Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Madison Clips on Plastic Boxes

User: infinity, Location: New Jersey

Asked on: Saturday, October 12, 2024 at 9:39 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:49 am EST

Question: A fellow electrician saw a TikTok (or some other platform) video where they repaired a loose plastic receptacle box with a metal Madison Clip. He asked me if this was code compliant. I said no because the metal clip is not connected to anything that is grounded (like when used with metal box) and could become energized. The next question was what code section would an inspector cite. Hmmm good one.Any thoughts?

This is a great question that highlights the importance of understanding the principles behind the code rather than just memorizing specific sections. You're right to be cautious, and your reasoning is sound.Here's a breakdown of why this is likely a code violation and where you might find support within the NEC

Why it's likely a violation:
Unintentional Energization and Lack of Grounding

The core issue is that the metal Madison Clip
could come into contact with an energized conductor within the box due to compromised insulation or other faults. Because it's not bonded to ground, it becomes a potential shock hazard. A fault could energize the clip, and a person touching it would create a path to ground, resulting in a shock.

Compromised Box Integrity

Using a Madison Clip to "repair" a loose plastic box suggests the box itself is damaged or its mounting method has failed. The box is designed to securely contain and protect the wiring. Simply adding a clip doesn't restore the original integrity.

Possible NEC Sections to Consider

Finding the exact section that explicitly forbids this specific scenario might be tricky, but here's how you can build a case based on general principles:1.

110.3(B) Installation and Use

"Listed or labeled equipment shall be installed and used in accordance with any instructions included in the listing or labeling." Plastic boxes are listed and tested for specific mounting methods and securement. Using a Madison Clip is almost certainly not part of the listing instructions for the box.2.

314.17(B) Securing and Supporting Boxes

This section deals with how boxes must be secured. While it focuses on the original method, it reinforces the idea that boxes need to be rigidly and reliably fastened. A Madison Clip jury-rigged to a plastic box is unlikely to meet the intent of secure and stable support.3.

314.23(H) Nonmetallic Boxes

Addresses how nonmetallic boxes must be supported. It will likely not cover your particular situation, but it could be worth a look.4.

314.25 Covers and Canopies

"All boxes shall be provided with a cover unless the installation complies with 406.5(C)." A loose box might not be properly covered, creating a hazard.
5.


General Safety Concerns

You can also appeal to the broader safety principles of the NEC. The purpose of the code is to safeguard persons and property from hazards arising from the use of electricity. Using a metal clip in this way introduces a potential shock hazard that the code aims to prevent.

Arguments to Make to an Inspector (if needed)



Manufacturer's Instructions

"This isn't how the box was designed to be mounted. Using a metal clip is outside the manufacturer's specifications and violates 110.3(B)."


Lack of Grounding and Potential for Energization

"The metal clip is not bonded to ground. If a fault occurs within the box, the clip could become energized, creating a shock hazard."*

Compromised Box Integrity

"The fact that the box is loose suggests it's damaged or its mounting has failed. Simply adding a clip doesn't restore the box's structural integrity or ensure it can safely contain the wiring."

The Correct Solution

The correct solution is almost always to replace the damaged box and properly secure it according to the manufacturer's instructions. If the box is loose due to a stripped screw hole, you can use a screw anchor designed for plastic or a larger screw (if the box allows).

In summary:
While there might not be one single, perfect code section, you can build a strong case against using a Madison Clip to "repair" a loose plastic receptacle box based on the principles of safe installation, manufacturer's instructions, and the potential for creating a shock hazard. Always err on the side of safety and proper repair methods. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question