User: nizak, Location: Wisconsin
Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 7:16 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:33 am EST
Question: Have a EV charger that says that the E.G.C. needs to be the same wire gauge as the ungrounded conductors.Circuit is protected at 100 amps w/ #3 thhn conductors.Does there install instructions supersede the NEC when it comes to grounding?
Let's break this down.
Understanding the NEC and Manufacturer Instructions NEC (National Electrical Code)
The NEC is the minimum standard for safe electrical installations. It provides guidelines and rules intended to protect people and property from electrical hazards.
Manufacturer Instructions
These are specific to the piece of equipment you're installing (in this case, the EV charger). They can be more restrictive than the NEC, but they cannot be less restrictive.
The Conflict
The NEC has specific tables (like Table 250.122) that generally allow for a smaller equipment grounding conductor (EGC) than the ungrounded conductors, based on the size of the overcurrent protection device (OCPD). In your case, a 100A circuit typically requires a #8 AWG copper EGC according to the NEC.Your EV charger's instructions state that the EGC must be the same size as the ungrounded conductors (which are #3 THHN). This is more restrictive than the NEC requirement.
The Answer: Follow the More Restrictive Requirement Yes, the manufacturer's instructions supersede the NEC in this specific case because they are more stringent. The NEC sets the floor, and the manufacturer is allowed to raise that floor. Therefore, you must use a #3 AWG copper (or equivalent) EGC for this EV charger installation.
Why Might the Manufacturer Require a Larger EGC?
There are several possible reasons why the manufacturer might require a larger EGC: Fault Current Handling
The charger may be designed to handle higher fault currents than a typical 100A circuit would be expected to handle. A larger EGC provides a lower impedance path for fault current, which helps the OCPD trip faster.
Reduced Voltage Drop
A larger EGC reduces voltage drop in the grounding system, which can be important for sensitive electronics.
Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC)
A larger, well-bonded EGC can improve the electromagnetic compatibility of the charging system, reducing the potential for interference.
Specific Design Requirements
The charger's internal design may rely on a larger EGC for proper operation or safety.
Future Proofing
The manufacturer may be future proofing the installation for upgrades or higher current charging.
Important Considerations Consult the Instructions
Always read and follow the manufacturer's instructions completely. Don't skim them.
AHJ Approval
Your local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) has the final say on whether an installation meets code. If you have any doubts or if the AHJ questions the installation, be prepared to show them the manufacturer's instructions and explain why you followed them.
Material
Be sure to follow the instructions for the EGC's material. If #3 copper is specified, using #3 aluminum might not be acceptable.
In summary, use a #3 AWG EGC for your EV charger installation, as the manufacturer's instructions are more restrictive than the NEC in this situation. Flag for review