Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Bryant panel with split breaker

User: shalomfred, Location: Dillon Montana

Asked on: Thursday, October 10, 2024 at 11:48 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:45 am EST

Question: I cannot find a code on this, and electrically I do not know the right way to handle this; doing a remodel on a old house with a Bryant panel, they have three split breakers with three old 12-3 romax (no ground) coming off of the split breaker (Edison circuit); does it matter that both feeds derive from the same split breaker, no way to install two poll breaker for Edison circuit, no room

Okay, this is a common situation in older homes and requires careful consideration. Let's break down the issues and potential solutions

Understanding the Problem
Edison (Multi-Wire Branch Circuit) with No Ground

This is the core of the issue. An Edison circuit uses two hots (opposite phases, 120V each) and a shared neutral. In older wiring, it's common to find this done with 12/3 cable (black, red, white) where the white wire is the neutral.
Without a ground wire, you have a significant safety risk.



Split Breaker (Duplex Breaker)

A split breaker (or tandem breaker) puts two separate circuits in the space of a single breaker. Your situation of needing a two pole is a good indication that you have an Edison circuit.

No Space for Two-Pole Breaker

This is a significant constraint, especially in older, crowded panels.


Bryant Panel

Important to know the brand as it can limit breaker options.

Safety Concerns

The lack of grounding is the biggest safety concern. In the event of a short circuit to a metal enclosure, the lack of a ground wire can create a shock hazard instead of immediately tripping the breaker.

Why the Same Split Breaker is Potentially ProblematicUsing a split breaker for both hots of an Edison circuit could be a code violation and a safety hazard in many cases. Here's why:


Common Trip

The key advantage of a two-pole breaker in an Edison circuit is that if either hot leg overloads or faults, both legs trip. This is vital to prevent the neutral wire from becoming overloaded. When current flow in a multiwire branch circuit is unequal, then neutral current is created. If there is no overcurrent protection for the neutral in this situation, then the neutral can overheat and fail.

Accidental Overload of Neutral

The neutral wire in an Edison circuit carries the
difference in current between the two hot legs. If one hot leg is drawing a lot more current than the other, the neutral can become overloaded. With two independent single-pole breakers (even if they are a split breaker), there's nothing forcing both circuits to trip simultaneously in an overload situation.

Maintenance/Troubleshooting Confusion

If you need to work on one leg of the Edison circuit, turning off a single breaker may not fully de-energize the entire circuit.

Possible Solutions (Ranked from Best to Least Desirable)


Panel Upgrade (Ideal but Most Expensive)

Best Solution. If at all possible, upgrade the electrical panel. This is the safest and most code-compliant option. A new panel will provide: More space for breakers (including a two-pole breaker for the Edison circuit). A dedicated ground bus bar for proper grounding. Improved overall electrical safety. This is the most expensive and disruptive option, but it addresses the root of the problem.2.

AFCI/GFCI Breaker with Pigtail Neutral (If Permitted by Code and Breaker Type)

Consult a Qualified Electrician. Certain Arc-Fault Circuit Interrupter (AFCI) and Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter (GFCI) breakers (specifically designed for MWBC) are designed to work with shared neutrals. These breakers have a "pigtail" neutral wire that connects to the panel's neutral bus bar. They monitor the current on both hot legs and the neutral. If an imbalance (indicating a ground fault or arc fault) is detected, both legs trip.

Important



Compatibility

Not all AFCI/GFCI breakers are designed for MWBCs. You MUST use one specifically designed for this purpose.

Code Compliance

Check with your local electrical inspector to ensure this is permitted. Some jurisdictions may not allow this as a substitute for a two-pole breaker.

Grounding

This still does NOT address the lack of a ground wire in the Romex. It only provides arc-fault and ground-fault protection.3.

Identify One Hot Leg as a Lost Cause



Downsize

Disconnect one of the hot legs and cap it off. This effectively makes the Edison circuit into a standard 120V circuit.

Rewire

Rewire one circuit using 12/2 Romex with Ground.
This reduces the load on the remaining circuit, but it may not be a practical solution if you need the full capacity of the Edison circuit. It's a last resort if other options are not possible.4.

Neutral Monitoring Relay (Advanced Solution, Requires Expertise)

For Experienced Electricians Only. A neutral monitoring relay can be installed to detect an overloaded neutral. If an overload is detected, the relay can be configured to trip both breakers feeding the Edison circuit. This is a more complex solution and requires a good understanding of electrical circuits and controls.

Important Considerations and Steps to Take



Consult a Qualified Electrician

This is not a DIY project. The potential for electrical shock and fire is significant. A licensed electrician can assess the situation, perform necessary testing, and recommend the safest and most code-compliant solution.

Local Codes

Electrical codes vary by location. Your electrician will be familiar with the local codes and can ensure that any work is done in compliance.

Testing

An electrician will use a multimeter and other testing equipment to verify the circuit's wiring, voltage, and current.


Grounding

Even if you choose one of the other solutions, discuss the possibility of adding grounding to the circuit with your electrician. There may be ways to retrofit a ground wire in some situations (e.g., using the metal conduit as a ground path, if applicable).

Document Everything

Keep detailed records of any electrical work performed, including diagrams, photos, and receipts.

In summary, your priority is to address the lack of grounding and the potential for neutral overload in the Edison circuit. The best solution is a panel upgrade. If that's not feasible, explore the AFCI/GFCI breaker with a pigtail neutral option (with electrician consultation and code approval). Do not attempt to work on this circuit yourself without proper training and equipment.
* Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question