Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 120V Feeder to the Dwelling

User: Kandela1992, Location: New York City

Asked on: Monday, October 14, 2024 at 2:12 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:53 am EST

Question: Hello,I am an master electrician in NYC.I have an potential job but conditions of it are concerning me.So, client is combining 3 apartments on the top, 17th floor of the multifamily residential building.Each apartment is fed by 120V 60A 2 wire feeder with 3 AWG conductors in steel conduit.Building is old and they have installed 3 phase 4 wire feeders for 3 apartment on top of each other. Sharing the grounded conductor between those three apartments.Distance from overcurrent protection to apartment panels is 250’ and as per my calculations voltage drop is exceeding allowable 4% drop as per 2011 NYC code.Load calculations as per engineer is 60A on each feeder.I just wanted your opinion if these installation, loading #3 wire on 250’ 3 phase system with 60A is allowed. Does it pose any overload or overheating of conductors?Thank you very much!

Okay, let's break down your concerns about this situation. It sounds like you're right to be cautious. Here's a comprehensive analysis of the issues and potential solutions, keeping in mind the NYC electrical code (especially considering you're referencing the 2011 code, which might have some differences from current editions)

Core Concerns:
Voltage Drop

This is your primary worry, and rightfully so. A 250-foot run on a 120V circuit, even with #3 AWG copper, at 60A is
likely to exceed the allowable voltage drop, as you've calculated. Excessive voltage drop can damage equipment, cause lights to dim, and generally reduce system efficiency.

Shared Neutral (Grounded Conductor)

Sharing a neutral between multiple circuits can be problematic, especially with older installations. The big concern is

neutral current overload
. While ideally, the neutral only carries the imbalance between the phase currents, harmonic currents (produced by modern electronic loads) can cause the neutral current to exceed the ampacity of the conductor, even if the phase currents are within limits. Feeder Loading

Loading #3 AWG conductors to 60A is right at the edge of their ampacity, according to the 2011 NEC, and depending on the conductor insulation type.


Code Compliance (2011 NYC Electrical Code)

NYC has its own amendments to the NEC. You need to verify that the existing installation and any modifications you make comply with the 2011 (or current) NYC Electrical Code, including any local amendments or interpretations.

Safety

Any system pushed to its limits, especially in an older building, has a higher potential for overheating, insulation breakdown, and ultimately, fire.

Detailed Analysis


Voltage Drop Calculation

You need to confirm your voltage drop calculation using a recognized formula (or a reliable online calculator). A common formula for voltage drop in a single-phase circuit is:

VD = (2  K  I  D) / CM
Where: VD = Voltage Drop (in volts) K = Direct-current constant; approximately 12.9 ohms/CMIL/ft for copper conductors. I = Current (in amps) D = One-way distance (in feet) CM = Circular Mils (conductor size). For #3 AWG copper, this is 52,620 CM (check a wire table to be certain).Plugging in your values:VD = (2 12.9 60 250) / 52620 = 7.35 VPercentage Voltage Drop:%VD = (VD / Source Voltage) 100 = (7.35 / 120) 100 = 6.125%

This confirms your concern.
A 6.125% voltage drop exceeds the typical 3% (for feeders) and 5% (total, including branch circuits) recommended limits. Remember to check the 2011 NYC code for specific allowable voltage drop limits - they might differ.2. Shared Neutral Concerns



Harmonic Currents

Modern appliances, lighting (especially LEDs), and electronic devices generate harmonic currents. These currents are
additive in a shared neutral. A neutral conductor sized based on the imbalance of fundamental (60Hz) currents might be significantly undersized when harmonics are present. This is a serious fire hazard.

NEC and NYC Code Requirements

Check the 2011 NEC and NYC code for requirements regarding shared neutrals in multi-family dwellings. Current code generally restricts the sharing of neutrals to specific conditions (e.g., multi-wire branch circuits from the same phase). An installation where multiple apartments are sharing a neutral is highly suspect.

Consider Neutral Current Measurement

Ideally, you'd use a clamp-on ammeter that can measure true RMS current (to capture harmonics) to determine the actual neutral current under various load conditions. This would give you hard data to back up your concerns.3.

