Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 40 amp 208v circuit to HWH had a dead short to Ground- Breaker did not trip. Why?

User: Scottybars2288, Location: South Carolina

Asked on: Tuesday, October 8, 2024 at 2:09 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:36 am EST

Question: So plumber was finalizing his end, filled heater with water and went to turn breaker on, upon doing this he said there was an arc where the wires splice to the heater wires. I opened up, one of the legs had been pushed in hard and insulation was nicked by the head of the ground terminal screw. fixed it, turned it on, checked for power, all good. I asked if the breaker had tripped and he said no. it is a standard 2 pole 40, Homeline, 10,000 AIR. What could this be besides bad ground connections, or a faulty breaker?

Okay, this is a serious situation because arcing is a fire hazard and indicates a problem that needs to be fully understood. Let's break down the possibilities and what you should consider

Most Likely Scenarios (Given the Information):

1. The Nicked Insulation Was the Culprit

You found a damaged wire. This is highly likely the cause of the initial arc. The nick could have been just deep enough to intermittently short to ground (the water heater's chassis via the ground screw). When the plumber flipped the breaker, the voltage difference was sufficient to arc across the compromised insulation.2.

Loose Connection (Even If You Tightened It)

A connection can appear tight but still have enough resistance to cause arcing. Here's why:

Corrosion

Even a little corrosion on the wire strands or the terminal can create resistance.


Improper Wire Stripping

If too much insulation was left on, the screw might not have been making solid contact with the wire itself. Or if the wire was nicked during stripping.

Stranded Wire Fanning Out

Stranded wire needs to be neatly twisted before insertion into a terminal, to prevent strands from straying and weakening the connection.3.

Marginal Breaker

Even though the breaker didn't trip immediately, it's possible it's become weak over time. A weak breaker might not trip as quickly as it should in the event of a fault. A breaker can weaken with age, especially if it's been subjected to repeated overloads or short circuits (even small ones that didn't cause a full trip).4.

Heater Element Issue

The heater element
could have an internal fault that is causing a high current draw (but not a direct short). This is less likely than the wiring issues, but it's still a possibility. A failing element might have internal arcing that doesn't necessarily trigger the breaker immediately. This is less likely because the element is new. This is less likely because the arcing happened as soon as the breaker was turned on.

Less Likely, But Still Possible



Mis-wired Heater

While unlikely, it's
possible the heater was mis-wired internally at the factory (though less likely with a new heater). This could create an unexpected path for current.

Why the Breaker Didn't Trip Immediately



Ground Fault Not Large Enough

The initial arc might not have been a "dead short" to ground. It could have been a high-resistance ground fault. Standard breakers are designed to trip quickly on high-current faults. A high-resistance fault might draw enough current to cause arcing and heat, but not enough to immediately trip the breaker.

Arc Fault Circuit Interrupter (AFCI) Needed

Standard breakers are
not designed to detect arcing conditions. That's the job of an Arc Fault Circuit Interrupter (AFCI) breaker. AFCIs are much more sensitive to arcing and are required in many locations (especially bedrooms) to prevent fires.

Slow-Tripping Breaker

Although it's a 40 amp breaker, some breakers have a "time delay" for certain types of overloads.

Weak Breaker (as mentioned above)



What You Should Do (Important for Safety)


TURN OFF THE BREAKER IMMEDIATELY!
Leave it off until you've thoroughly investigated.2. Call a Qualified Electrician

This situation requires a professional assessment. Don't try to troubleshoot this yourself if you're not comfortable and experienced with electrical work. Arcing is dangerous, and you want to ensure everything is safe. Explain to the electrician what you found (nicked wire, arcing) and the steps you've taken.3.

Detailed Inspection by the Electrician

The electrician should:


Inspect All Wiring

Thoroughly examine all wiring connections to the water heater, including the splices, terminals, and the wiring inside the junction box on the water heater itself.

Check Wire Gauge

Make sure the wire gauge is appropriate for a 40-amp circuit (typically 8 AWG copper, but verify based on local codes and the breaker rating).


Torque Connections

Use a torque screwdriver to tighten all connections to the manufacturer's specified torque. Under- or over-tightening can both cause problems.

Insulation Resistance Test (Megger Test)

A Megger test applies a high voltage (DC) to the wiring to check for insulation breakdown. This can help identify shorts or near-shorts that might not be obvious.


Check the Breaker

The electrician should test the breaker to ensure it's functioning correctly.

Inspect the Heater Element (If Suspected)

The electrician can use an ohmmeter to check the resistance of the heating element. An unusual reading could indicate a problem.


Consider an AFCI Breaker

Discuss with the electrician whether an AFCI breaker is appropriate for this circuit, even if not required by code in your area. It adds an extra layer of safety.4.

Document Everything

Keep detailed records of the problem, the steps you took, and the electrician's findings and actions.

Important Safety Notes



Electricity is Dangerous

If you're not experienced with electrical work, DO NOT attempt to troubleshoot or repair this yourself.


Always Turn Off Power

Before working on any electrical circuit, turn off the power at the breaker. Double-check with a voltage tester to ensure the circuit is dead.

Use Proper Tools

Use insulated tools designed for electrical work.


Follow Code:
Ensure all wiring and repairs comply with local electrical codes.Let me know if you have any other questions! Good luck, and stay safe. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question