Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Paralleled Output to (1) AC PV DISCONNECT from (2) AC PV INVERTER OUTPUT COMBINERS

User: Pressure, Location: Lawrence, KS

Asked on: Monday, October 14, 2024 at 12:34 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:53 am EST

Question: I am designing a system, that will require (2) AC PV Inverter Output Combiners. Each combiner will be rated at 800A with a 800A Main OCPD, and have 752A at the continuous use rating. I would like to then parallel the output of each combiner to a single 1600A Fused AC PV Disconnect. Each Combiner will require (3) Sets of [(3) 400kCMIL AL and (1) #1/0 AWG EGC CU in 2.5" Conduit to the 1600A AC PV Disco.The question is in regard to the paralleling of the (2) power sources and their distances from each other. I am calculating a 2.02V drop @ 0.42% for the first combiner, and a 5.79V drop @ 1.21% for the second combiner. I do not believe this violates any paralleled conductor rules, but I could be wrong. Can I potentially increase the conductor size of the second combiner to bring it closer to the Vdrop of combiner 1, or do I need to have both combiners next to each other and have the same size and length of conductors for each?Any insight into best practices for this situation would be appreciated. Thanks.

Okay, let's break down this PV combiner paralleling scenario and address your questions. You're on the right track thinking about voltage drop and paralleling rules.

Understanding the Requirements Code Basis

I'm assuming you're working under the NEC (National Electrical Code) since you're using AWG and kCMIL conductor sizes. If you're under a different electrical code, the specific rules may vary.


Continuous Current

752A is the important number here. This is the sustained load that the conductors will carry.

Paralleling

NEC Article 310.10(H) provides the rules for paralleling conductors.

Analysis of Your Situation
1. Paralleling Rules (NEC 310.10(H))



Current Rating

You're using 400 kCMIL aluminum conductors. You'll need to verify the ampacity of these conductors in your specific installation based on the NEC ampacity tables (310.16 or 310.17), taking into account temperature rating of the conductors, termination temperature ratings, and any applicable derating factors (ambient temperature, number of conductors in a raceway, etc.). A typical 75°C rated 400 kCMIL aluminum conductor has an ampacity around 310A in free air, but this number must be adjusted downwards in a raceway with other current carrying conductors. With 3 parallel sets of 400kCMIL AL conductors per phase, you will have 9 conductors total in the conduit. Assuming all are current carrying, this will require a 70% derating for more than 3CCC in a raceway. Keep this in mind when selecting your appropriate wire size.

Same Length



This is the critical point for your question.
310.10(H)(5) requires that paralleled conductors be the same length to prevent unequal current sharing. Significant differences in length will lead to the shorter conductors carrying a disproportionately larger share of the current, potentially overloading them. Same Conductor Material

You're good here – all aluminum for the phase conductors.

Same Size

Also, good here - all 400kCMIL.


Same Insulation Type

Ensure all conductors within each parallel set have the same insulation type.

Terminate in the Same Manner

This means using the same type of lugs and torqueing them to the manufacturer's specifications.


Maintain Same Arrangement

The conductors should be bundled, taped, or cabled to maintain the same electrical characteristics.2.

Voltage Drop Concerns

The voltage drops you calculated (2.02V and 5.79V) are different. This directly contradicts the "same length" requirement. If the lengths are different, and the impedance (due to conductor length and size) are different, the current will not be evenly shared, and the voltage drops will be different.

NEC Recommendation

NEC Informative Annex D provides guidelines on voltage drop. While not mandatory, it's good practice. It generally recommends a voltage drop of no more than 3% for feeders and 5% overall (feeder + branch circuit). Your 1.21% drop is within that guideline individually, but the difference between the two combiners is problematic due to paralleling rules.

Recommendations
1. Equal Lengths are Paramount



The most important thing is to ensure the parallel conductors from
both combiners to the disconnect are the exact same length and installed with identical methods.
This minimizes impedance differences. You will likely need to coil up the excess length from the first combiner. Consider physically locating the combiners next to each other to simplify this. This is best practice. Measure and cut the conductors precisely. If the distances are truly unavoidable, and you cannot achieve identical lengths, paralleling is not a viable solution.2. Conductor Size Adjustment (With CAUTION)



The NEC does
not allow you to intentionally mismatch conductor sizes within a parallel set to "balance" voltage drop
if the lengths are the same. All conductors within a parallel set must be the same size. If you are intentionally increasing conductor size to compensate for different lengths, you will violate the NEC and create an unsafe installation. If you achieve identical lengths, conductor sizing should be based on ampacity and limiting voltage drop to the NEC recommendations (Annex D).3. Calculate and Verify

After installation, use a clamp meter to measure the current in each parallel conductor set. This is crucial to verify that the current is being shared relatively equally. If you see a significant imbalance (more than a few percent difference), investigate immediately. It may indicate a loose connection, a manufacturing defect in a conductor, or a violation of paralleling rules.4.

Consider Alternatives



Series Connection (If Feasible)

If your inverter architecture allows, explore connecting the inverters in series instead of paralleling their outputs. This can eliminate paralleling issues, but it requires careful consideration of voltage levels and grounding. Generally, this is not practical or possible on the AC output of the inverters.


Separate Disconnects

Another option is to avoid paralleling altogether and use separate disconnects for each combiner. This might be more expensive (due to the additional disconnect), but it eliminates the complexities of paralleling.

Larger Single Combiner

If possible, consider using a single, larger combiner that can handle the combined output of the inverters.

In Summary

Your primary focus
must be on ensuring that the paralleled conductors are the same length and installed identically. Do not* intentionally mismatch conductor sizes to try to compensate for length differences. Proper planning, careful installation, and post-installation verification are key to a safe and code-compliant system.

Disclaimer:
Consult with a licensed electrical engineer to ensure your design meets all applicable codes and standards. This response is for informational purposes only. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question