Feeder Loading and Ampacity



#3 AWG Ampacity

Refer to the 2011 NEC (Table 310.16) and any NYC amendments. The ampacity of #3 AWG copper conductors depends on the insulation type (THHN, THWN, etc.) and the termination temperature rating of the equipment (60°C, 75°C, or 90°C). Typically #3 AWG can handle around 70 amps at 75C, which is common terminal temperature.

Derating Factors

Consider any derating factors for conduit fill, ambient temperature, or other conditions. If the conduit is packed with other conductors, or if the ambient temperature is high, you might need to reduce the allowable ampacity of the #3 AWG conductors.4.

Engineer's Load Calculation



Question the Load Calculation

A calculated load of 60A per apartment after combining three units seems low, especially considering modern living with increased electrical demands. Carefully review the engineer's load calculations to ensure they are realistic and account for all potential loads (lighting, appliances, HVAC, receptacles, etc.). It's possible the calculation is based on a diversity factor that's not appropriate for the combined apartments.

Future Proofing

Even if the current load is calculated to be 60A, consider the potential for future increases in electrical demand. It's generally wise to size the feeders to accommodate some level of future growth.5.

Existing Condition and Documentation



Documentation

Obtain as much documentation as possible about the existing electrical system, including: Original electrical drawings Load calculations (if available) Inspection reports Permits

Inspection

Conduct a thorough visual inspection of the existing electrical system, paying close attention to:
The condition of the conductors and insulation The integrity of the conduit The connections at the panelboards Signs of overheating (discoloration, burning)

Recommendations


Bring Your Concerns to the Client and Engineer (in Writing)

Document your concerns about the voltage drop, shared neutral, and load calculations
in writing. Explain the potential consequences of these issues (equipment damage, safety hazards, code violations).2.

Propose Solutions (and Their Costs)

Offer potential solutions and the associated costs. Here are some options:


Upgrade the Feeders

The most reliable solution is to upgrade the feeders to a larger conductor size. This will reduce voltage drop and increase ampacity. You might need to replace the conduit as well to accommodate larger conductors.

Dedicated Neutrals

Run dedicated neutral conductors for each apartment's feeder. This is the
safest solution to address the shared neutral issue.

Increase Voltage

If possible, you could explore increasing the voltage to 208V or 240V (depending on what's available in the building) to reduce the current draw and thus the voltage drop. This would require a complete panel and equipment changeout within the apartments.

Multiple Feeders

Consider running separate feeders to distribute the load more evenly. This might involve splitting the apartment into zones and running individual feeders to each zone.


Voltage Drop Compensation

As a last resort (and generally not recommended for residential applications), you might consider using voltage drop compensation devices (e.g., automatic voltage regulators). However, these devices are expensive and can introduce their own set of complexities.3.

Involve the Local Electrical Authority (NYC Department of Buildings)

If you have serious concerns about the safety or code compliance of the existing installation, consider contacting the NYC Department of Buildings (DOB) for guidance. They can provide clarification on code requirements and help ensure the installation is safe and compliant.4.

Obtain Permits and Inspections

Ensure that all work is performed under proper permits and is inspected by the NYC DOB. This is crucial for ensuring compliance with the NYC Electrical Code.5.

Document Everything

Keep detailed records of all inspections, calculations, discussions, and work performed.

Important Considerations for NYC



NYC Electrical Code Amendments

The NYC Electrical Code is based on the NEC but has its own unique amendments. You
must be familiar with these amendments and ensure that your work complies with them.

NYC DOB Regulations

The NYC DOB has its own regulations and procedures for electrical work. You need to be aware of these regulations and follow them carefully.*

Licensed Electrical Contractors

Electrical work in NYC generally requires a licensed electrical contractor. Make sure you are working within the scope of your license.

In summary, your concerns are valid. The existing installation appears to be pushing the limits and potentially violating code. The best course of action is to thoroughly investigate the situation, document your concerns, and propose solutions that prioritize safety and code compliance, with the ultimate goal of getting NYC DOB approval of the design.
Good luck with the project! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question