Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Oversized Generators

User: Ben BVE, Location: California

Asked on: Friday, October 11, 2024 at 1:33 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:46 am EST

Question: I have a client that has oversized generators for their systems. For example, they have a 400-amp 200kw generator feeding a 200-amp ATS and 200-amp service. When brought up to the engineering team they said to upgrade the lugs on the ATS to accommodate the 350 kcmil from the generator. However, I feel that this is still violating a few different NEC codes ie. 700.4, 110.3, and 240.4. I am hoping to get the soundest code violation that I can bring to them. Let me know if I am wrong.I also feel like this is going to cause extra maintenance like load banking.Let me know what you all think and thanks in advance.

You're right to be concerned. Here's a breakdown of the NEC concerns and other considerations, along with the strongest code violations

NEC Concerns and Code Violations
1. 240.4(B) Protection of Conductors

This is arguably your strongest argument. You've got a 400A generator capable of delivering a lot of fault current, feeding a 200A ATS and service. Even if you upgrade the lugs on the ATS to accommodate the larger conductors, the ATS and downstream service equipment are still only rated for 200A. In the event of a short circuit on the load side of the ATS, the 350 kcmil conductors could be subjected to overcurrent for an extended period, potentially damaging the conductors
before the 200A breaker on the service side trips.

Why it matters

The NEC requires conductors to be protected against overcurrent in accordance with their ampacity. The 200A overcurrent device is only protecting the 200A rated components of the ATS and service, not the 350 kcmil conductors upstream. While you can "up-size" conductors to compensate for voltage drop or to meet other requirements, you cannot allow the overcurrent protection to exceed the ampacity of the equipment it's protecting.

2. 110.3(B) Installation and Use

Equipment that is listed and labeled must be installed and used according to the instructions included in the listing or labeling. Modifying the lugs on an ATS to accommodate a larger conductor than it was originally designed for violates this section. The ATS is rated for a specific maximum conductor size. Bypassing that rating with larger conductors is a violation of the listing and could void the warranty and potentially create a safety hazard.


Why it matters

Listed and labeled equipment has been tested and approved for specific performance characteristics. Altering the equipment in a way that deviates from its listing voids the testing and approval.

3. 700.4 Coordination

(Emergency Systems) If this is an emergency system (required by code), proper coordination of the overcurrent protective devices is paramount. The system must be designed to minimize power outages to other parts of the system when a fault occurs. The 400A generator with 350kcmil conductors feeding a 200A ATS makes achieving proper coordination more difficult. The fault current potential is much higher than the 200A equipment is designed to handle.


Why it matters

Proper coordination is essential for selective tripping. You want the closest upstream overcurrent device to trip in the event of a fault, minimizing the impact on the rest of the emergency system. An oversized generator and conductors can make achieving selective coordination very difficult.

4. 445.13 Ampacity of Conductors from Generator

This section requires that conductors from the generator terminals have an ampacity not less than 115% of the nameplate current rating of the generator. In your example, the generator nameplate current rating is approximately 577 amps (200,000 watts / 240 volts / 1.732). 115% of this current would require conductors rated for at least 664 amps. While the 350 kcmil conductors might meet this requirement on paper, the fact that they're feeding into a 200A ATS and service creates a fundamental conflict with 240.4(B).

Additional Considerations
Engineering Justification

Ask the engineering team for the specific engineering calculations and justification for their design. Demand a clear explanation of how their approach complies with all applicable NEC codes.

Load Banking

You're absolutely right about the increased maintenance. Generators that are significantly oversized relative to the load they serve are prone to "wet stacking." This occurs when the generator doesn't run at a sufficient load to burn off all the fuel, leading to carbon deposits and reduced engine life. Frequent load banking becomes necessary to combat wet stacking.


Cost

Load banking adds to the expense of maintaining a generator.

Voltage Drop

While unlikely in this scenario with such large conductors, an oversized generator can contribute to voltage drop issues if not properly managed.


Future Loads

Sometimes, oversizing generators is done in anticipation of future load growth. However, even if future loads are planned, the current installation must comply with the NEC. The system can be designed for future expansion while remaining compliant now.

How to Present the Information to the Engineering Team
1. Politely and Professionally

Approach the team with a genuine desire to understand their reasoning and ensure a safe and code-compliant installation.2.

Cite Specific Code Sections

Clearly reference the specific NEC sections mentioned above (240.4(B), 110.3(B), 700.4, 445.13).
3.


Explain the Concerns

Articulate the safety concerns related to overcurrent protection, potential damage to equipment, and difficulty in achieving selective coordination.4.

Request Documentation

Ask for the engineering calculations and justification for the design.5.

Suggest Alternatives

Propose more code-compliant alternatives. Some possibilities include:

Reduce the Generator Size

Install a generator that is more appropriately sized for the load.


Use a Transfer Switch with a Higher Ampacity

Install a transfer switch with a higher ampacity that matches the generator output.*

Install Overcurrent Protection at the Generator

Install a properly sized overcurrent protective device (breaker or fuses) at the generator output to protect the downstream equipment. This might require a more complex system design to ensure selective coordination.

In summary, the biggest issue is the potential for an overcurrent event to damage the conductors feeding the ATS before the 200A breaker trips. The NEC prioritizes protecting conductors from overcurrent, and your client's current design does not provide adequate protection.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question