User: designer82, Location: Boston
Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 10:04 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:34 am EST
Question: Working on a 14 unit multi-family residential project, which will have central hot water via four 4.5kw (each) heat pump water heaters.These water heaters will be located in a community mechanical space in the basement.Question is, can I apply the 75% demand factor allowed by 220.53 to these heat pump water heaters?It does say:It shall be permissible to apply a demand factor of 75 percent to the nameplate rating load of four or more appliances rated 1∕ 4 hp or greater, or 500 watts or greater, that are fastened in place, and that are served by the same feeder or service in a one-family, two-family, or multifamily dwellingMy service calc. is ultra close and the 75% demand would actually make big difference if I can use it.(new transformer vs. no new transformer needed)\I don't see why not personally. Would appreciate your thoughts. Thanks
You're right to be scrutinizing this closely, especially with the service calculation being so tight. Here's a breakdown of why I believe you can apply the 75% demand factor in 220.53, but with some critical points to consider
Arguments Supporting the 75% Demand Factor (220.53):
Meets the Appliance Requirements
Each heat pump water heater is 4.5 kW, which is well above the 500W minimum rating specified in 220.
53. They are also fastened in place.
Multifamily Dwelling
Your project is a multifamily dwelling, which is explicitly included in the scope of 220.53.
Served by the Same Feeder or Service
The critical element here is whether the four water heaters are served by the same feeder or service. If they are all connected to a single feeder coming from the main service, then this condition is met. If each has its own dedicated feeder directly from the service, it's a different story.
Crucial Considerations and Potential Challenges
Local Amendments and Interpretations
This is the most important factor.
Call your local electrical inspector or the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ). They have the final say on interpretations of the code. Some jurisdictions might have local amendments that restrict the use of demand factors for water heaters, especially heat pump models, due to their potential for simultaneous operation under certain conditions. Get their blessing in writing if possible.2. "Fastened in Place"
Make sure that the water heaters can truly be considered "fastened in place". If they have any kind of plug & cord connection, the inspector may argue that they are not fastened in place and thus this section cannot be applied.3.
Likelihood of Simultaneous Operation
While the code allows the demand factor, consider the actual likely use of hot water. Are the units sized to handle peak demand? If the building has a lot of families taking showers at the same time, the actual demand might be closer to the total connected load, especially in winter months.4.
Backup Heating Elements
Do the heat pump water heaters have resistance heating elements as backup? If so, how are these controlled? If they can operate simultaneously with the heat pump, the demand might be higher than you anticipate. You might need to calculate the load with the heat pump and* the backup resistance elements to be on the safe side.5.
Future Capacity
Even if the 75% demand factor is allowed and appears sufficient now, think about future needs. Will tenants likely add electric vehicle chargers or other significant loads? It might be prudent to upsize the service anyway to accommodate future demand, even if not strictly required today.
Recommendation
Contact the AHJ (Electrical Inspector)
This is paramount. Explain your situation and get their explicit approval for using the 75% demand factor under 220.53 for heat pump water heaters.
2.
Document the Conversation
Keep a record of your communication with the inspector, including the date, time, and the inspector's name. Written confirmation is always best.3.
Evaluate Simultaneous Use
Seriously consider the potential for simultaneous hot water demand. If you have doubts, err on the side of caution and increase the service size.4.
Factor in Backup Heat
Account for the backup heating elements if they exist and can operate simultaneously.5.
Future-Proof the Design
Consider potential future load additions and whether a larger service would be a wise investment.
In summary: On the face of it, 220.53 seems to allow the demand factor. However, the AHJ's interpretation is key, as is a careful assessment of the actual anticipated load. Get confirmation from the inspector before proceeding. Flag for review