Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Wet Locations

User: hyattjay, Location: CO.

Asked on: Thursday, October 10, 2024 at 5:30 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:45 am EST

Question: I am having a rather deep dive discussion with a non-electrical engineer regarding NEC wet locations:"where exposed to weather" is one of the specific definitions I recall in defining a wet location.In our discussion, I pointed out that an aerial installation (on a messenger or not) would be or could be defined as a wet location.Further on in the conversation, it was asked if a TC-ER cable listed for aerial installation, though not specifically indicated for use in a wet location is contradictory, since by the listing as tray rated, exposed or extended run or in an aerial install, the cable would or could be exposed to weather. Since the cable maybe listed for use in direct sunlight, is moisture resistant and chemically resistant and listed for aerial installation, how does one determine the suitability of wet vs. dry locations? Where is the line?What if the manufacturer states, dry locations, and also states aerial installation, and suitable for all approved raceways, no direct burial?I reviewed Article 336.10(c) and ticked positive or compliant for all of the applicable aspects for 336.10 (1) through (7) a. through g, (8), (9), the exceptions and (10) - based on our hypothetical cable type (UL listed TC-ER, dry locations, 90C, Fire resistant - 2hrs @2000F + other flame test, sunlight, moisture, chemically resistant, installed in cable tray & RMC, no direct burial or aerial aspects of the installation, industrial area serviced by qualified personnel only, no public access - highly controlled site, cable not exposed to physical damage and fully supported every 6ft.)Thoughts, comments? Is my point all wet? (no pun intended.)

You've raised a really interesting and nuanced point about the interpretation of "wet location" versus the practical realities of aerial cable installations. Here's a breakdown of the issues and how I see it, keeping in mind I am an AI and not a certified electrical inspector

Key Considerations:
NEC Definition of Wet Location

The NEC defines a wet location broadly, encompassing "installations under ground or in concrete slabs or masonry in direct contact with the earth; locations subject to saturation with water or other liquids, such as vehicle washing areas; and

unprotected locations exposed to weather
." This last part is what makes the aerial installation a gray area.
Cable Listings & Intended Use

The listing of a cable (TC-ER, etc.) dictates its allowable uses. A "dry location only" listing from the manufacturer is a

hard stop
. Even if it's sunlight resistant, moisture resistant, and chemically resistant, the manufacturer is explicitly prohibiting its use in wet locations. This overrides any perceived suitability based on its other properties. Contradictory Manufacturer Statements

A manufacturer stating "dry locations only" AND "aerial installation" IS inherently contradictory and should raise a HUGE red flag.

This alone is a reason to reject the cable.
Reputable manufacturers would never knowingly list a cable in such a conflicting manner. It suggests a potential error in their documentation or, worse, a misunderstanding of the NEC requirements.
"Exposed to Weather" vs. Actual Wetness

This is the crux of your discussion. While an aerial installation is exposed to weather (sun, wind, rain, snow), the question is:

Does the cable become saturated with water or experience conditions that would classify it as a wet location according to the NEC's intent?
This is a judgment call, but the manufacturer's "dry location only" label closes that door. Article 336.10 Compliance

While you might be able to argue compliance with various subsections of 336.10 regarding support, physical damage, and qualified personnel, the
fundamental problem is the manufacturer's limitation to "dry locations." The NEC permits uses; it doesn't allow you to bypass a manufacturer's limitations.

Analysis of Your Points


Aerial Installation as Wet Location

You are correct that an aerial installation
can be considered a wet location based on the "exposed to weather" definition. However, this is not an automatic determination. The degree of exposure and the cable's ability to withstand those conditions are relevant.2.

TC-ER Cable Contradiction

The contradiction you identified between the aerial listing and the "dry location only" is significant. It points to a problem with the cable's intended use or the manufacturer's understanding of the application.3.

Suitability Factors (Sunlight, Moisture, Chemical Resistance)

These properties are beneficial, but they
do not override a "dry location only" listing. The manufacturer has explicitly stated the cable is not suitable for wet environments, regardless of its other resistances.4.

NEC 336.10 Checklist

While you can tick all the boxes for 336.10 compliance in terms of installation methods,
the cable itself must be suitable for the location. The "dry location only" negates this suitability.5.

Controlled Industrial Environment

The fact that the site is controlled and only accessible to qualified personnel does
not change the NEC requirements regarding location suitability. While qualified personnel can perform installations properly, they cannot override the cable's listing.

The Line

The line is drawn by the

cable's listing
. If the manufacturer says "dry locations only," you cannot use it in a location that could be reasonably classified as wet, even if it seems resistant to the elements.

Your Point: Is it All Wet?

Yes, it is likely wet!Conclusion

While you've correctly identified the complexities of applying the NEC definition of "wet location" to aerial installations, the

manufacturer's "dry location only" specification is the deciding factor.
You cannot use this cable in an aerial installation exposed to weather, regardless of its other properties or installation practices.

Recommendations



Consult the Manufacturer

If there's any ambiguity, contact the cable manufacturer directly for clarification. Ask them to explain the contradiction in their documentation and confirm whether the cable is suitable for your application. Get it in writing.

Choose a Cable Listed for Wet Locations

The simplest and safest solution is to select a TC-ER cable (or other appropriate cable type) that is explicitly listed for use in wet locations and aerial installations. This eliminates any ambiguity and ensures compliance with the NEC. Look for markings like "Wet," "Sunlight Resistant and Wet," or "Suitable for Wet Locations."


Seek Guidance from the AHJ:
Ultimately, the final decision rests with the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ). Discuss your proposed installation with them and get their approval before proceeding. They may have local interpretations or requirements that you need to consider.In short, don't try to force a cable into an application it's not listed for. The potential consequences (safety risks, code violations, warranty issues) are not worth it. Use the right cable for the job! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question