Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Single conductor 15kV cable routed in tray laid flat, not triplexed?

User: Dale001289, Location: Georgia

Asked on: Tuesday, October 8, 2024 at 1:17 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:36 am EST

Question: We have a 1/C 15kV, shielded three phase feeder being routed in cable tray and the lead EE is saying the conductors should NOT be triplexed in a bundle but rather routed separately, laid flat across the tray. There is a about four inches between phases and EGC is also separateDoes this make sense?

Yes, the lead EE's instruction to not triplex the conductors and lay them flat with separation makes sense for a 1/C 15kV shielded three-phase feeder in a cable tray. Here's why

Reasons for Separated, Laid-Flat Configuration:
Heat Dissipation

High-voltage cables generate heat due to conductor losses (I²R losses) and dielectric losses. Bundling concentrates this heat, raising the conductor temperature. Laying the cables flat, with separation, significantly improves heat dissipation to the surrounding air. This allows the conductors to operate closer to their ampacity rating.


Ampacity Derating

The NEC (National Electrical Code) requires ampacity derating for conductors bundled together in raceways or cable trays due to the reduced heat dissipation. By separating the conductors, the lead EE aims to minimize or eliminate the need for derating, allowing the feeder to carry its intended load.

Voltage Drop

While the effect isn't as dramatic as with heat, spacing the conductors slightly increases the inductance of the circuit, and can slightly increase voltage drop. However, this is typically a minor factor compared to heat management.


Shielded Cable Considerations

The shields on high-voltage cables generate some heat as well. Separating the cables helps dissipate heat from the shields.

Ease of Maintenance and Inspection

Separated cables are easier to inspect for damage or wear. Troubleshooting and future modifications are also simplified.


Cable Tray Capacity

Bundling thick high-voltage cables can quickly fill up a cable tray, making it difficult to add future circuits. Spacing the cables allows for better use of the available tray space.

Inductive Reactance

It's true that closely spacing the conductors minimizes inductive reactance. However, in a cable tray installation with short runs, the increase in inductive reactance due to spacing is usually a minor concern compared to the significant benefits of improved heat dissipation and ampacity.

In summary, the primary justification for this approach is to maximize ampacity by optimizing heat dissipation.
Potential Considerations (Confirm with Lead EE)



NEC Compliance

Ensure the chosen configuration complies with the NEC requirements for cable tray installations and conductor spacing.

Tray Fill

Confirm that the cable tray is not overfilled with the separated conductors. There are fill limits based on the type of tray.


Cable Clamping/Support

Make sure the cables are properly secured and supported within the cable tray to prevent movement and damage. Use appropriate cable clamps or ties that are rated for the cable size and voltage.

Shield Grounding

Confirm the proper grounding of the cable shields. Typically, the shields are grounded at both ends, or grounded at one end and voltage limited at the other.

When Bundling Might Be Acceptable (But Less Ideal)



Low Load Current

If the feeder is significantly underloaded, the heat generation may be low enough that bundling is acceptable (but still less desirable). This requires careful ampacity calculations and considerations for future load growth.

Short Run Lengths

For very short runs, the temperature rise may be less significant.


Forced Cooling

If forced air cooling is used in the cable tray, bundling might be more acceptable (but still needs careful calculations).

In conclusion, the lead EE's decision to separate the 1/C 15kV cables in the cable tray is a standard and generally sound engineering practice to optimize ampacity, manage heat, and improve maintainability.
Follow the instructions and ensure proper cable support and grounding are implemented. Verify code compliance with the lead EE. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question