User: binwork91, Location: new york
Asked on: Tuesday, October 8, 2024 at 3:27 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:37 am EST
Question: I have a project, tap conductor feeds a panelboard with MCS (molded case switch).Is MCS a overcurrent protective device?In my opinion, MCS is not a overcurrent protective device, it does not provide overcurrent protection, it only has a fixed instantaneous self-protecting trip element which may open the switch under high fault conditions, therefore, we can not use 10ft tap, 25ft tap rule to feeds a panelboard with MCS.What is your opinion?
You are correct in your assessment. A Molded Case Switch (MCS) is not an overcurrent protective device (OCPD) in the same way a circuit breaker or fuse is. Therefore, you cannot use the 10ft or 25ft tap rules to feed a panelboard protected solely by an MCS.Here's a breakdown of why: Purpose of an MCS
The primary function of an MCS is to provide a means of disconnecting power to the downstream panelboard or equipment. While it can have an instantaneous trip function for very high fault currents, this is primarily for the switch's self-protection, not for the protection of the conductors or equipment it feeds.
Overcurrent Protection Defined
Overcurrent protection, as defined by the NEC, is intended to protect conductors and equipment against overloads and short circuits. It does this by automatically interrupting the current flow when it exceeds a predetermined safe level. This protection requires both:
Overload protection
Response to current above the conductor's ampacity but below short-circuit levels. This would prevent the conductor from overheating.
Short-circuit protection
A very fast response to very high fault currents.
MCS and Overcurrent Protection
An MCS lacks the overload protection characteristics. It's designed to carry its rated current without tripping, even if that current is above the safe ampacity of the tap conductors. The instantaneous trip (if present) would only activate at extremely high fault levels, likely after the tap conductors have been damaged.
Tap Rules and OCPD
The tap rules (10ft, 25ft, etc.) in the National Electrical Code (NEC) are specifically written under the assumption that the tap conductors are protected by an overcurrent protective device at the termination of the tap. This OCPD must be properly sized to protect the ampacity of the tap conductors. Since the MCS doesn't fulfill this function, the tap rules do not apply.
NEC References
While the NEC doesn't explicitly state "an MCS is not an OCPD," the definition of overcurrent protection and the application of the tap rules make this clear.* NEC Article 240 addresses overcurrent protection. Pay close attention to the sections covering conductor protection and tap conductor rules (e.g., 240.21).
Conclusion
You are absolutely correct. You cannot use the tap rules when feeding a panelboard protected only by a molded case switch. You need a properly sized overcurrent protective device (circuit breaker or fuses) at the end of the tap conductors to protect them according to their ampacity. This OCPD would then feed the panelboard with the MCS.
In summary: An MCS is a switching device with limited (or no) overcurrent protection capabilities suitable for protecting tap conductors. For tap conductor applications, you require an OCPD (fuse or circuit breaker) at the tap termination to properly protect the conductors from overcurrent conditions. Flag for review