Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 3 Temporary generators one service

User: Moosifer, Location: Panama City Beach, FL

Asked on: Wednesday, October 9, 2024 at 3:30 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:41 am EST

Question: Customer has 3 non fused disconnects from a single utility feed. 200a, 200a, 100a. 240v single phase.They want to be able to run 3 temporary generators.... one for each.If I replace the disconnects with fused double throw switches (manual transfer switches) and give them what they need to power up with 3 different generators will they have an issue with the floating neutrals with 3 non-synchronized generators? Do they need to be separately derived systems with switched neutrals bonded in the generators and the generators grounded to earth? It seems like sharing the existing service neutral/ground will be an issue.

You've identified a potential problem, and your thinking is on the right track. Running three separate generators without proper isolation and handling of neutrals will likely cause issues. Here's a breakdown of the concerns and the steps needed to address them

The Problem: Multiple Generators and Floating Neutrals
Neutral Bonding and Grounding

Generators can be either separately derived systems or non-separately derived systems. A separately derived system has its neutral bonded to ground
at the generator. A non-separately derived system does NOT bond the neutral at the generator, and instead relies on the existing service neutral to provide the return path.

The Existing Service

The existing service likely has a single neutral-to-ground bond at the main service disconnect.

Conflict

If you simply connect three generators (especially if they are not designed to be paralleled) to the existing system
without switching the neutral, you create a situation where there are multiple potential paths for neutral current. This can lead to circulating currents in the grounding system, voltage imbalances, and potential equipment damage.

Floating Neutrals (Misnomer)

The issue isn't that the neutrals are truly "floating" in the sense of being completely ungrounded. The problem is where they are bonded to ground, and the fact that there can be multiple bonds.

Solution: Separately Derived Systems (SDS) with Switched Neutrals


The safest and most reliable approach is to treat each generator as a separately derived system (SDS) when it's powering its respective load. This means:1. Double-Throw Switches (with Switched Neutrals)

You are correct to use double-throw switches. Crucially, these switches

must switch the neutral
along with the two hot legs. This completely isolates the generator's neutral from the utility neutral when the generator is in use. These are often referred to as "transfer switches with switched neutrals."2. Neutral-Ground Bond at the Generator

Each generator

must have a neutral-to-ground bond
within the generator itself (usually factory installed). This is what defines it as a separately derived system. Consult the generator's manual to confirm this bond exists.3. Grounding to Earth

Each generator

must be properly grounded to earth
according to local codes. This is typically done with a grounding electrode conductor (GEC) connected to a grounding electrode (ground rod, water pipe, etc.). This connection must be properly sized for the generator. This provides a low-impedance path for fault current to return to the generator, tripping the generator's breaker.

Why this works



Isolation

Switching the neutral ensures that only one neutral-to-ground bond exists at any given time: either the utility's bond when on utility power, or the generator's bond when on generator power.


Defined Path

Each generator, when active, has its own, defined neutral-to-ground bond and ground fault return path. This prevents circulating currents and ensures proper operation of overcurrent protection.

Important Considerations & Code Compliance



Local Codes

Always consult with the local electrical inspector to ensure your installation complies with all applicable codes and regulations. They may have specific requirements for generator installations.


Generator Sizing

Ensure the generators are sized appropriately for the loads they will be powering.

Wiring and Conduit

Use appropriately sized conductors and conduit for all connections, following NEC guidelines.


Labeling

Clearly label all equipment, including the transfer switches, generators, and grounding connections.

Professional Installation

It is strongly recommended to have this work performed by a licensed and qualified electrician who is experienced with generator installations. Improper wiring can be dangerous and could damage equipment.


Interlock

Ensure the double throw switches have an interlock to prevent both sources from being connected at the same time.

Example Scenario

Let's say you have the 200A generator connected. When the 200A transfer switch is in the "generator" position: The utility feed is completely disconnected (including the neutral). The generator's neutral is bonded to ground at the generator. The generator is grounded to earth. The generator now powers the loads connected to that 200A panel as a separately derived system.

In summary: Replace the non-fused disconnects with fused double-throw transfer switches that switch the neutral, ensure each generator has a neutral-to-ground bond inside the generator (check the manual), and ground each generator to earth. This creates three separately derived systems when running on generator power, avoiding the circulating current problems and providing a safe and reliable solution.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question