User: fastline, Location: midwest usa
Asked on: Saturday, October 12, 2024 at 1:18 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:49 am EST
Question: I am working through a complete audit of an industrial building in which the access control system and surveillance system need to be upgraded. I am tasked with guiding this process. I am trying to learn more about certain on-prem and cloud based access systems but finding it very hard to get much info on specific equipment, or even know what all is out there. I was trying to narrow the field in terms of what is desired and which systems would be of interest. Seems most security installers just recommend what they are a dealer for, and I am trying to learn in a broader sense.
You're right, navigating the access control and surveillance system landscape can be tricky! It's often difficult to get unbiased information, and installers naturally gravitate towards what they know and support. Let's break down a strategy to help you narrow your options for your industrial building upgrade.
I. Understanding Your Needs and Requirements
This is the most crucial step! Before even looking at specific systems, define exactly what you need. Security Levels and User Groups
Who needs access, and to where? Define different user groups (e.g., employees, contractors, visitors, management) and the specific areas they need to access (e.g., entire building, specific offices, server rooms, loading docks, hazardous material storage). What are the time-based access needs? Do access permissions need to vary by time of day, day of the week, or specific schedules? Does security need to ramp up/down at certain times? Consider shift changes, or other recurring events.
Type of Access Control
Card/Fob Readers: Standard, reliable, and relatively inexpensive. Consider the type of card technology (proximity, smart card, etc.). What level of security is required? Biometrics: Fingerprint, facial recognition, iris scan. Higher security, but often more expensive and can raise privacy concerns. Mobile Access: Using smartphones. Convenient but relies on phone connectivity and security. PIN Codes: Can be easily shared, generally considered the least secure.
Door Hardware Considerations
Electromagnetic Locks (Maglocks): Strong holding force, require constant power to remain locked (fail-safe). Electric Strikes: Replace the existing strike plate. Can be fail-safe or fail-secure. Electric Mortise Locks: Offer robust security and multiple locking points. Exit Devices (Panic Bars): Must comply with fire codes for egress. Door Position Sensors: Provide confirmation that doors are closed and locked.
Surveillance System Requirements
Coverage Areas: Prioritize critical areas: entrances, exits, loading docks, production floors, storage areas, parking lots, server rooms, perimeter fencing. Camera Types:
Fixed Cameras: Best for specific areas where the view doesn't need to change. PTZ (Pan-Tilt-Zoom) Cameras: Offer flexibility to monitor a wider area. Bullet Cameras: Good for outdoor use and long-range viewing. Dome Cameras: More discreet, often used indoors. Thermal Cameras: Useful for perimeter security and detecting heat signatures in low-light conditions. Image Quality: Resolution (1080p, 4K, etc.), frame rate, low-light performance. Recording Requirements: How long do you need to store footage? What is the retention policy? Analytics: Motion detection, object recognition, facial recognition, license plate recognition, people counting.
Integration
Access Control & Surveillance: Can the systems integrate? For example, can camera footage be automatically triggered by access control events? Intrusion Detection System: Do you need integration with an existing or planned alarm system? Fire Alarm System: Integration for automatic door unlocking during fire emergencies. Building Management System (BMS): Integration for energy management or overall building control. HR/Employee Database: Can access control user data be synchronized with your HR system?
Network Infrastructure
Existing Network Capacity: Can your network handle the bandwidth requirements of the surveillance system, especially if using high-resolution cameras? Will you need to upgrade network switches, cabling, or Wi-Fi? Network Security: How will you secure the access control and surveillance systems from cyber threats? Consider network segmentation, strong passwords, and regular security updates. Power over Ethernet (PoE): Can PoE be used to power cameras and access control readers, simplifying installation?
Power Considerations
Power Consumption: Consider the power requirements of all components (readers, cameras, locks, servers, etc.). Backup Power: Uninterruptible Power Supplies (UPS) to ensure the system remains operational during power outages.
Budget
Be realistic about the cost, including hardware, software, installation, maintenance, and ongoing subscriptions.
Compliance
Are there any industry-specific regulations or standards that the system must meet (e.g., HIPAA, PCI DSS, GDPR)?
Future Scalability
Will the system be easy to expand as your needs grow?
Maintenance and Support
What level of support is available from the vendor? What is the cost of maintenance?
On-Premise vs Cloud
The on-premise vs cloud decision depends on your IT capabilities, security concerns, and budget. On-Premise: You own and manage the hardware and software. More control, but requires in-house IT expertise. Cloud-Based: The vendor hosts the hardware and software. Lower upfront costs, but requires a reliable internet connection and raises data security questions.
