User: The electron man, Location: Nyc
Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 8:59 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:33 am EST
Question: So I was wondering if you had a delta delta transformer and one of the phase hit ground how would the current return to the source to trip the ocpd since you have no neutral ??
You're right to point out the nuance of a grounded phase in a delta-delta transformer. The current will return to trip the overcurrent protective device (OCPD), but the path is different, and often involves the ground itself. Here's the breakdown
Understanding the Situation
Delta-Delta Basics
A delta-delta transformer configuration has no neutral point tied to ground. The windings form a closed triangle on both the primary and secondary sides.
Grounded Phase
When one phase (let's say Phase A) accidentally connects to ground, it creates a new, unintended current path.
How the Current Returns and Trips the OCPD1. Fault Current Path
The fault starts at Phase A, where it is now connected to ground. The fault current flows from Phase A, through the unintended ground path.2.
Ground Return Path
The fault current needs a way to return to the transformer's secondary winding in order to complete a circuit and allow current to flow. The return path will predominantly use the available earth/ground return path to complete this circuit. The ground acts as a conductor. While it's not as efficient as a dedicated wire, it will carry current. Any metallic objects connected to ground (conduit, equipment grounding conductors, building steel, etc.) will provide a lower impedance path than the earth alone.3.
Current Flow in the Transformer
This current returning through ground will flow back to the transformer winding. The increased current will then flow through the other two windings, and increase the current in the supply conductors of the transformer's primary winding.4.
OCPD Operation
The increased current in the primary winding will result in higher current flow through the OCPD, eventually causing it to trip due to overcurrent.
Key Factors Affecting OCPD Operation Ground Impedance
The impedance of the ground path (earth, grounding conductors, etc.) is crucial. Higher impedance reduces the fault current, potentially delaying or preventing the OCPD from tripping.
Fault Current Magnitude
The magnitude of the fault current is determined by the system voltage and the impedance of the fault path (including the transformer winding impedance).
OCPD Type and Settings
The type of OCPD (fuse, circuit breaker) and its settings (trip curve) determine how quickly and at what current level it will trip.
Available Fault Current
The available fault current from the source is also critical. A system with limited fault current capacity might not generate enough current to trip the OCPD quickly, even with a grounded phase.
System Grounding (or Lack Thereof)
While delta-delta systems don't have a dedicated neutral ground, there is often unintentional grounding through equipment grounding conductors, conduit, and the earth itself. This unintentional grounding is what allows the fault current to return.
Why It's Not Ideal Low Fault Current
The ground path impedance is often high, resulting in relatively low fault currents. This can lead to:
Delayed Tripping
The OCPD might take a long time to trip, or might not trip at all, exposing equipment and personnel to hazards.
Voltage Rise
The voltage on the un-faulted phases can rise significantly above normal, stressing insulation and potentially causing further damage.
Touch Potential
If the fault current is flowing through the ground, any metal objects connected to ground can become energized, creating a shock hazard.
Unpredictability
Reliance on unintentional grounding makes the system less predictable and more susceptible to problems.
Importance of Ground Fault Protection (GFP) (Especially with Delta-Delta)
Because of the potential issues with fault current magnitude and delayed tripping in a delta-delta system with a grounded phase, Ground Fault Protection (GFP) is often used. GFP relays or breakers are specifically designed to detect small ground fault currents and trip quickly, mitigating the risks associated with a grounded phase in a delta-delta system. These systems monitor the current balance in the three phases. In a normal operating system, the current going out is equal to the current coming back, as such there is zero net current flowing to ground. If there's a ground fault, some current will leak to ground, creating an imbalance, and thus GFP will trigger.
In summary:
While a delta-delta transformer has no dedicated neutral ground, a grounded phase will cause current to return to the source via ground paths and will likely trip an OCPD eventually. However, relying on unintentional grounding is problematic, making GFP highly recommended to ensure safety and proper system protection. Flag for review