Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Purpose of fuses between CB and motor OL relay

User: ChefTurnedSparky, Location: Columbus, Ohio

Asked on: Friday, October 11, 2024 at 10:53 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:46 am EST

Question: In a motor starter, what’s the purpose? Are they that much faster to break the circuit than a CB? Is it just standard practice to put them there?What type and size would I need for a 20A circuit, 1 hp motor? 208, single phase.Crew lead told me to take picture of the data sheets in the starter, the clips and send it to purchasing with the HP/ fla of the motor. But that’s no fun for anyone. I want to know HOW and WHY!

Okay, let's break down motor starters, their purpose, and how to size one for your situation.

What is a Motor Starter and What Does It Do?

A motor starter is more than just a simple on/off switch. It's a device specifically designed to safely start and stop electric motors, while also providing overload protection. Here's a breakdown of its key functions: Starting Control

Motors, especially larger ones, draw a significant inrush current (also called locked rotor amps or LRA) when they first start. This inrush can be several times the motor's normal running current (FLA - Full Load Amps). A motor starter helps manage this inrush to prevent voltage dips and stress on the electrical system. Some starters use reduced voltage starting methods (like autotransformers or soft starters) to further limit the inrush current.


Overload Protection

This is a critical function. The starter includes overload relays that monitor the motor's current. If the motor draws excessive current for a prolonged period (due to being overloaded, jammed, or having another fault), the overload relay will trip, disconnecting the motor from the power supply. This protects the motor from overheating and potential damage.

Under-Voltage Protection

If the supply voltage drops significantly or is interrupted, some starters can trip out, preventing the motor from restarting automatically when power is restored. This can be important to prevent unexpected starts and potential hazards.


Stopping Control

Provides a way to turn the motor off, either manually or automatically.

Coordination

Motor starters are designed to coordinate with upstream protective devices like circuit breakers to ensure proper clearing of faults without nuisance tripping.

Motor Starters vs. Circuit Breakers: Speed and Purpose
Speed

While a circuit breaker can interrupt a fault faster than a motor starter's overload relay, that's not the primary difference. Circuit breakers are designed for short-circuit protection - extremely high currents caused by a direct fault (like a short to ground). The breaker will disconnect much quicker than the overload protection.

Purpose



Circuit Breaker

Protects the entire circuit from overcurrents and short circuits. Think of it as protecting the wires and other components in the circuit. It is a code requirement for overcurrent protection.

Motor Starter

Primarily protects the
motor from overheating due to overloads (drawing too much current for too long). It also manages the starting current.

Why Use a Motor Starter?
Motor Protection

Overload protection is crucial for motor longevity. Repeated overloads without protection will significantly shorten the life of the motor.

Coordination

Starters allow for better coordination with upstream breakers. Without a starter, the motor's inrush current could potentially nuisance-trip the breaker during starting.


Remote Control/Automation

Motor starters often include control circuits that allow for remote starting and stopping, integration with automated systems, and interlocks.

Sizing a Motor Starter for Your 1 HP, 20A, 208V Single Phase Motor


Here's how to approach sizing a motor starter:1. Determine the Motor's FLA (Full Load Amps)

You mentioned your circuit is 20A, but that's your breaker size, not necessarily the motor's FLA. Look at the motor's nameplate. It must have an FLA rating. Alternatively, you can look up typical FLA values for a 1 HP, 208V, single-phase motor in the National Electrical Code (NEC) Table 430.248. A typical value is around 8.8 amps but verify the nameplate before proceeding.
2.


Choose the Starter Size (NEMA Size)

Motor starters are classified by NEMA size (e.g., NEMA Size 0, NEMA Size 1, NEMA Size 2, etc.). Each size is rated for a certain horsepower and current range. You select a size that's appropriate for your motor's HP and FLA. Refer to the motor starter manufacturer's data sheets or selection tables (e.g., from Allen-Bradley, Siemens, Schneider Electric, etc.). You will find that a Size 0 starter should suffice for this motor size.3.

Select the Overload Relay

The overload relay is the heart of the motor protection. It consists of two components: the heater pack and the relay itself. The heater pack are sized according to the motor full load current.

Adjust Overload Setting

Overload relays typically have an adjustable current range. Set the overload relay to the motor's nameplate FLA value.4.

Control Voltage

Determine the control voltage you want to use for the starter's coil (e.g., 120VAC, 24VAC, 24VDC). This voltage is used to energize the starter's coil, which closes the contacts and starts the motor.5.

Enclosure (if needed)

Consider the environment where the starter will be installed. You may need a NEMA-rated enclosure for protection against dust, moisture, or other hazards.

Example (Hypothetical)

Let's
assume your 1 HP, 208V, single-phase motor has an FLA of 8.8 amps.

NEMA Size

You'd likely choose a NEMA Size 0 starter. Double check the manufacturer's specs.

Overload Relay

Select an overload relay with an adjustable range that includes 8.8 amps. Set the overload relay to 8.8 amps.


Heater Pack
: Size accordingly with the overload. Control Voltage

Select a starter with the desired control voltage (e.g., 120VAC).

Why Your Crew Lead Asked for Data and Photos

Your crew lead asked for photos of the existing starter's data sheets and clips (heater packs) for a couple of reasons:


Direct Replacement

If they're replacing an existing starter, they want to ensure they get a compatible replacement. The data sheets provide all the necessary information about the starter's specifications (NEMA size, voltage, coil voltage, etc.).

Heater Pack Size

The clips are the heater elements for the overload relay. The number on the heater shows the actual trip-current setting. This helps ensure the correct overload protection for the motor.


Accuracy

Relying on nameplate data and your measurements is good, but having the actual part numbers from the existing starter is the best way to guarantee a match.

Purchasing

Purchasing departments need specific part numbers to order the correct components.

In Summary:


Motor starters are essential for safe and reliable motor operation. They provide overload protection, manage starting currents, and allow for control and automation. While a circuit breaker provides short-circuit protection, it doesn't offer the motor-specific overload protection that a starter does. Sizing a starter involves determining the motor's FLA and selecting a starter and overload relay with appropriate ratings.I hope this helps clarify the role of motor starters! Remember to
always* consult the NEC, local codes, and manufacturer's documentation when selecting and installing electrical equipment. It's best to consult a qualified electrician for installation and troubleshooting. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question