing more circuits into a panel that's not designed for them is a code violation and a safety hazard.
Overcrowding
Even if the panel can accept tandem breakers, you need to ensure that adding them doesn't create overcrowding within the panel. Proper wire bending space is essential.
5. Townhouse Community Restrictions
HOA/Condo Association
You already know that getting a larger service is unlikely. Check for any HOA or condo association rules regarding electrical work, especially modifications to the service entrance.
Shared Metering/Service
Make absolutely sure the service is solely for this townhouse and not shared with any other units.
6. Alternatives and Recommendations
Consider a Hybrid Tankless
Look at hybrid tankless models that use a small holding tank combined with on-demand heating. These often require less amperage and are a great compromise.
Heat Pump Water Heater
A heat pump water heater is far more energy efficient than an electric tankless and might be a better option, especially considering the existing heat pump systems. They typically require a 30 amp 240v circuit.
Gas Tankless
If natural gas or propane is available, a gas tankless water heater is a much more efficient and less electrically demanding option.
Staggered Startup
Some tankless models may have the option for a staggered start to reduce the inrush current requirements.
Multiple Smaller Units
You might consider using multiple smaller tankless units placed closer to the points of use, which would reduce the required amperage and voltage drop.
Definitely Advise Against
I would strongly advise against installing the electric tankless water heater given what you know about the electrical service unless you can definitively prove through a load calculation and voltage drop calculation that it is safe and code-compliant.
Action Plan
Load Calculation
The very first step* is to perform a thorough load calculation.2.
Voltage Drop Calculation
Once you know the required amperage and distance, calculate the voltage drop.3.
Panel Inspection
Carefully inspect the panel for compatibility with tandem breakers and general condition.4.
Consult with the Customer
Explain the potential issues and the cost implications of upgrading wiring (if necessary). Be honest about the possibility that the existing service may be inadequate.5.
Get a Permit
Obtain the necessary electrical permits. This will ensure the work is inspected by a qualified electrical inspector.
In summary, installing a tankless electric water heater in this situation is high risk and requires careful evaluation and planning. Prioritize safety and code compliance. If the load calculation indicates that the existing service is inadequate, be prepared to advise the customer against installing the tankless heater. Flag for review