Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 220.60 Noncoincident loads

User: Ryan Ray, Location: Washington

Asked on: Tuesday, October 8, 2024 at 3:44 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:37 am EST

Question: If AC is omitted as the smaller load, is it still increased 25% if it's the largest motor? Tom Henry's Calculations book states that you use the next highest rated motor and not the AC if it's omitted, but I don't believe this is true. Does anyone know if I'm, correct?

You are correct. Tom Henry's statement is misleading, at best, and likely incorrect based on a standard interpretation of the NEC (National Electrical Code).Here's why: NEC 430.24 (Several Motors or a Motor(s) and Other Load(s))

This section clearly states that the conductors supplying several motors, or a motor(s) and other load(s), shall have an ampacity equal to the sum of the following:1. 125% of the full-load current rating of the

highest rated motor
2. The sum of the full-load current ratings of all other motors in the group3. The ampacity of other loads
Interpreting "Highest Rated Motor"

The "highest rated motor" refers to the motor with the highest full-load current rating. If the AC unit's compressor motor has a higher full-load current than any other motor in the system, it IS the "highest rated motor" for calculation purposes, regardless of whether you're calculating the feeder size for just motors or motors and other loads.

AC as an "Other Load"

While AC units
can be considered an "other load" if you're calculating the feeder size for an entire building, in this specific case, where you're dealing with a circuit or feeder dedicated to motor loads, and the AC unit is essentially being treated as another motor load, the AC's compressor motor should still be considered when determining the "highest rated motor".

Why Tom Henry's Statement is Likely Wrong

Tom Henry's books, while helpful, are interpretations of the NEC and are not the NEC itself. He may be simplifying a scenario or creating confusion by not clearly defining the context. It's possible he's referring to a specific scenario where the AC is truly being considered
only as an "other load" and not factoring in its compressor motor's current, but this is uncommon when determining the minimum conductor ampacity required.

Example

Let's say you have:
Motor A: 10 amps full-load current Motor B: 8 amps full-load current AC Unit (Compressor Motor): 12 amps full-load current "Other" Loads: 5 amps (lights, etc.)Following NEC 430.24, you'd calculate the feeder size as:1. (12 amps 1.25) = 15 amps (125% of AC's compressor motor)2. 10 amps + 8 amps = 18 amps (sum of other motors)3. 5 amps (other loads)

Total: 15 + 18 + 5 = 38 amps


If you incorrectly followed Tom Henry's (potentially) flawed logic and used the next highest motor after omitting AC.1. (10 amps * 1.25) = 12.5 amps (125% of Motor A)2. 8 amps = 8 amps (sum of the other motor)3. 5 amps (other loads)Total: 12.5 + 8 + 5 = 25.5 amps

This feeder size wouldn't properly carry the load that may be presented.

In conclusion: Rely on the NEC itself as the definitive guide. If the AC compressor motor has the highest full-load current, it should be the basis for the 125% calculation, even if you are classifying it as an "other load". Always consult with a qualified electrician and your local electrical inspector for specific applications. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question