User: Vsharp, Location: California
Asked on: Friday, October 11, 2024 at 5:45 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:48 am EST
Question: I have project on a facility that has medium voltage customer owned substation feeding multiple building's with 480/277 wye. The facility was built in the 60's and very few detached building feeders have equipment grounds. The facility will soon be replacing all the substation switchgear which will require Gfpe protection per 230.95. Would the facility have to also re-pull all new equipment grounds or could either of the exemptions from 250.32(B)1 apply? There are concerns of the new ground fault protection not operating correctly.
This is a complex situation with significant safety and code compliance implications. Here's a breakdown of the issues and considerations
The Problem:
Missing Equipment Grounds
Buildings fed from the substation that lack equipment grounding conductors are a safety hazard. They violate current code and increase the risk of shock and fire in ground fault conditions.
GFPE and Ungrounded Systems
Ground fault protection of equipment (GFPE) relies on a low-impedance path back to the source to trip the breaker when a ground fault occurs. Without a properly sized equipment grounding conductor, the fault current path becomes high impedance, potentially limiting or preventing the GFPE from operating correctly.
230.95 Mandate
The requirement to install GFPE on new service equipment for solidly grounded wye systems over 150V to ground necessitates careful consideration of the existing grounding infrastructure.
Older Construction
The facility was built in the 1960s when grounding requirements were often less stringent. Retrofitting is generally required when changes happen to a system but older building feeders might not have all the code required safety components.
Relevant NEC Sections
230.95 Ground-Fault Protection of Equipment
Mandates GFPE on service equipment rated 1000 amps or more for solidly grounded wye systems over 150 volts to ground (e.g., 277/480V). It also specifies that the maximum setting be 1200 amps and the maximum clearing time be 1 second for ground faults of 3000 amps or more.
250.4(A)(5) Bonding of Electrically Conductive Materials and Equipment
Requires that normally non-current-carrying conductive materials be connected together and to the electrical supply source in a manner that establishes an effective ground-fault current path.
250.32(B) Buildings or Structures Supplied by a Feeder or Branch Circuit. Covers the grounding and bonding requirements for buildings or structures supplied by a feeder or branch circuit. (B)(1) Grounded Systems
This section requires that the equipment grounding conductor be run with the supply conductors to the building or structure and connected to the building or structure grounding electrode system. It also outlines two exceptions which might be applicable.
250.4(A)(5) Effective Ground-Fault Current Path. Electrical equipment and wiring must be installed in a manner that creates a low-impedance ground fault current path for safely carrying fault current and facilitating the operation of overcurrent devices. 250.122 Size of Equipment Grounding Conductors
Determines the minimum size of the equipment grounding conductor based on the overcurrent protective device protecting the circuit.
Analysis and Options
Full Compliance is the Goal
The ideal solution is to bring the entire system into full compliance with current NEC requirements. This means:
Replacing Feeders
Repulling new feeders to all detached buildings with correctly sized equipment grounding conductors. This is the safest and most reliable solution.
Proper Grounding Electrode System
Ensuring that each building has a properly installed and maintained grounding electrode system (ground rods, etc.) bonded to the equipment grounding conductor.
Bonding
Ensuring all metallic components (conduit, enclosures, water pipes, etc.) are properly bonded to the equipment grounding system.
Engineering Study
A proper ground fault study that analyzes the entire system's grounding and short circuit capability.2.
Evaluating the 250.32(B)(1) Exceptions
Carefully assess whether either of the exceptions in 250.32(B)(1) actually apply and are safe and code-compliant in your specific situation.
Do not assume they apply without thorough investigation and documentation. These exceptions are narrow and have specific requirements: Exception No. 1
Only applies if the grounding electrode conductor (GEC) for the detached building is connected to the grounded conductor of the feeder and there are no continuous metallic paths between the buildings. This is rarely the case in older facilities, as there's often metallic water piping, gas piping, or even shared structural steel that creates a metallic path. Furthermore, this exception is often disallowed by local amendments and is generally considered less safe than running a dedicated equipment grounding conductor.
Exception No. 2
This requires that the feeder be part of a qualified maintenance program under qualified persons. This exception is designed to address situations where it is impractical to install a separate equipment grounding conductor and relies on careful monitoring and maintenance of the grounding system. It would require documentation.
Why the Exceptions May Not Be Suitable (Especially in your Case)
Safety Risk
Relying on the earth as the primary ground fault path (which is what happens without a properly sized equipment grounding conductor) is dangerous. The earth has a high impedance, which can limit fault current and prevent the GFPE from tripping.
Stray Voltage
Without proper equipment grounding, stray voltages can develop on metallic surfaces, creating a shock hazard.
Code Compliance
Relying on exceptions when the primary method is feasible is often frowned upon by inspectors. Be prepared to justify your reasoning.
GFPE Malfunction
GFPE might not operate correctly or reliably without a low-impedance ground fault path. The resistance of the earth can significantly reduce the fault current, preventing the GFPE from tripping within the required time.
Recommendations
Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer
Engage a professional engineer with experience in power systems, grounding, and NEC compliance. They can perform a site assessment, conduct a grounding study, and develop a solution that meets your specific needs and ensures safety.2.
Grounding Study
Have a thorough grounding study conducted to determine the existing grounding impedance, available fault current, and the impact of adding GFPE without upgrading the grounding system.3.
Prioritize Full Compliance
Strongly consider repulling feeders with properly sized equipment grounding conductors to all detached buildings. This is the safest and most reliable option.4.
Document Everything
If you decide to use an exception, thoroughly document your reasons, the qualifications of the personnel involved, and the maintenance procedures in place. Be prepared to present this documentation to the electrical inspector.5.
Coordination Study
Perform a full coordination study after the installation of the new switchgear and GFPE to ensure that all overcurrent protective devices (breakers, fuses) are properly coordinated to protect the system.6.
Work with the AHJ
Discuss your plans with the local Authority Having Jurisdiction (electrical inspector) before starting any work. Obtain their input and approval.
In Summary:While the exceptions in 250.32(B)(1) might seem like a way to avoid the expense of repulling feeders, they are generally not recommended, especially in older facilities where the grounding infrastructure is likely inadequate. Prioritize safety and code compliance by installing properly sized equipment grounding conductors to all buildings. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer and the AHJ to develop a plan that meets your specific needs and ensures the safety of your facility. Installing GFPE without addressing the inadequate grounding system is a recipe for potential disaster. Flag for review