Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Generator guy asks about service inspection and it backfires

User: electrofelon, Location: Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA

Asked on: Tuesday, October 8, 2024 at 1:43 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:36 am EST

Question: So get a call from a lady who I did a service upgrade for in 2008. She says she had a generator installed and the generator guy said he didn't see any evidence of a service inspection. Around here inspections are third party, and the inspection sticker usually fades or falls off after a few years. I went back and forth with her a couple times, and just tried to explain the inspection gets called in to the utility electronically and if it gets hooked up and the meter sealed then you know the inspection went through. I called the inspection agency and they no longer have the certificate. She insists on a re-inspection. Okay so I figured I should just go look before I call the inspector.... Probably need an inter- system terminal on there. I look at the ATS while I'm there, which is after the meter main. Guy never removed the neutral ground bond in the ATS. I tell the lady about the code violation and ask if HIS work was inspected

This is a tricky situation, but you're handling it well. Here's a breakdown of the issues and some suggestions on how to proceed

Understanding the Issues
Inspection Certificate Gone

The lack of a physical inspection certificate from 2008 is not surprising. Many inspections are electronic now, and paper records fade. The utility having the record is the key.


Generator Installer's Suspicion

The generator installer raising concerns is understandable. They may be cautious about liability or genuinely unsure if the original service upgrade was inspected.

Neutral-Ground Bond in ATS

This is the most pressing issue. A neutral-ground bond in the ATS (after the service disconnect/meter) creates a parallel neutral path, which is a code violation (NEC 250.24(A)(5) and often 250.30). This can lead to circulating neutral currents, increased shock hazard, and potential equipment damage.


Lady's Request

She wants a re-inspection to ease her mind.

Liability

You are potentially liable if your original work was not inspected or was incorrectly installed.

Your Actions So Far (Good Job!)
Explaining the Electronic Inspection

You correctly explained the utility's electronic inspection process.

Checking the ATS

You're smart to go to the site to assess the situation
before contacting the inspector. Finding the neutral-ground bond was crucial.

Recommended Next Steps
1. Document Everything! Photos

Take clear, well-lit photos of: The ATS. Focus on the neutral-ground bond. Get photos that show the entire setup, the bonding point, and the labeling. The meter and service equipment. The original service panel. Any existing labeling or wiring related to the generator installation.

Notes

Write detailed notes about your observations, including:
The make and model of the ATS. The size of the service conductors. The grounding electrode conductor (GEC) size and connections. Any other relevant information.

Dates and Times

Note the date and time of your visit.2.

Communicate with the Homeowner (Carefully)



Frame the Neutral-Ground Bond as a Safety Issue

"I found a code violation in the generator installation related to the grounding. There's a neutral-ground bond in the ATS that needs to be corrected. This could create a shock hazard and needs immediate attention."
Avoid placing blame; focus on the safety aspect.



Document the conversation in writing (email, text message)

"As we discussed on [date] at [time], I found a neutral-ground bond in the ATS. This presents a potential electrical safety hazard and should be corrected as soon as possible."

Recommend a Qualified Electrician (If Not You)

"I recommend having a qualified electrician (ideally one familiar with generator installations) correct this issue." If you want to do it, say so.


Avoid Admitting Fault (For Now)

Don't say anything that suggests you were responsible for the neutral-ground bond (even if you suspect it). The generator installer is the one who worked on the ATS.

Gauge her reaction

Listen carefully to her concerns and frustrations. Empathize with her situation but stay focused on the facts.3.

Decide if You Want to Correct the Neutral-Ground Bond (Profitability vs. Liability)



Pros of Correcting It

Resolves the immediate safety hazard. Potentially earns her trust and avoids further complaints. Demonstrates your professionalism.

Cons of Correcting It

Takes your time. Could be seen as admitting responsibility (even if it wasn't your fault). You would be working on work done by another contractor, so make sure it is up to code.4.

Contact the Generator Installer (After Speaking with the Homeowner)



Professional Tone

"I recently inspected a generator installation that you performed on a service I upgraded in 2008. I observed a neutral-ground bond in the ATS, which is a code violation (NEC 250.24(A)(5)). This needs to be corrected for safety reasons. I recommend reviewing your work and correcting this issue promptly."

Avoid Accusations

Don't start a fight. Focus on the code violation and the need for correction.


Listen to their response

Be prepared for them to be defensive.

Document the Conversation

Keep a record of your conversation.5.

Communicate with the Utility
Speak with someone at the utility regarding the inspection. If they have records, ask if they can provide some type of confirmation of the inspection.6.

Re-inspection and Final Resolution



If YOU Correct the Neutral-Ground Bond

After correcting the issue, request an inspection to ensure it meets code.


If ANOTHER ELECTRICIAN Corrects It

Ask for documentation and verification of the correction.

Important Considerations

Legal Advice

If you are concerned about potential liability, consult with an attorney specializing in construction or electrical work.


Statute of Limitations

Be aware of the statute of limitations in your area for electrical work.

Insurance

Review your liability insurance policy.


Documentation is Key

Every communication, photo, and note is important in case of a dispute.

In summary, your priority is addressing the safety hazard caused by the neutral-ground bond in the ATS. Approach the situation professionally, document everything meticulously, and seek legal advice if needed. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question