User: binwork91, Location: new york
Asked on: Thursday, October 10, 2024 at 3:01 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:44 am EST
Question: If I connect 1230A load to the 1200A MES298 CT with (1) 1/4"x5" copper bus. Is this C.T. undersize?I mean it is 1200A C.T, connect to 1230A load, it sounds like undersize.However, the bus ampacity is 1250A, it is good for 1230A load.What about 800A trans-s feed 830A load? I do not know the bus size in the trans-s. Do I need to measure the bus size to determine if it is good or not? I never see a trans-s provide the bus size in the cutsheet.The reason I ask if per NYC local code.
Let's break down these scenarios and address your concerns
Scenario 1: 1230A Load with 1200A CT and 1/4" x 5" Copper Bus
CT Undersizing
Yes, the CT (Current Transformer) is technically undersized. A CT should be rated for at least the maximum expected load current. In your case, the load is 1230A, and the CT is rated for 1200A. This means the CT will be operating beyond its designed capacity, which can lead to inaccurate readings and potential damage over time.
Bus Ampacity
While the 1/4" x 5" copper bus has an ampacity of 1250A, which is sufficient for the 1230A load, it doesn't negate the CT undersizing issue. The bus can handle the current, but the CT is the bottleneck in the measurement chain.
NYC Code
NYC electrical code will likely require the CT to be appropriately sized for the load. Undersizing can be a violation and could lead to issues during inspection.
Conclusion for Scenario 1
You need to replace the 1200A CT with a CT that is rated for at least 1230A, preferably a bit higher (e.g., 1500A) to provide a safety margin and account for potential future load increases. The fact that the bus is appropriately sized is good, but it doesn't solve the CT problem.
Scenario 2: 800A Transformer Feeding 830A Load Transformer Overload
Yes, you are exceeding the transformer's nameplate rating. While transformers can sometimes handle short-term overloads, continuously running an 800A transformer at 830A is generally not recommended and can significantly shorten its lifespan.
Bus Bar Importance
Whether or not the bus bars inside the trans-s can handle the 830A is absolutely critical. Transformers are designed with specific bus bar configurations to carry the rated current. Overloading the bus bars can lead to overheating, insulation breakdown, and ultimately transformer failure.
Finding Bus Bar Information
You are correct; transformer cut sheets rarely explicitly state the bus bar ampacity. Here's how to proceed:1.
Contact the Manufacturer
The best approach is to contact the transformer manufacturer (or distributor). Provide them with the transformer's serial number and nameplate information. They should be able to provide you with the internal bus bar ampacity.2.
Review the Transformer Specifications
Look carefully at the transformer's documentation for any clues about its overload capacity or temperature rise characteristics. This might give you some insight into the design margin.3.
Consult a Qualified Electrical Engineer
This is the recommended approach. An engineer can assess the transformer's design, potential limitations, and make a safe recommendation based on the actual load conditions and NYC code requirements.
NYC Code
Similar to the CT situation, NYC electrical code will likely prohibit overloading the transformer. Overloading can be a safety hazard.
Conclusion for Scenario 2
Most Likely Needs Upgrade
An 800A transformer feeding an 830A load is almost certainly overloaded and needs to be addressed.2.
Determine Bus Bar Capacity
You must determine the ampacity of the transformer's internal bus bars. Contact the manufacturer or consult an engineer. Do not assume they can handle the overload.3.
Consider Options
You'll likely need to: Upgrade the transformer to a larger size. Reduce the load on the transformer. Implement load management strategies to ensure the load never exceeds the transformer's rating.
General Advice (for both scenarios)
Consult with a Licensed Electrical Engineer
Especially in NYC, with its specific and strict electrical codes, you should consult with a licensed electrical engineer experienced in local codes and commercial/industrial power systems. They can perform load calculations, assess the existing infrastructure, and recommend solutions that meet both code requirements and safety standards.
Conservative Approach
It's always best to err on the side of caution when dealing with electrical systems. Avoid pushing components to their absolute limits. Providing a safety margin will improve reliability and longevity.
Documentation is Key
Keep detailed records of all equipment specifications, load calculations, and any modifications made to the electrical system. This will be helpful for future maintenance and inspections.
Safety First: Electrical work can be dangerous. Always de-energize equipment before working on it and follow proper safety procedures.In summary, both scenarios raise concerns about undersized components. You need to address the CT undersizing and investigate the transformer overloading situation, prioritizing safety and compliance with NYC electrical code. Consulting with an electrical engineer is highly recommended. Flag for review