Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Rotork IQ series Breaker/Fuse sizing

User: SparkinTexas2001, Location: Texas

Asked on: Monday, October 7, 2024 at 10:25 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:34 am EST

Question: Since the IQ series comes with overload protection what is the consensus on breaker and fuse sizing? FLA vs LRA

You're asking about a crucial topic: properly sizing circuit breakers and fuses for motors, particularly in the context of equipment like the IQ series, which includes built-in overload protection. Here's the consensus, explained with clarity and important considerations

The Fundamental Principle:
FLA (Full Load Amps) is the Key for Breaker/Fuse Size

Generally, you size the breaker/fuse based on the

FLA
(Full Load Amps) of the motor, NOT the LRA (Locked Rotor Amps). The FLA represents the continuous current the motor draws when operating at its rated load.
Overload Protection Handles the Rest

The built-in overload protection (present in IQ series and other modern motor controllers/soft starters) is designed to protect the motor from prolonged overcurrents due to mechanical overload (e.g., a jammed pump impeller). It's there to trip the motor off-line if it runs at, say, 125% of its FLA for an extended period, preventing overheating and damage.

Why NOT Use LRA?
LRA is a Short-Term Surge

LRA (Locked Rotor Amps) is the current the motor draws for a very brief moment when it initially starts up. It can be several times higher than the FLA. If you sized the breaker based on LRA, it would be far too large, and would not protect the wiring or components from overloads.


Nuisance Tripping

A breaker sized for LRA would likely never trip during an overload condition. You'd only protect against severe short circuits, but not the more common (and damaging) overload scenarios.

The Code & Specific Percentages (NEC Guidance)

The National Electrical Code (NEC) provides guidance for the proper sizing of breakers and fuses for motor circuits. Here's a summarized version, but always consult the latest version of the NEC and any applicable local codes for definitive answers:

Inverse Time Breakers

Typically, the NEC allows you to size an inverse time breaker (standard thermal-magnetic breaker) at

150% to 250% of the FLA
of the motor. However, if that value doesn't allow the motor to start, you can increase the breaker size, but you MUST NOT EXCEED the maximum values specified by the NEC. This is where experience and careful consideration of the motor's starting characteristics come into play. Dual-Element Time-Delay Fuses

These fuses are designed to tolerate the inrush current (LRA) of a motor without blowing. The NEC generally permits sizing them at

175% of the FLA
of the motor. Again, if necessary for starting, you might be able to increase it, but do not exceed the code limits. Instantaneous Trip Circuit Breakers (Magnetic Only)

These are rarely used as the
sole motor branch circuit protection due to the fact that they have no inverse time delay.

Important Considerations When Sizing


Motor Nameplate

Always use the motor's nameplate FLA value. Don't guess.2.

Service Factor

If the motor has a service factor greater than 1.0, the overload protection should be sized accordingly.
3.


Ambient Temperature

If the motor is in a very hot or cold environment, derate the breaker/fuse accordingly.4.

Wire Size

The conductor (wire) feeding the motor must be sized to handle at least 125% of the motor's FLA. The breaker or fuse protects the
wire, and the overload relay protects the motor.5.

Coordination

If you have multiple motors on a system, consider coordination (selectivity). This means that a fault on one motor should only trip the breaker for that motor, not the main breaker feeding the entire system.6.

Manufacturer's Recommendations

Always consult the manufacturer's recommendations for the specific motor and motor control equipment being used. The IQ series documentation may have specific requirements or recommendations.7.

Application Specific Requirements

The NEC and local codes may have specific requirements for certain types of motors or applications (e.g., fire pumps, elevator motors). Be sure to adhere to these.

In Summary

Base the breaker/fuse size on the motor's FLA, not LRA. The motor's overload protection will handle prolonged overcurrents. The breaker/fuse protects the wiring from short circuits and excessive overloads. Consult the NEC, local codes, and manufacturer's documentation for specific requirements. When in doubt, err on the side of caution and consult with a qualified electrical engineer or electrician.

Example

Let's say you have a motor with an FLA of 10 amps. You are using a standard inverse time circuit breaker.1.

Calculate 150% of FLA

10 amps 1.50 = 15 amps2.

Calculate 250% of FLA

10 amps
2.50 = 25 ampsYou could likely use a 15 amp, 20 amp, or 25 amp breaker, depending on the specific starting characteristics of the motor. A 20 amp breaker is a common choice. If the 20 amp breaker trips on startup, you can consider moving up to a 25 amp breaker if and only if the NEC and manufacturer's specifications allow it. You must also ensure your conductors are rated for at least 125% of the FLA of the motor. So in this case, 12.5 amps.

Disclaimer:
I am an AI Chatbot and not an electrical engineer. The information provided is for general guidance only and should not be considered a substitute for professional advice. Always consult with a qualified electrical engineer or electrician for specific recommendations and to ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question