Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: LS Electric / Susol Breakers

User: jstpie5, Location: Baton Rouge

Asked on: Thursday, October 10, 2024 at 6:28 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:45 am EST

Question: Anyone have experience with LS Electric / Susol breakers?They kinda look cheap to me but I’m really being pushed to bless them as the engineer on this project.I’m concerned about reliability, spare parts availability, warranty, and repairability. So I thought I’d turn to you crusty folks for any info.TIA - stay safe

You're right to be cautious and do your due diligence. Gut feelings, especially when coupled with visual impressions, can be surprisingly accurate in electrical work. Here's a breakdown of my experience and what I've gathered about LS Electric (formerly LG Industrial Systems, now LSIS) and their Susol breakers

Overall Impression:
Price Point

LS Electric is generally positioned as a cost-effective alternative to established brands like Schneider, ABB, Eaton (Cutler-Hammer), and Siemens. That lower price comes at some cost, though.


Performance

They can work, but don't expect them to be equivalent in performance to the top-tier brands. They are generally considered acceptable for standard applications, not for critical infrastructure or situations where downtime is extremely costly.

Concerns (you were right to bring these up)



Reliability

This is the biggest concern. Reports and anecdotal evidence suggest a higher failure rate compared to the leading brands. Expect a shorter lifespan and potentially more nuisance tripping.


Spare Parts Availability

This is a big one. While LS Electric is expanding its presence, spare parts availability in North America (if that's where you are) is not as robust as it is for established brands. You might find yourself waiting longer and paying more for replacements. Inventory is becoming more accessible, but your local distributor should be contacted to verify the ability to obtain common parts.

Warranty

Carefully review the warranty terms. Understand the process for making claims and how LS Electric handles replacements. The terms may be less generous than those offered by the big players.


Repairability

Most molded case circuit breakers (MCCBs) are not designed for field repair. The usual practice is to replace them. However, for larger air circuit breakers (ACBs), repair is sometimes an option. Check if LS Electric has authorized repair facilities in your area. The smaller players will frequently require you to send the breaker back to them, or even overseas.

Agency Listings

Ensure the breakers have the necessary UL (or equivalent) listings for your region and application. This is
essential for code compliance and safety. Verify all certifications independently, as counterfeit or improperly certified breakers can be a significant hazard.

Specific Experiences/Things to Consider



Trip Curves

Carefully review the trip curves to ensure they are appropriate for your application. Compare them to the trip curves of breakers you trust and have used successfully in the past. Pay attention to the instantaneous trip settings, which can be a source of nuisance tripping if not properly coordinated.

Construction Quality

Examine the breaker closely. Note the materials used, the fit and finish, and the overall build quality. Compare it to a breaker from a brand you trust. Do the terminals look robust? Are the markings clear and durable?


Short-Circuit Current Rating (SCCR)

Ensure the breakers have a sufficient SCCR for your application. This is a critical safety consideration. The SCCR must be greater than the available fault current at the point of installation. Don't cut corners here.

Supplier Reputation

Talk to other engineers and contractors in your area. See if they have used LS Electric breakers and get their honest feedback. Online reviews can be helpful, but take them with a grain of salt.


Application



Non-Critical Loads

If the breakers are for non-critical loads (lighting circuits, small motors, etc.) where downtime is not a major issue, LS Electric
might be acceptable, especially if the cost savings are significant.

Critical Loads

If the breakers are for critical loads (e.g., life safety systems, process control equipment, data centers), strongly consider using a more reliable brand. The cost of downtime far outweighs the initial cost savings on the breakers.

Coordination Studies

Any circuit breaker that you install should be considered in the light of its application to the other breakers in the system. If you are installing a breaker as the main device for a panel, you may also need to consider the branch circuit breakers and their let-through current in the event of a fault.

Recommendations


Document Your Concerns

Put your concerns in writing to the project manager and/or the client. Explain your concerns about reliability, spare parts, warranty, and repairability. Make it clear that you are not comfortable "blessing" a product that you believe could compromise the reliability and safety of the electrical system. Cover your rear.2.

Request Alternatives

Request quotes for comparable breakers from more established brands. Present the cost difference and explain the potential benefits of using a more reliable product.3.

Risk Assessment

Conduct a risk assessment that considers the potential consequences of breaker failures (e.g., downtime, equipment damage, safety hazards). Quantify the costs associated with these consequences and compare them to the cost savings of using LS Electric breakers.4.

Consult with LS Electric

Reach out to LS Electric's technical support team and ask them specific questions about their breakers. Ask about failure rates, spare parts availability, warranty coverage, and repair options. Get their answers in writing.5.

Don't Compromise on Safety

If you have serious concerns about the safety of the breakers, stand your ground. Your professional responsibility is to protect the public and ensure the safety of the electrical system.

In summary:
LS Electric can* be a viable option in some applications where cost is the primary driver, and reliability is not a major concern. However, for critical applications, it's generally best to stick with more established brands that have a proven track record of reliability, robust spare parts availability, and comprehensive support. Your caution is warranted, and you are doing the right thing by investigating thoroughly. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question