Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Both lamps don’t come on in fixture

User: ItsFrank, Location: California

Asked on: Wednesday, October 9, 2024 at 1:24 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:41 am EST

Question: I have a 2 lamp (LED) fixture where one lamp doesn’t come on. I can put both lamps in the locked position but only one will work. If I unlock one, the other will work vise versa, doesn’t matter left or right. I checked all the connections and replaced the old 120-277v ballast with a like for like but I can only get one lamp to work at a time. WTH?

Okay, this is a frustrating problem, but let's troubleshoot it systematically. Since you've already replaced the ballast and checked the connections, we need to dig a little deeper. Here's a breakdown of potential causes and how to investigate them

1. The LED Lamps Themselves (Even if They Look Fine):
The Most Likely Culprit

Even new LEDs can be faulty. The behavior you describe – one works when the other is out, and vice versa – strongly suggests that one of the LED lamps has a partial short or an internal fault that's affecting the circuit when both are connected.


Test

This is crucial:

Try a Known Good LED

Borrow or buy a completely new, known-good LED lamp of the correct type (voltage and base). Try it in each socket, one at a time, in combination with
your existing lamps. This will quickly isolate if one of your lamps is the issue.

If you have multiple fixtures

Test your LED lamps in a different fixture to see if the problem follows the lamp.

2. The Lamp Sockets (Tombstones/Lampholders)



Possible, but Less Likely After Ballast Change

Although you replaced the ballast, there might be an issue with the tombstones themselves that weren't apparent initially.


Check for Damage

Carefully inspect each tombstone for: Cracks or breaks in the plastic housing. Loose or corroded wiring connections where the wires attach to the tombstone. Even though you checked connections, inspect the tombstone connection points specifically.

Burn marks or discoloration, which indicate overheating.
Bent or damaged contacts inside the tombstone where the LED lamp pins connect.


Voltage Test (Requires Caution and a Multimeter)

If you're comfortable and competent working with electricity (and

DISCONNECT THE POWER FIRST before working on the fixture,
test that it is disconnected, then proceed), you can check for voltage at each tombstone with one LED lamp installed and working. Then, swap the LED lamps and check the other tombstone. Look for a significant voltage difference.

Tombstone Replacement (If Necessary)

If a tombstone looks damaged or the voltage test is off, replace it. Make sure you get the correct type for your LED lamps.

3. Wiring (Beyond Basic Connection Checks)



Neutrals

A shared neutral that is not properly connected can cause very odd behavior. Make sure the neutral wire feeding the fixture is tightly connected at both ends (the fixture itself and the connection upstream in the circuit).


Internal Wiring in the Fixture



Look for Shorts

Even though you inspected connections,
carefully trace each wire within the fixture, looking for any points where the insulation might be damaged and a wire could be shorting to the fixture body or another wire. Pay special attention to areas where wires are bent or pass through metal housings.

Wire Gauge

Confirm that the wire gauge used in the fixture is adequate for the current draw of the LED lamps. (This is unlikely to be the problem unless someone has modified the wiring previously.)

4. The New Ballast



Rare, but Possible

Even though it's "like for like," a brand-new ballast could be faulty. It's less likely since you replaced it, but still consider this.


Confirm Correct Ballast Type

Double-check that the ballast you installed is absolutely the correct type for the LED lamps you're using. The voltage and current requirements must match. A mismatch can cause all sorts of strange issues.

Return for Testing/Replacement

If all else fails, consider returning the ballast for testing or replacement.

Troubleshooting Steps (in Order of Likelihood/Ease)


Start with the LED Lamps

This is the easiest and most likely solution. Test with known good LED lamps.2.

Inspect the Tombstones

Thorough visual inspection for damage and loose connections.3.

Check Neutral Connections

Ensure a solid neutral connection.4.

Examine Internal Wiring

Look for shorts and damage.5.

Voltage Test at Tombstones (If Comfortable and Safe)

This can help pinpoint a bad tombstone or wiring issue.6.

Consider the Ballast (Last Resort)

Double-check the type and consider replacement.

Important Safety Notes



Always Disconnect Power

Before working on any electrical fixture, always disconnect the power at the circuit breaker.

Test with a non-contact voltage tester to confirm the power is off.

If Unsure, Hire an Electrician:
* If you're not comfortable working with electricity, or if you've tried these steps and still can't find the problem, it's best to call a qualified electrician.Good luck! Let me know what you find as you go through these steps. The more information you give me, the better I can help. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question