User: shawnbebout, Location: Henrico County, VA
Asked on: Tuesday, October 8, 2024 at 8:56 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:38 am EST
Question: Ok. So I am a facilities electrician at a company. We have a “group” of buildings we have added onto to make 1 big building. Each addition has a different address for the service. 7070, 7060, 7040.No wires go in between buildings except fire alarm wires. The maintenance manager now wants to run a branch circuit between 7060 and 7040. The circuit will originate in 7040 and supply a work station in 7060.We are pretty much out of power in 7060. The last load study I did revealed about 100 amp available on the 7060 buss bar, so he wants to bring it from the other building.I’m not real fond of this idea, cause it will create a precedent going forward and we will have all kinds of branch circuits ran between buildings and it’s going to be a mess.Is there a code article against this?Thinking building supplies via another service would limit how many circuits could go in between.
You're right to be concerned. Running branch circuits between separately addressed buildings, even if they are physically connected, is generally not a good idea and can create a number of code and safety compliance issues. Here's a breakdown of the relevant concerns and code considerations
Key Concerns:
Safety
You're creating a potential for voltage differences between the grounding systems of the two buildings. This can lead to circulating currents, increased ground fault hazards, and potentially shock hazards.
Code Compliance
As you suspect, several NEC (National Electrical Code) sections address this, though not always explicitly prohibiting it in every scenario. It's more about what's required if you do it, making it expensive and complex.
Overcurrent Protection
You'll need to coordinate overcurrent protection devices across the two buildings. A fault in the workstation at 7060 needs to be reliably cleared by the breaker in 7040, and this might be difficult to achieve without causing nuisance trips.
Future Expansion/Modification
As you correctly predicted, it opens the door for more inter-building circuits, making troubleshooting and future modifications much harder. You'll have to track circuits originating in one building and feeding loads in another.
Documentation and Labeling
Accurate and up-to-date circuit directories and labeling become absolutely critical to avoid confusion and potential hazards.
Voltage Drop
Depending on the distance, you could experience excessive voltage drop, impacting the performance of the workstation equipment.
Relevant NEC Code Sections (Consult the latest NEC edition)
225.30 Number of Supplies. A building or other structure shall be supplied by only one feeder or branch circuit unless permitted in 225.30(A) through (E). Where more than one feeder or branch circuit supplies a building or other structure, one of the following shall be used. 225.32 Disconnecting Means. Buildings or other structures supplied by feeders or branch circuits shall have a means for disconnecting all ungrounded conductors from all sources of supply. The disconnecting means shall be installed at a readily accessible location either inside or outside of the building or structure served. 250.32 Buildings or Structures Supplied by a Feeder(s) or Branch Circuit(s). This section deals with the grounding and bonding requirements for buildings supplied by feeders or branch circuits. It essentially requires a grounding electrode system at each building, connected to the grounded conductor or equipment grounding conductor. 300.3(B) Conductors of the Same Circuit. All conductors of the same circuit and, where used, the grounded conductor and all equipment grounding conductors and bonding conductors shall be contained within the same raceway, auxiliary gutter, cable tray, cablebus assembly, trench, cable, or cord.
Why This is Problematic
Grounding Differences
NEC 250.32 is a big hurdle. Each building is likely grounded independently with its own grounding electrode system (ground rods, etc.). Running a branch circuit between them creates a potential path for circulating ground currents if there are even slight voltage differences between the grounding systems.
Disconnecting Means
NEC 225.32 requires a disconnecting means at each building. If the circuit originates in 7040, how will you provide a readily accessible disconnecting means for that circuit at 7060? You would need to install a fused disconnect or breaker at the workstation location in 7060 that can shut off that specific branch circuit.
Number of Supplies
NEC 225.30 is what you are looking for. It only allows for a limited number of situations where multiple supplies are allowed.
Possible (But Usually Impractical) Solutions (That Meet Code)
If you were forced to do this, the only way to do it safely and to meet code would be:1.
Thorough Grounding and Bonding
Ensure very robust grounding and bonding between the two buildings. This might involve running a substantial grounding electrode conductor (GEC) between the grounding electrode systems of the buildings. You would want an engineer to design this.2.
Proper Overcurrent Protection
Select an overcurrent protection device that meets code requirements for interrupting capacity and that has proper coordination between the buildings. A fuse might be the best option for selective coordination.3.
Install a Disconnecting Means
Install a readily accessible disconnecting means for the branch circuit at the 7060 location.4.
Documentation and Labeling
Document everything clearly on electrical drawings and label all panels and disconnects.5.
Consider a Feeder
Instead of a branch circuit, you could consider installing a feeder from 7040 to 7060 and then installing a new subpanel at 7060. This would still require careful grounding and bonding and adherence to NEC 250.
32.
Recommended Action
Strongly Advise Against It
Explain to the maintenance manager the code complications, safety concerns, and potential future problems associated with running branch circuits between buildings. Emphasize the importance of maintaining separate electrical systems for each address.2.
Explore Alternatives
Re-evaluate the Load Study
Are there any non-essential loads in 7060 that could be reduced or moved to free up capacity?
Energy Efficiency
Can more energy-efficient equipment be installed in 7060 to reduce the overall load?
Panel Upgrade
If the buss bar has ampacity available, can you upgrade or expand the panelboard at 7060 to provide more circuit capacity?
Load Shedding
If peak demand is the issue, consider implementing a load shedding system to prioritize essential loads.
Service Upgrade
The best, but most expensive, solution is to upgrade the service at 7060 to provide more capacity.3.
If Forced to Proceed (Discouraged)
If, despite your advice, management insists on running the circuit, insist on getting a qualified electrical engineer involved. They can assess the situation, design a code-compliant system, and ensure that all safety requirements are met. This will likely involve significant costs for engineering, materials, and labor.4.
Document Everything: Document your concerns in writing and keep a record of all decisions and justifications. This will protect you in the event of a future problem.In short, running branch circuits between separately addressed buildings should be avoided if at all possible. It introduces significant complexity, potential safety hazards, and code compliance challenges. Exploration of alternative solutions within 7060 is the best course of action. Flag for review