Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Solar, Subpanels and Breakers

User: spacemancw, Location: California

Asked on: Wednesday, October 9, 2024 at 12:51 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:39 am EST

Question: I have 2 questions, about my current set up and future setup.1.)I have 28 x 305W solar panels going into a SolarEdge 7600H grid-tied inverter.The Inverter comes into the main panel on a 40a breaker, which sits in the very bottom slot of the busbar.I also have sub-panel, ( HOM1224L125PC rated 125a ) that comes off the main panel. I have a 2-pole 100a breaker in the main panel feeding that sub-panel, over 3AWG wire.My first question is, does the position of that 100a breaker in the main, matter?Currently from the top down I have :200a main breaker,30a (incoming gas generator, in off position with interlock switch)50a to barn and pool equipment100a to sub-panela few more breakersetcetclastly, the 40a Solar.I was wondering if the sub-panel should be further down, or right above the solar breaker.2.)My next question would render the first moot, if I go this way.I am considering getting battery backup for the solar and doing AC coupling.So the SolarEdge inverter would come into the sub-panel .. or in this case we'll call it a critical loads panel.As I said that panel is rated 125a.Then from the critical loads panel to a new hybrid inverter (EG12kpv), and then from the new inverter to the main panel.And then batteries hanging off the EG12k.So that new hybrid inverter would enter the main panel on a 40a breaker (8 AWG I think) because the 120% rule would still apply to the main breaker.My question is can I feed the SolarEdge into the Critical loads panel on a 40a breaker?28 x 305W Solar Panels > SE 7600H > 40a breaker > Critical Loads Panel (Rated 125amps) > EG12k > 40a breaker > Main Panel (Rated 200amps) <> GridNote: at this point that 3AWG wire from the subpanel to the 100a breaker in the main panel, would no longer be in play and I would take away the gas generator input from the main panel.

Okay, let's break down your questions about your current and future solar setup.1. Sub-Panel Breaker Position in Main Panel

Yes, the position of the 100A breaker feeding your sub-panel in the main panel can matter, particularly in older panels and based on the way the busbar is designed. The reason is voltage drop.Here's why: Busbar Loading

Busbars are designed to carry current effectively, but all conductors have
some resistance. The farther you are from the main breaker's connection point, the potential for slightly lower voltage increases. This is usually negligible in modern panels, but...

Heat Generation

Heavy, sustained loads (like a 100A sub-panel feed) generate heat. Heat can impact breaker performance and lifespan, although modern breakers are very good at mitigating this.

Manufacturer Instructions

Some panels have explicit instructions about breaker placement for high-current loads. It's
always a good idea to check the labeling on the panel itself or the manufacturer's documentation.

The 120% Rule

The

NEC 705.12(B)(2)(3)(a)
states that the sum of all overcurrent devices (Breakers) supplying power to a busbar or conductor in a panel cannot exceed the busbar or conductor's rating by more than 20%. This applies to the location where the solar breaker is placed. In your setup, this means you would apply the rule here.(Main Breaker Amps + Solar Breaker Amps) / (120%) > Main Breaker Amps(200 Amps + 40 Amps) / 1.2 > 200 Amps240/1.2 = 200 This passes.

Recommendations for Existing Setup


Check Panel Documentation

This is the most important step. See if your panel's documentation specifies any restrictions on high-current breaker placement. It might have diagrams showing preferred layouts.2.

Move the Sub-Panel Breaker (Potentially)

Assuming there are no manufacturer restrictions, moving the 100A breaker closer to the main breaker can potentially improve performance and longevity (although the impact might be small). Moving it right above the solar breaker won't necessarily improve the situation. You'd want it as high in the busbar as possible (closest to the main breaker). However, consider the physical layout and ease of wiring. Don't compromise safety or neatness for a marginal theoretical benefit.3.

Monitor Voltage

Use a multimeter to monitor the voltage at the sub-panel under heavy load. If the voltage is consistently low, that's a stronger indication that breaker placement is contributing to the issue.

2. AC Coupling with Battery Backup


Okay, let's analyze your proposed AC-coupled battery backup setup.

Your Diagram

28 x 305W Solar Panels > SE 7600H > 40a breaker > Critical Loads Panel (Rated 125amps) > EG12k > 40a breaker > Main Panel (Rated 200amps) <> Grid

Key Considerations and Answers



Feeding SolarEdge into Critical Loads Panel

Yes, you can feed the SolarEdge 7600H into the critical loads panel using a 40A breaker. This is a common and valid approach for AC coupling.

Breaker Size

You have correctly sized the breaker for the 7600H.


Critical Loads Panel Sizing

Your critical loads panel must be sized appropriately to handle the combined load of the SolarEdge inverter output, the EG12k output, and all the critical loads you intend to power. Do a careful load calculation to ensure the 125A rating is sufficient.



EG12k Breaker in Main Panel

Yes, your 40A breaker and 8 AWG wire for the EG12k to the main panel is appropriate,
assuming the EG12k manufacturer specifies those sizes. This is mainly to protect the conductors.

NEC 705.12(B)(2)(3)(a) for SubPanel: The

NEC 705.12(B)(2)(3)(a) must also apply to the subpanel where the solar enters. Using the same formula.(Main Breaker Amps + Solar Breaker Amps) / (120%) > Main Breaker Amps(125 Amps + 40 Amps) / 1.2 > 125 Amps165/1.2 = 137.5 This passes.

Important Points and Recommendations


EG12k Sizing and Configuration

Crucially, make sure the EG12k is appropriately sized for your battery bank and your desired level of backup power. Understand its peak and continuous output capabilities. Consult the manufacturer's documentation for the correct breaker and wire sizes for all connections.2.

Battery Bank Sizing

Properly size your battery bank to meet your backup power needs. Consider the load of the devices you want to run during an outage and the desired duration of backup power.3.

Anti-Islanding Protection

The EG12k must have proper anti-islanding protection to prevent it from energizing the grid during an outage. This is a critical safety requirement. The EG12k will handle this aspect as it is specifically designed for grid-tied battery backup systems.4.

Permitting and Inspections

AC-coupled battery backup systems are complex. Obtain all necessary permits from your local authorities and schedule inspections to ensure the system is installed safely and correctly.5.

Professional Installation

While you can DIY this, I strongly recommend hiring a qualified and licensed electrician and/or solar installer with experience in AC-coupled battery backup systems. Mistakes can be costly and dangerous.6.

EG12k Placement: The EG12k should be installed in a way that is easy to cool.

In summary: Your proposed AC-coupled setup is feasible. Ensure you are calculating the correct breaker sizes and applying the 120% rule. Carefully size all components (especially the battery bank and the EG12k), follow all manufacturer instructions, and prioritize safety. This is a complex project, and professional assistance is highly recommended. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question