User: RdmanElect, Location: Poughkeepsie NY
Asked on: Thursday, October 10, 2024 at 7:22 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:43 am EST
Question: Hey guys, I'm a working foreman at a fairly large electrical form. (100 employees)I have a project manager assigned to me. She's very nice but I find that I'm doing most of the managing, laying out the job, executing the work. She basically handles the paperwork, sets schedule and orders what I ask for. I'm a master electrician and make roughly 75k yearly. She does a fraction of my work load and needs me for my knowledge of code and efficiency in laying out the job in accordance to NEC. But she makes a lot more than me. I don't get it. And was looking for other people's input on what a project manager should be doing. Thanks!
Okay, this is a common frustration in the construction industry, especially in the electrical field. Let's break down the typical responsibilities of a Project Manager and how it should ideally work, and then address the discrepancy in your situation.
What a Project Manager Should Be Doing (Ideally)
Planning & Strategy
Overall Project Planning
The PM should be responsible for the big picture – creating the project plan, defining scope, setting goals and objectives, developing a work breakdown structure (WBS), and ensuring the project aligns with the overall company strategy.
Resource Allocation
Determining the required manpower, tools, and equipment needed for each phase of the project. They should be working proactively to anticipate needs, not just react to your requests.
Risk Management
Identifying potential risks (delays, material shortages, weather issues, code changes, etc.) and developing mitigation strategies.
Financial Management
Developing and managing the project budget, tracking costs, analyzing variances, and ensuring profitability. This includes change order management.
Communication & Coordination
Client Liaison
Primary point of contact for the client. Attending client meetings, managing expectations, and addressing concerns.
Team Coordination
Facilitating communication and collaboration between the field team (you and your crew), other trades, engineers, architects, and any other stakeholders.
Progress Reporting
Providing regular updates to the client, senior management, and the project team on project status, milestones achieved, and any challenges encountered.
Scheduling & Tracking
Developing the Project Schedule
Creating a detailed project schedule using software like MS Project or similar, and tracking progress against that schedule.
Critical Path Analysis
Identifying the critical path activities and ensuring they are on schedule to avoid delays.
Schedule Adjustments
Making adjustments to the schedule as needed to account for unforeseen delays or changes in scope.
Procurement & Logistics
Material Procurement
While you may specify what you need, the PM should be responsible for managing the procurement process, ensuring materials are ordered on time, delivered to the site, and properly stored.
Subcontractor Management
If subcontractors are involved, the PM should manage their work, ensure they are meeting their obligations, and coordinate their activities with the rest of the team.
Quality Control & Compliance
Ensuring Quality Standards
Working with you to ensure that the work is being performed to the required quality standards and in accordance with the contract documents.
Code Compliance
While you are the expert on the NEC, the PM should be aware of code requirements and ensure that all work is compliant.
Safety
Ensuring that safety protocols are being followed on the job site. This is often a shared responsibility with the foreman, but the PM has overall responsibility.
Problem Solving
Resolving Issues
Addressing and resolving any issues that arise during the project, whether they are technical, logistical, or personnel-related.
Change Order Management
Identifying and managing change orders, ensuring they are properly documented, priced, and approved.
Why Your Situation Might Be the Way It Is (and what to do about it)
Experience Level/Skills
Your PM might be new to the role, lack specific electrical experience, or simply not be a strong PM. Sometimes companies promote based on factors other than pure project management skills.2.
Company Culture
Some companies don't fully empower their PMs, or they may not value the role of the foreman as much as they should.3.
Over-Reliance on Foreman Expertise
The company might be heavily reliant on your expertise and assume you'll handle the on-the-ground management.4.
Poor Communication
The PM may not be communicating effectively with you, the client, or other stakeholders.5.
Overlapping Roles
There may be unclear boundaries between your role and the PM's role, leading to confusion and duplicated effort.6.
You're REALLY Good at Your Job
Honestly, sometimes the PM leans heavily on the experienced foreman because they trust your judgment and ability to get things done right. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it shouldn't mean you're doing their job.
What to Do About It
Have a Direct Conversation
The first step is to have a candid conversation with your project manager. Explain your concerns and ask for clarification on their responsibilities. Frame it as wanting to work together more effectively as a team. Examples: "I'm happy to provide my technical expertise on the code and layout, but I'm also spending a lot of time on tasks that I believe fall within the PM role, such as [specific examples]." "To ensure we're both contributing effectively, could we review our roles and responsibilities on this project? I want to make sure I'm focusing on what I do best."
Track Your Time
For a week or two, keep a detailed log of how you're spending your time. This will give you concrete data to support your concerns. It will also show you where you're spending time on things you shouldn't be.
Escalate to Your Supervisor (Strategically)
If the conversation with the PM doesn't lead to change, consider escalating your concerns to your supervisor or another senior manager. Present your case professionally, with data to back it up. Focus on how improved project management will benefit the company (e.g., increased efficiency, reduced costs, improved client satisfaction).
Negotiate Your Salary
Armed with your time tracking data and a clear understanding of your contributions to the project, you can make a strong case for a raise. Emphasize the value you bring to the company, your expertise in the NEC, and your ability to manage projects effectively. Point out that you are essentially performing duties beyond the scope of a typical foreman. If you're the only master electrician and doing all the inspections, your bargaining power increases.
Seek Training
If you're interested in moving into a PM role yourself, ask the company to provide you with training in project management skills. This could include courses in project planning, scheduling, budgeting, and risk management. PMP certification is a common goal.
Consider Other Opportunities
If the company isn't willing to recognize your contributions or provide opportunities for advancement, it may be time to consider other job opportunities. Your skills and experience are valuable, and you may be able to find a company that appreciates them more.
Regarding the Salary Discrepancy
Project Managers generally earn more than foremen because:
Higher Level of Responsibility
They are responsible for the overall success of the project, including financial performance, client satisfaction, and risk management.
Education & Experience
PMs often have a bachelor's degree in engineering, construction management, or a related field, and they may have certifications like PMP.
Strategic Role
They are involved in the strategic planning and decision-making for the project.
Overhead Cost
They are considered an overhead cost as they generally aren't doing billable work, but are necessary for the overall project.However, the salary difference should be commensurate* with the actual responsibilities being performed. If you are effectively doing the job of a PM in addition to your foreman duties, you have a strong argument for a raise. The value of a good foreman who understands the code and can efficiently execute the work is immense.
In Summary:
Don't assume the situation will change on its own. Be proactive, communicate your concerns, and document your contributions. You deserve to be compensated fairly for your work and to have a clear understanding of your role in the project team. Good luck! Flag for review