User: The electron man, Location: Nyc
Asked on: Wednesday, October 9, 2024 at 8:56 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:42 am EST
Question: Why dose an open service neutral create voltage on the grounding systemI get that current is returning and has no way back to the service neutral and get to the grounding system using the main bonding jumper, but the neutral in the main disconnect is still grounded so how dose this happen
You're on the right track! Here's a breakdown of why an open service neutral creates voltage on the grounding system, and why the fact that the neutral should be grounded at the service doesn't prevent the problem
The Core Problem: Current Needs a Return Path
In a properly functioning electrical system, current flows from the source (utility transformer) through the hot (ungrounded) conductor to the load, and then returns to the source via the neutral (grounded) conductor. The neutral is intentionally connected to ground at the service entrance (through the grounding electrode conductor and any supplementary electrodes). This creates a low-impedance return path for fault current, and provides a reference point for voltage stabilization. When the service neutral is open (broken/disconnected), the current cannot return to the source through its intended low impedance path. It must find another route.
How the Grounding System Becomes Involved
Impedance and Voltage Division
Think of household wiring as a series of resistors (lights, appliances, etc.) connected in parallel between the hot and neutral wires. Each load has some impedance. Because the neutral is open it is no longer connected to the electrical source2.
Parallel Paths
The grounding system (ground wires in circuits, metal conduit, grounding electrodes) offers an alternative, albeit higher-impedance, path back to the source.3.
Voltage Build-up
Because the grounding system now carries current (it shouldn't!), a voltage develops on it. The voltage is proportional to the amount of current flowing and the impedance of the ground path (Ohm's Law: V = I R).
Why the Grounded Neutral at the Service Doesn't Solve the Problem
The Point of the Bond is Lost
The main bonding jumper (MBJ) is the crucial connection between the neutral bus and the grounding system at the service entrance. It's supposed to ensure that the neutral and grounding system are at the same potential. With an open neutral upstream of that point (towards the utility), the neutral bus itself is not at the same potential as the utility neutral.
Effective Grounding vs. Broken Neutral
Yes, the neutral is technically "grounded" at your service panel. But if it's open further back on the utility side, that "ground" is isolated from the utility's ground. The open neutral creates a break in the low impedance return path, negating the benefits of grounding. The grounding system is now serving as the primary return path for some current, and a voltage is induced on it.
The Problem is Upstream
The key is that the break is between your service panel and the transformer supplying your power. Even though your grounding system is properly connected at your panel, it can't compensate for a missing or compromised connection to the source.
Consequences
Shock Hazard
Any conductive surface connected to the grounding system (appliance chassis, metal pipes) can become energized, posing a shock hazard.
Equipment Damage
Fluctuating or elevated voltage on the grounding system can damage sensitive electronic equipment.
Erratic Operation
Appliances and devices may malfunction due to voltage imbalances.
Fire Hazard
In extreme cases, excessive current flowing through the grounding system can cause overheating and potentially start a fire.
Analogy
Imagine a water pipe system. The utility is the reservoir, your house is the user, and the pipes are the conductors. The neutral is like the main drain pipe. If that main drain pipe is blocked (open neutral), water will find other paths to escape, possibly through smaller pipes or even through cracks in the foundation (grounding system). This can cause pressure buildup and potential damage.
Important Note: An open service neutral is a very dangerous situation.* It's crucial to immediately contact a qualified electrician and your utility company to investigate and repair the issue. Do not attempt to troubleshoot or fix it yourself unless you are a licensed electrician.In summary, even though the neutral is grounded at the main service panel, an open neutral further upstream prevents it from providing a proper return path for current, forcing current to flow through the grounding system and creating a dangerous voltage on it. Flag for review