User: Dengineer, Location: new york
Asked on: Thursday, October 10, 2024 at 9:55 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:43 am EST
Question: Hello all,I am working on some service load summary calculations for a mixed use building and had a few questions.I currently have 3-phase 4 wire incoming service that will feeder a 3phase meter bank and single phase downstream residential panels.Now when sizing a service using the service load calculations are you just sizing the incoming service conductors or do you also size the service tap conductors. Lets say my service calculations for a meter bank and house panel are 260A and the commercial space is 95A. Now I want to remove the house panel from the meter bank and do a direct taps on a wire trough to the service conductors. Is the meter bank tapped at 300A or can I downsize to 250A because I removed the house load and will do a separate service tap. Note I am running the service conductors into a wire trough and service tapping for each space with no dedicated upstream disconnect, so everything would be a service tap instead of a feeder tap.
You're asking a great question that hinges on the definitions and application of the NEC. Let's break down the scenario and requirements
Key Definitions (NEC is king here):
Service Conductors
Conductors from the serving utility's point of connection to the service disconnecting means. In your case, these run from the utility drop/underground lateral to the wire trough.
Service Equipment
This usually includes the main disconnecting means, overcurrent protection (e.g., main breaker), and metering equipment. Your wire trough, by itself, is not service equipment unless it contains a main breaker.
Service Point Connection between the facilities of the serving utility and the premises wiring.
Understanding Your Scenario
You have:1.
Incoming Utility Service
3-phase, 4-wire.2.
Wire Trough (No Main Breaker)
This acts as a junction point/distribution point for your service taps.3.
Meter Bank (Serving Commercial Space)
This meters the commercial space and likely contains its own disconnect (but might not, see below).4.
House Panel
Initially fed from the meter bank, now to be fed by a direct tap from the wire trough.5.
Commercial Space
95A calculated load.6.
Meter Bank + House Panel
260A calculated load.7.
House Panel Alone
260A - 95A = 165A Calculated Load
Answering Your Question
Sizing the Incoming Service Conductors
These must be sized based on the total connected load served by them. Since the incoming service conductors feed everything (the wire trough, which then feeds the meter bank and the house panel), they MUST be sized to carry the
260A calculated load (95A for commercial + 165A for the house) as a minimum. This is because, at one point, they were required to feed both. NEC 230.42(A) Minimum Size and Rating. Service-entrance conductors shall have an ampacity not less than either (1) or (2). Sizing the Service Tap Conductors
This is where the flexibility (and careful code adherence) comes in. Since each tap now goes directly to a panel with its own overcurrent protection, you size the tap conductors based on the load they serve after the separation.
Tap to the Meter Bank (Commercial Space)
The tap conductors must have an ampacity not less than the calculated load (95A) and not less than the rating of the overcurrent protective device protecting the conductors. Therefore the minimum tap size required would be 100A. You can use a 100A overcurrent protective device.
Tap to the House Panel
The tap conductors must have an ampacity not less than the calculated load (165A) and not less than the rating of the overcurrent protective device protecting the conductors. Therefore the minimum tap size required would be 175A. You can use a 175A overcurrent protective device.
NEC 230.43 The wiring shall be protected from overcurrent in accordance with the requirements of 230.90. NEC 240.4 Protection of Conductors Conductors, other than flexible cords, flexible cables, and fixture wires, shall be protected against overcurrent in accordance with their ampacities specified in 310.15, unless otherwise permitted or required in 240.4(A) through (G).
Important Considerations and Code Sections
Service Disconnecting Means
Crucially, you must have a disconnecting means for each service (NEC 230.71) to disconnect all ungrounded service conductors simultaneously. Typically, this is a circuit breaker. Your setup implies no main disconnect before the wire trough. This means that the individual disconnects in the meter bank and house panel become the service disconnects for those respective loads.
NEC 230.71 Maximum Number of Disconnects. Each service shall have no more than six disconnecting means for each set of service-entrance conductors permitted by 230.40, Exception No. 1, 3, 4, or 5. NEC 230.40 Number of Service-Entrance Conductor Sets. Each service drop or lateral shall supply only one set of service-entrance conductors, except as permitted in 230.40, Exceptions No. 1 through 5. Overcurrent Protection (OCPD)
Each service tap must be protected by an OCPD. Given that your wire trough doesn't have an upstream disconnect, the first OCPD you encounter after the tap acts as the protection.
Taps to Service Conductors
These are allowed under specific conditions outlined in NEC 230.82(5)
NEC 230.82 Equipment Connected to the Supply Side of Service Disconnect - In addition to the equipment and meters specified in 230.81, other equipment shall be permitted to be connected to the supply side of the service disconnecting means where provided with overcurrent protection and means of disconnect.
In Summary
Incoming Service Conductors
Size for the total calculated load (260A).2.
Service Tap Conductors (Meter Bank)
Size for the calculated load (95A), but it must be protected by an OCPD not more than the ampacity of the conductors.3.
Service Tap Conductors (House Panel)
Size for the calculated load (165A), but it must be protected by an OCPD not more than the ampacity of the conductors.4.
Confirm Disconnect/OCPD
Make absolutely sure each service (meter bank and house panel) has a readily accessible service disconnect and OCPD as close to the tap as possible. This arrangement puts greater importance on the individual disconnects in each panel.5.
Local Codes and AHJ
Always consult your local electrical codes and the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ). They may have specific requirements or interpretations of the NEC.6.
Safety and Professional Installation
Electrical work can be dangerous. Always hire a qualified electrician for installation and inspection.
Example
Let's say you use 300 kcmil copper conductors for the main service (ampacity 320A). You could then use a 1/0 copper conductor (150A ampacity, protected by a 150A breaker) for the tap to the house panel, and a #3 copper conductor (100A ampacity, protected by a 100A breaker) for the meter bank tap.
Recommendation
While this configuration is potentially compliant with the NEC, consider the following:
Future Expansion
Is there any chance of adding load to either the commercial space or the house? Oversizing the taps slightly now could save you money later.
Main Disconnect
Consider adding a main disconnect before the wire trough. This would be the cleanest and arguably safest approach. You'd then have feeder taps instead of service taps which have some additional requirements.Good luck with your project! Again, consult with a qualified electrician to ensure code compliance and safe installation.
Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide professional electrical engineering or code compliance advice. This information is for general educational purposes only. Consult with a licensed electrician for all electrical work.* Flag for review