Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Vertical conduit runs on a Hospital roof

User: 30yroldtimer, Location: Chino

Asked on: Friday, October 11, 2024 at 2:27 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:47 am EST

Question: Hoping to get some help here. We are installing 1-1/2" conduit on roof blocks on a hospital roof. We had to cross a pathway (grip paper over pebble type roof) that lead from a roof hatch to a elevator room, penthouse entryway. The IOR passed our rough installation inspection but the FLSO recommended that we move our conduit from across the pathway. We moved the conduit but requires additional work to the scope. We are giving the GC a CO for the additional work. The GC is fighting the CO because they are saying we did not follow the NEC. Firstly, I do not agree with the GC because they referenced the NEC when we build using the CEC for healthcare facilities. Second, I've looked through both the NEC, CEC, and the CBC and cannot find anything that says I cannot run conduit over a pathway. This is a hospital with multiple A/C units, EF, and other mechanical equipment with multiple types of conduits running all over. I did find a code section in the CA residential code R324.6.1 "Pathways shall be located in areas with minimal obstructions such as vent pipes, conduit, or mechanical equipment." "Minimal" it says, not "No". Is there a code that I am not finding? Please help.

Okay, this is a tricky situation with code interpretations and the need to balance safety, accessibility, and project scope. Let's break down the key points and see if we can find a solid footing for your Change Order.

Key Considerations and Arguments


Which Code Governs? (CEC vs. NEC)
You are absolutely correct. If you are building in California, and the project is under the jurisdiction of the California Electrical Code (CEC), then the NEC is irrelevant. The GC's argument based on the NEC is invalid. This is your strongest point.2. Code Search

You've done a good job searching the relevant codes (CEC, CBC) for explicit prohibitions. The absence of a direct prohibition against running conduit across a pathway, in general, is a significant point in your favor. The residential code reference is interesting, but it's not directly applicable to a commercial hospital roof.3.

The "Pathway" Argument

The heart of the matter is whether your conduit run across the pathway creates a hazard or impedes access. Think about the FLSO's reasoning. What were their specific concerns? Common reasons for such objections include:

Trip Hazard

Even a low conduit run can be a trip hazard, especially in low-light conditions or when someone is carrying equipment.


Accessibility for Maintenance

Does your conduit hinder access for maintenance personnel who need to service equipment in the elevator room or penthouse?

Impediment to Emergency Access/Egress

In an emergency, personnel need to be able to move quickly and safely.


Obstruction to Required Clearances

Other equipment on the roof may require specific clearances for operation, service, or ventilation.4.

FLSO Authority

The Fire Life Safety Officer (FLSO) often has broad authority to interpret and enforce safety regulations beyond the prescriptive code. This is crucial. Even if the letter of the code isn't violated, the FLSO's interpretation of intent carries significant weight.5.

Pre-Existing Conditions vs. New Obstructions

Your argument about existing conduit on the roof is valid to a point, but the FLSO might argue that adding another obstruction is unacceptable, even if others exist. A photo log of existing conditions before you installed your conduit would be helpful.

Strategies and Recommendations


Document, Document, Document



Code Search

Compile your code search results (CEC, CBC) showing the
lack of a direct prohibition. Highlight the relevant sections.

FLSO Communication

Get in writing the FLSO's specific reason for requiring the relocation of the conduit. If you only have a verbal request, try to get them to put it in an email or a formal letter. The more detail you can get about the specific concern, the better.

Before/After Photos

Document the situation before and after the conduit relocation.


Impact Assessment

Carefully document the additional work (materials, labor) required to relocate the conduit. This is essential for your Change Order.2.

Focus on CEC Compliance

Refute the GC's NEC argument directly by pointing out that the project is governed by the CEC.3.

Engage the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)

Consider contacting the local electrical inspector or building official (if different from the FLSO). Explain the situation and ask for their opinion. A supportive opinion from the AHJ will strengthen your position.4.

Negotiation and Compromise



Offer Alternatives

If possible, suggest alternative conduit routing that might be more acceptable to the FLSO.


Mitigation Measures

Could you mitigate the FLSO's concerns without a full relocation? For example, could you install a ramp or cover over the conduit to eliminate the trip hazard? Could you paint the conduit a highly visible color?

Cost Sharing

Be prepared to negotiate on the cost of the Change Order. The GC might be more willing to compromise if you can reduce the cost impact.5.

Review the Original Contract

Carefully review the original contract and the project specifications. Are there any clauses that address unforeseen conditions, changes required by the AHJ, or responsibility for code compliance interpretations?

Potential Arguments in Your Favor for the Change Order



Lack of Code Violation

The conduit installation, as originally designed, did not violate any specific CEC or CBC codes.

FLSO Requirement

The relocation was required by the FLSO, acting in their capacity to ensure safety.


Unforeseen Condition

The FLSO's specific interpretation of the "pathway" issue was not reasonably foreseeable during the initial design and bidding process.

Change in Scope

The relocation constitutes a change in the original scope of work.

Example Communication

"Dear [GC Contact],We are writing to follow up on the concerns raised by the FLSO regarding our 1-1/2" conduit run across the pathway on the hospital roof. We understand the need to ensure safe and accessible pathways.As we discussed, we have thoroughly reviewed the California Electrical Code (CEC), California Building Code (CBC), and project specifications. We have not found any specific code prohibiting the installation of conduit in this location. (Attached are our code search results).However, to address the FLSO's concerns [State the FLSO's specific concerns - e.g., potential trip hazard and access for maintenance], we have relocated the conduit as requested. This relocation has required [Describe the additional work - e.g., additional conduit, fittings, labor, etc.].Therefore, we are submitting Change Order [Number] for the additional cost associated with this relocation. The original installation complied with the applicable codes and regulations, and this change was unforeseen.We are open to discussing this Change Order further and exploring any alternative solutions. We have also documented all communications with the FLSO and have attached photos of the initial and final installations."

Important Considerations



Maintain a Professional Tone

Always maintain a professional and collaborative tone in your communication with the GC and the FLSO.*

Timeliness:
Address the issue promptly and keep the project moving forward as much as possible.This is a complex situation, and the outcome will depend on the specific facts, the FLSO's reasoning, and your ability to negotiate with the GC. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question