User: W@ttson, Location: USA
Asked on: Friday, October 11, 2024 at 2:50 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:47 am EST
Question: Hello,I have a client that has two utility feeds that feed into an ATS. One utility feed is from 2 miles away and sends it to the ATS via their own medium voltage distribution. The other is nearby to the ATS. The utility grids are separate.The system has automatic power factor correction equipment connected to the 480V distribution bus. The PF correction only goes online when only the near utility feed is feeding the distribution. When the ATS is switched to the far away utility, the PF correction is not online at all.My thought is that the nearby utility has a lot of parasitic harmonics from neighbors. The nearby utility feeds many large facilities that use hundreds of drives. Can it be possible that the harmonics from the nearby neighbors effects the 480V bus and therefore kicks on the power factor correction unit? Then when connected to the far away utility, the neighbors that are at nearby to that 2 mile away location generally do not have harmonic producing loads so the harmonic load is not an issue and therefore the PF Correction unit does not kick on?Thanks
Your hypothesis is plausible and worth investigating. Here's a breakdown of why your thinking makes sense, along with steps you can take to confirm it
Why Your Hypothesis is Plausible:
Harmonics and Power Factor Correction
Power factor correction (PFC) equipment, particularly capacitor banks, can be significantly affected by harmonics. Harmonics can cause:
Overheating
Harmonics increase the current flowing through the capacitors, leading to overheating and potential failure.
Resonance
Harmonics can excite resonant frequencies in the system, causing voltage and current amplification, which further stresses the PFC equipment.
Control Problems
The control algorithms of the PFC unit might misinterpret the distorted waveforms caused by harmonics, leading to improper operation or even tripping.
Different Utility Feeds, Different Harmonic Profiles
As you pointed out, the two utility feeds are likely to have different harmonic profiles due to:
Proximity to Harmonic Sources
The nearby utility feed serves facilities with numerous drives and other nonlinear loads, making it more susceptible to harmonic pollution.
Distance and Impedance
The 2-mile distribution line to the far away utility introduces impedance, which can attenuate some harmonics before they reach your client's facility.
Different Grid Conditions
The grids themselves might be operated differently and have different levels of harmonic distortion.
PFC Unit Sensitivity
Some PFC units are more sensitive to harmonic distortion than others. The control algorithms, the capacitor bank design, and the overall system impedance all play a role.
How to Investigate
Here's a structured approach to confirm or refute your hypothesis:1.
Harmonic Analysis
This is the most critical step. You need to measure harmonic distortion on the 480V bus under both utility feed conditions:
Equipment
Use a high-quality power quality analyzer that can measure voltage and current THD (Total Harmonic Distortion), individual harmonic magnitudes (up to at least the 50th harmonic), and TDD (Total Demand Distortion).
Location
Measure directly at the 480V bus where the PFC unit is connected.
Duration
Record data for at least 24 hours under each utility feed condition to capture load variations. Ideally, record for a week to get a comprehensive picture.
Analyze the Results
Compare the THD, TDD, and individual harmonic levels for each utility feed. Look for significant differences. Focus on odd-order harmonics (3rd, 5th, 7th, etc.) as they are most commonly produced by nonlinear loads. Pay attention to the 5th harmonic - it's often the most problematic.2.
PFC Unit Parameters and Configuration
Review the PFC unit's manual and settings
Understand how it's configured (e.g., target power factor, sensitivity to voltage and current disturbances).
Check for alarm logs
See if the PFC unit has logged any alarms related to overcurrent, overvoltage, or harmonic distortion.
Inspect the capacitors
Visually inspect the capacitors for signs of bulging, discoloration, or leakage, which could indicate overheating and damage from harmonics.
Check the capacitor bank reactors if there is any present
Reactors are sometimes installed on the PFC unit to protect the capacitors from excessive harmonic currents. Make sure the reactors are still working as expected.3.
Voltage Regulation
Measure the voltage regulation
Measure the line voltage at the 480V bus under both utility feed conditions. Significant voltage drops or fluctuations on one feed compared to the other could indicate issues.
Check voltage balance
A significant unbalance on the 480V bus may cause issues.4.
Neighboring Facility Assessment (If Possible)
Inquire about load profiles
If possible, talk to the managers or engineers at nearby facilities to understand their load profiles and the types of equipment they use (e.g., variable frequency drives, rectifiers, UPS systems).
Check their grounding systems
Are there any bonding problems between the different facilities?5.
System Modeling (Optional but Recommended for Complex Situations)
Create a simplified electrical model
Use power system simulation software (e.g., ETAP, SKM, EasyPower) to model your client's system, including the two utility feeds, the ATS, the PFC unit, and the nearby loads.
Simulate harmonic injection
Inject harmonic currents into the model based on the harmonic measurements you took.
Analyze the results
See how the harmonics propagate through the system and affect the PFC unit. This can help you pinpoint the root cause and evaluate potential mitigation solutions.
Potential Solutions (Based on Findings)
If your hypothesis is confirmed, here are some potential solutions:
Harmonic Filters
Install harmonic filters (tuned or broadband) at the 480V bus to reduce harmonic distortion.
Detuned Reactors
If the PFC unit uses capacitor banks, consider installing detuned reactors in series with the capacitors to prevent resonance.
Active Harmonic Filters
Active harmonic filters can dynamically compensate for harmonics, providing a more flexible solution than passive filters.
Upgrade PFC Unit
Replace the existing PFC unit with a more robust unit that is less sensitive to harmonics.
Isolate the Harmonic Sources
If possible, work with the nearby facilities to mitigate harmonic sources at their facilities.
Change Utility Configuration
In very extreme situations, you might want to explore alternatives with the utility company to find a utility feed that has lower harmonics.
Load Shedding or Smoothing
Shift or smooth out the load profile to reduce demand surges and subsequent harmonic generation.
Important Considerations
Safety
Work with qualified electrical personnel and follow all safety procedures when taking measurements and making modifications to electrical systems.
Coordination
Coordinate with the utility company before making any changes to the power factor correction system.
Cost: Evaluate the cost-effectiveness of different solutions before implementing them.By following these steps, you'll be able to determine whether harmonics are indeed causing the PFC unit to behave differently under the two utility feed conditions, and you'll be in a much better position to recommend an appropriate solution. Good luck! Flag for review