User: tom baker, Location: Bremerton, Washington
Asked on: Sunday, October 13, 2024 at 11:18 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:52 am EST
Question: Helping a friend replace his old panel.Would like a recommendation on type of panelboard, plug on neutral desiredSiemensSquare D HomelineCutler HammerWant an exterior 3R combo meter/panel, 200 amp service panelwith 6/8 ckts, use feed thru lugs to ATS and then inside to 42 ckt main lug panelWould like same mfg on panelsUsing the combo exterior panel would allow an SPD and branch cord for HVAC or ?
Okay, I can help you break down the options for your friend's panel upgrade. Given your requirements (200A service, combo meter/panel, feed-through lugs, ATS, interior panel, plug-on neutral, and surge protection), here's a breakdown of the pros and cons of the brands you mentioned, along with recommendations
Key Considerations:
Plug-on Neutral
This is a worthwhile feature for easier and cleaner wiring.
Combo Meter/Panel (All-in-One)
These save space and simplify the installation. Make sure it meets your local utility requirements.
Feed-Through Lugs
Essential for feeding the ATS and then the interior panel.
ATS Compatibility
Ensure the ATS is compatible with the brand of panel you choose. Some ATS manufacturers may prefer or recommend certain brands.
Surge Protection (SPD)
Integrating surge protection is a smart move.
Enclosure Type (NEMA 3R)
Important for outdoor installations, protecting against rain and ice.
Circuit Count
6/8 circuits in the combo panel might be a bit limiting depending on future needs. Consider a panel with more spaces if there's room.
Local Electrical Codes
Check with local jurisdictions before starting to ensure that all components and installations meet local standards.
Qualified Electrician
It's highly recommended that a qualified electrician perform this work to ensure safety and code compliance.
Brand Breakdown
1. Siemens
Pros
Reputation for quality and reliability. Offers plug-on neutral options in their load centers. Comprehensive product line for residential and commercial applications. Readily available at many electrical supply houses and some big box stores.
Cons
Can sometimes be slightly more expensive than Square D Homeline.
Considerations
Siemens has a good selection of meter combos with feed-through lugs. They offer surge protection devices (SPDs) that integrate well with their panels.
2. Square D Homeline
Pros
Generally the most affordable option. Plug-on neutral is available in their Homeline series. Widely available at big box stores and electrical supply houses. Easy to find accessories and replacement parts.
Cons
Some electricians view Homeline as being of slightly lower build quality compared to Square D QO or Siemens. (This is subjective).
Considerations
Good option if budget is a major concern. Ensure the meter combo you choose has the feed-through lugs you need. Square D offers SPDs designed for their panels.
3. Cutler-Hammer (Eaton)
Pros
Solid reputation and a wide range of products. Offers plug-on neutral load centers. Good selection of meter combos.
Cons
Availability may be slightly less widespread than Siemens or Square D, depending on your location.
Considerations
Eaton (Cutler-Hammer) has a good offering of meter combos with feed-through lugs. They have SPDs designed to work with their panels.
Recommendations
Based on your requirements, here's my recommendation:1.
Siemens
This is my top recommendation due to its reputation for quality, comprehensive product line, and readily available meter combos with feed-through lugs and plug-on neutral options.
Specific Component Choices (Using Siemens as an Example)
Exterior Meter/Panel Combo (200A, 3R, Feed-Through Lugs)
Look for a Siemens meter combo with a NEMA 3R enclosure, 200A main breaker, feed-through lugs (rated for 200A or higher), and sufficient spaces for your 6-8 circuits and space for the SPD breaker. Consider a slightly larger enclosure if possible. Example: (You'll need to check Siemens' catalog and local supply houses for the exact model available in your area) A Siemens MC series meter combo with feed through lugs
Interior Panel (42-Circuit, Main Lug)
Choose a Siemens 42-circuit main lug panel with plug-on neutral. Make sure it has sufficient space for future expansion. Example: Siemens PL Series 42-Space, 200A, Main Lug, Plug-on Neutral Load Center.
Automatic Transfer Switch (ATS)
Select an ATS that is compatible with Siemens panels. Consult the ATS manufacturer's documentation for recommended panel types.
Surge Protective Device (SPD)
Choose a Siemens surge protection device (SPD) designed for their load centers. Ideally, one that can be easily mounted within the combo meter/panel. Example: Siemens FirstSurge series.
Breakers
Use Siemens breakers that are compatible with their load centers, and remember that the combo panel does not need to have breakers of the same amperage of the main panel.
Wiring Scenario
Utility Meter
Power comes from the utility to the meter in the combo unit.2.
Main Breaker
The 200A main breaker in the combo unit protects the entire service.3.
Feed-Through Lugs
Wires from the load side of the main breaker connect to the feed-through lugs.4.
ATS
Wires run from the feed-through lugs to the ATS. The ATS will switch between utility power and generator power.5.
Interior Panel
Wires run from the load side of the ATS to the main lugs of the 42-circuit interior panel.6.
Branch Circuits
Branch circuits (lighting, outlets, appliances) are wired from the interior panel.7.
SPD
The SPD is wired to a dedicated breaker in the combo panel.
Important Considerations & Recommendations
Consult a Qualified Electrician
This is crucial. Electrical work is dangerous and must be done correctly to comply with codes and ensure safety. A licensed electrician will know local requirements and ensure proper grounding and bonding.
Permitting
Obtain the necessary permits from your local building department before starting any work.
Utility Coordination
Coordinate with your local utility company for the meter installation and service connection.
Load Calculation
Perform a load calculation to ensure that the 200A service is adequate for your friend's needs.
Wiring Size
Use the correct wire size for the 200A service, ATS connection, and all branch circuits, according to the National Electrical Code (NEC) and local codes.
Grounding and Bonding
Proper grounding and bonding are essential for safety. Follow the NEC requirements.*
Arc Fault Circuit Interrupters (AFCIs) and Ground Fault Circuit Interrupters (GFCIs): Use AFCIs and GFCIs as required by code for various circuits (bedrooms, bathrooms, kitchens, etc.).By carefully considering these factors and working with a qualified electrician, you can help your friend upgrade their electrical panel safely and effectively. Flag for review