Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Tom Henry Calculations errors?

User: Ryan Ray, Location: Washington

Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 7:23 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:33 am EST

Question: Page 187 of Tom Henry's Calculations book states that if you omit AC as the smaller due to the heat being larger, you use the next largest motor as the largest motor to be increased 25%. 220.60 states that you still us the AC as the largest motor even if it's omitted due to heat being the larger load. Has anyone seen this in Tom Henry's book? Am I missing something?

Yes, you've identified a potential conflict between Tom Henry's method and the NEC. Here's a breakdown of why you're seeing this and how to approach it

The Heart of the Issue: Load Calculations and Diversity

Load calculations are about determining the maximum amount of current a service or feeder needs to supply. The NEC (specifically Article 220) provides rules to account for the fact that not everything will be running at its maximum capacity simultaneously. This is where diversity comes in.

NEC 220.60 (Air-Conditioning and Space Heating Equipment)

This section is very clear. It says:"Air-conditioning and space-heating equipment shall be calculated in accordance with 220.50 and 220.
51."
And those sections basically say you take the larger of the air conditioning or the space heating load as the total load for those systems. But it doesn't say you can ignore the AC when determining the largest motor. Further, the Informational Note No. 2 specifically states:"Informational Note No. 2: Where the air-conditioning equipment is a larger load than the space-heating equipment, it is permissible to omit the space-heating equipment load calculation, other than controls, from the service or feeder calculation. This allowance shall not affect the calculation for the largest motor as covered in 430.24."


Tom Henry's Interpretation (Potentially)

It sounds like Tom Henry's book is suggesting that if the heating load is larger than the AC load and you're omitting the AC load from the total overall calculation, you should then look to the next largest motor as the one to increase by 25% (as per 430.24 and related sections). While this approach might simplify the calculation, it can lead to undersized conductors and overcurrent protection.

Why This Matters (and Why the NEC is Correct)


Motor Starting Current

The 25% increase for the largest motor is primarily to account for the inrush current (also known as locked-rotor current) when a motor starts. This inrush is significantly higher than the motor's running current and can cause voltage drops if the conductors are not sized appropriately.2.

AC Units are Motors

Air conditioners (specifically their compressors) are motors. A large AC compressor can draw a significant starting current. Even if its total running load is less than the heating load, its inrush current could be substantial.3.

Code Compliance

The NEC is the law in most jurisdictions. Deviation from it can result in failed inspections and potentially unsafe installations.

What To Do


Follow the NEC

Always prioritize the National Electrical Code. NEC 220.60 and associated sections clearly state that the AC is still considered when determining the largest motor for the purposes of 430.24, even if you omit its running load from the overall calculation because the heating load is larger.
2.


Err on the Side of Safety

When in doubt, it's always better to be slightly oversized than undersized. If the calculations are close, consider bumping up the conductor and overcurrent protection sizes.3.

Verify Tom Henry's Interpretation

Carefully re-read the section in Tom Henry's book you're referring to. It's possible the wording is ambiguous or there's some context you might be missing. It might also be an outdated interpretation.

In Summary

While Tom Henry's book is a valuable resource, it's crucial to remember that the NEC is the ultimate authority.

Do not omit the AC unit when determining the largest motor for the 25% increase (430.24) even if you omit its running load from the overall calculation because the heating load is larger.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question