II. Researching Access Control & Surveillance Systems
Major Manufacturers to Start With (This is not exhaustive, but a good starting point)
Access Control
HID Global
A well known brand, broad product range.
LenelS2
Part of Carrier, Enterprise level solutions
Kisi
Cloud based and generally easier to install
Brivo
Cloud based access systems
Honeywell
Integrate with intrusion and building management.
Allegion (Schlage)
Physical security, door hardware, electronic access.
Axis Communications
Known for their cameras, but they also offer access control solutions.
Open Options
DNA Fusion is used for access control
Surveillance (Video Surveillance as a Service - VSaaS)
Axis Communications
High quality cameras and analytics.
Hanwha Techwin (Samsung)
Broad range of cameras and recording solutions.
Bosch Security Systems
Reliable and feature-rich.
Avigilon (Motorola Solutions)
Advanced analytics and high-resolution cameras.
Eagle Eye Networks
Cloud-based video management system (VMS).
Arlo
For lighter duty and simple requirements
Online Resources
ASIS International
Professional organization for security professionals. Their website has resources and publications.
Security Industry Association (SIA)
Trade association for security companies.
Industry Publications
Security Technology Executive, Security Sales & Integration, SDM Magazine.
Online Forums
Search for security forums or Reddit communities related to access control and surveillance. Be cautious about biased opinions.
Product Review Websites
Search for reviews on sites like Capterra, G2, or TrustRadius, but remember these can sometimes be influenced.
Manufacturer Websites
Dive deep into the websites of the manufacturers listed above. Download brochures, datasheets, and case studies.
Cloud vs. On-Premise Considerations
Cloud-Based Pros
Lower upfront costs (no server hardware to buy). Scalability. Remote access and management. Automatic software updates.
Cloud-Based Cons
Recurring subscription fees. Reliance on internet connectivity. Data security concerns (who owns the data, where is it stored, is it encrypted?). Latency (potential delays in video streaming).
On-Premise Pros
More control over data and security. No recurring subscription fees. Can operate without internet connectivity (after initial setup).
On-Premise Cons
Higher upfront costs (server hardware, software licenses). Requires in-house IT expertise to manage and maintain. Responsibility for software updates and security patches.
III. Evaluating and Selecting Systems1.
Create a Matrix
Build a spreadsheet comparing the features, capabilities, and costs of different systems. Use the requirements you defined in Step I as the columns in your matrix.2.
Request Demos and Proof of Concepts (POCs)
Contact the vendors that seem like a good fit and request a demo of their system. If possible, conduct a POC in a small area of your building to test the system's performance and compatibility.3.
Ask Specific Questions
Don't be afraid to ask tough questions to the vendors: What are the total costs, including hardware, software, installation, training, and ongoing maintenance? What is the system's track record for reliability and security? What type of encryption is used to protect data? What are the vendor's service level agreements (SLAs) for uptime and support? Can the system integrate with my existing systems? What is the process for handling security breaches or vulnerabilities? Can you provide references from other industrial customers? What type of training is available for my staff?4.
Consider Working with a Consultant
If you're feeling overwhelmed, consider hiring a security consultant who specializes in access control and surveillance systems. They can provide unbiased advice and help you navigate the selection process. Look for someone with experience in industrial environments.5.
Thoroughly Review Contracts
Before signing any contract, carefully review the terms and conditions, including warranty information, support agreements, and data ownership clauses. Have your legal team review the contract as well.
IV. Important Considerations for Industrial Environments
Durability
Industrial environments can be harsh. Choose equipment that is ruggedized and designed to withstand dust, moisture, temperature extremes, and physical impacts.
Integration with Machinery and Automation
Consider integrating the access control and surveillance systems with your existing machinery and automation systems.
Safety
Ensure that the access control system does not impede emergency egress. All exit doors must comply with fire codes.
Compliance with Industry Regulations
Be aware of any industry-specific regulations or standards that apply to your facility (e.g., OSHA, EPA).
Key Takeaways
Needs-Based Approach
Start with a clear understanding of your requirements. Don't let a vendor dictate what you think you need.
Multiple Bids
Get quotes from several vendors before making a decision.
Due Diligence
Conduct thorough research and check references.
Security is Paramount
Don't compromise security for cost savings.
Long-Term Perspective: Consider the total cost of ownership, including ongoing maintenance and support.By following these steps, you can make an informed decision and select the access control and surveillance systems that best meet the needs of your industrial building. Good luck! Flag for review