User: Scottybars2288, Location: South Carolina
Asked on: Tuesday, October 8, 2024 at 7:58 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:38 am EST
Question: I have 800 amp services on the end of each building. each with 18 meters 1ph 120/208 125a-one with an additional house meter, 3ph 4w 120/208 225. I noticed in the house panel and in the 125 amp 1ph panel, i’d have straight continuity between the neutral and ground, as I should. Once I turn on the lighting circuits the the continuity on my meters sounds like it comes and goes, like something is disrupting it or it’s loose. Comes back when lighting is turned off again. Continuity between neutral and ground at the service remains even while everything is energized, unlike the panel. my feeder connections are tight and neutral bonded in the main cabinet. From each service I have a UFER ground and a 3/0 copper to 4” underground water pipe.
Okay, this is a tricky situation that points to a potential issue with your grounding and neutral system. Let's break it down and explore potential causes and troubleshooting steps.
Understanding the Issue Expected Behavior
You should have continuity between the neutral and ground at the service entrance (where the neutral is bonded to ground). In subpanels (like those fed by the 800A services), the neutral and ground should be kept
separate. Continuity in the subpanels usually indicates a problem. Problem 1: Continuity in the 125A 1ph Panel and House Panel
This is the major red flag. The neutral and ground conductors should not be bonded together in those panels. The fact that you have continuity before turning on the lights suggests the problem is always present, even when nothing is drawing power.
Problem 2: Intermittent Continuity with Lights On
This could indicate a loose neutral connection somewhere in the lighting circuits, or it could be exacerbating the existing problem. A load (lights) being switched on is changing the voltage/current flow, making the problem more noticeable. It's essentially "wiggling" something.
Continuous Continuity at the Service
This part is expected; the neutral should be bonded at the service.
Possible Causes and Troubleshooting Steps
Here's a systematic approach:1. Verify Proper Wiring in Subpanels (MOST IMPORTANT) Double-Check all 1-Ph 125A panels and House Panel
This is paramount. Go to every 1ph 125A meter panel and the house panel. Completely disconnect the neutral and ground bars. Visually inspect each panel.
Look for
Bonding Jumper
Are there any jumpers connecting the neutral and ground bars? REMOVE them. This is the most common mistake.
Multiple Wires Under One Lug
Is a neutral and a ground wire crammed together under a single lug? Correct this.
Nicked/Damaged Insulation
Check for any spots where the insulation on a neutral or ground wire is damaged and might be touching the metal enclosure. Repair/replace.
Corrosion
Clean any corrosion on the neutral or ground bars or on the wire terminations.
Separate Neutrals and Grounds
After the inspection, make sure the neutral wires go only to the neutral bar, and the ground wires go only to the ground bar. The ground bar should be bonded to the metal enclosure of the panel.2.
Confirm Proper Service Grounding (Again)
Visual Inspection
Check the UFER ground and the connection to the water pipe. Are they in good condition (no corrosion, tight connections)?
Ground Resistance Test
Use a ground resistance meter (if you have one, or hire an electrician with one) to measure the resistance to ground. It should be very low (ideally under 5 ohms, but local codes may specify a different value). A high reading indicates a problem with the ground connection.3.
Neutral Conductor Integrity Megger Test
A megger (insulation resistance tester) can help identify insulation faults in the neutral conductor between the service and the subpanels. Disconnect the neutral at both ends (service and subpanel) before meggering!
Voltage Drop Test
Under a heavy load (safely load up some of the lighting circuits), measure the voltage drop on the neutral conductor between the service and the farthest subpanel. Excessive voltage drop indicates a high resistance connection or undersized conductor.4.
Investigate Lighting Circuit Issues (AFTER fixing the neutral/ground separation)
Isolate the Problem Circuits
If the intermittent continuity only occurs when certain lighting circuits are on, isolate those circuits by turning off their breakers one at a time. See if you can pinpoint a specific circuit that's causing the issue.
Check Lighting Fixture Wiring
Inspect the wiring in the lighting fixtures themselves, especially in the problem circuits. Look for:
Loose Connections
Tighten all wire connections.
Miswired Fixtures
Make sure the neutral and ground wires are connected to the correct terminals in the fixtures.
Ballast Issues (if applicable)
If you have fluorescent or LED fixtures with ballasts or drivers, a failing ballast can sometimes cause strange neutral behavior. Try replacing suspect ballasts.
Check Switches
Check the wiring at the light switches. Make sure that the neutral is not being switched, which is very dangerous.5.
Check Main Service Neutral Connections
Main Panel Connections
Even though you said they're tight, verify the tightness of the neutral connections in the main 800A service panel. Use a torque wrench to tighten to the manufacturer's specifications. A loose neutral here can cause a lot of problems.
Important Safety Considerations
Work De-Energized
The vast majority of this work should be done with the power OFF. Work on live circuits only when absolutely necessary (for voltage testing), and use extreme caution. Use proper PPE (Personal Protective Equipment).
Qualified Electrician
If you're not comfortable working with electrical systems, hire a qualified and licensed electrician. Electrical work can be dangerous, and improper wiring can create fire hazards and shock hazards.
Local Codes
Make sure your wiring complies with all applicable local electrical codes.
Lockout/Tagout
Before working on any electrical equipment, use proper lockout/tagout procedures to ensure that the power cannot be accidentally turned on.
Why the Continuity Sounds Intermittent
Your multimeter is likely showing an intermittent connection because: Loose Connection
A loose connection is vibrating or moving slightly when the lights are turned on, causing the resistance to change.
Voltage/Current Dependence
A failing component (e.g., ballast) might be creating a small voltage or current leak between neutral and ground only when it's energized. Your meter is detecting this.
In Summary
Start by addressing the fundamental problem of neutral-ground bonding in your subpanels. Once that's corrected, you can then focus on the intermittent issue in the lighting circuits. Be methodical, prioritize safety, and consider hiring a qualified electrician if you're unsure. Good luck! Flag for review