User: Smash, Location: Philadelphia suburbs, PA USA
Asked on: Monday, October 14, 2024 at 8:35 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:55 am EST
Question: Got a warehouse with 50 UFOs the fixtures are already purchased by the owner with a utility company rebate. So the fixture style is not negotiable. It’s a 200W TCP high bay UFO with an attachment cord only. There is no way to hardwire in and out of these no knock outs can’t drill any you’ll void the warranty. So plug receptacle, is my choice. There’s an overhead crane which runs the entire length of the 240ft building it creates vibration on the steel. So now my cost I need twist lock 240V plug and matching receptacle $20 I attachment hook $5 1900 deep box and single whole cover my cost is about $45 each not counting any wiring, connectors, or jack chain that’s $2250.00 for 50 fixtures. Anyone know a better cheaper way ? I thought of sleeving the cord in greenfield and hardwiring but pretty sure that’s not per code.
Okay, this is a tricky situation. You're right, sleeving the cord in Greenfield and hardwiring is likely not to code (and would also void the warranty). Here's a breakdown of your options and potential cost-saving measures, weighing code compliance and practicality
Understanding the Challenges:
UFO Fixture Limitations
The sealed nature of the UFO fixtures makes this tough. No modifications allowed.
Crane Vibration
This is a key concern. It eliminates anything flimsy and requires secure connections.
Code Compliance
This is paramount. We need to ensure whatever you do meets electrical codes.
Cost
Finding a balance between safety, reliability, and budget.
Analyzing Your Current Approach
Your current plan with the twist-lock receptacles is solid and safe, if installed correctly. It's reliable and allows for easy fixture replacement. The cost is your major concern.
Potential Cost-Saving Strategies (With Considerations)
Evaluate Plug/Receptacle Alternatives
Cheaper Twist-Lock Brands
Shop around! Look at brands like Leviton, Hubbell, or Pass & Seymour through electrical supply houses. Bulk discounts can often be negotiated. A reliable local supplier may be more willing to work with you on cost than a big box store.
Lower Amp Rating (if appropriate)
200W at 240V is less than 1 amp. If your local code allows it, can you use a lower amperage twist-lock receptacle? This might bring the cost down a bit.
Consider a Short Cord
Are the cords on the UFOs excessively long? A shorter cord would reduce weight and potential for strain on the connection. (Be very careful when shortening cords and be sure to do it right.)2.
Optimize Mounting Hardware
Consider a "Pancake" or Shallow Box
If the fixture cords are very short, a thinner box might be an option. Be absolutely certain you have enough room for code-compliant wire connections inside the box. This won't save a ton but every little bit helps.
Explore alternative J-Hooks or Cable Supports
Instead of a separate hook and chain, are there integrated J-hooks or other cable support systems that would be more economical and still secure? Consider options that clamp to the building structure or beam.
Bulk Purchase Discounts
If you can buy all the boxes, covers, plugs, receptacles, and support hardware from one supplier, you can often negotiate a better price.
Metal vs. Plastic Boxes
Depending on local code, a plastic box might be acceptable. Metal is generally more durable, but plastic could save a few dollars per box.3.
Efficient Installation Practices
Pre-Assembly
Pre-assemble as much as possible on the ground to save time.
Proper Wire Management
Use the correct connectors and wiring methods to minimize waste and ensure neat, code-compliant installations.
Consider Labor Costs
If saving a few dollars on materials significantly increases labor time, it might not be worth it.4.
Important Considerations on Hardwiring & Warranty
Don't Void the Warranty
This is a big one. The rebate likely has conditions tied to the warranty. Voiding it could cost the owner a lot more than the savings you're looking for.5.
Ask the Utility Company
Explain the situation to the utility company representative who arranged the rebate. They may have encountered this problem before and have suggestions or even pre-approved alternative installation methods that still qualify for the rebate.
Code Compliance is KEY
Local Codes
Consult with your local electrical inspector before making any changes to the plan. They can tell you specifically what is allowed and what isn't in your jurisdiction.
Strain Relief
Ensure all cords have proper strain relief at both the fixture and the junction box.
Secure Mounting
The junction boxes must be securely mounted to the building structure to withstand vibration.
A Word of Caution about Greenfield/Flexible Conduit
While sleeving the cord in Greenfield might seem like a cheaper alternative, it's highly unlikely to be code-compliant unless the fixture cord is specifically rated for that application. Cords are typically not rated for use inside conduit. Furthermore, you'd need proper connectors at both ends of the conduit, and the whole setup would need to be grounded. This could quickly become as expensive or more expensive than the twist-lock receptacle approach.
Example Scenario (Illustrative - Confirm with your local Inspector)
Cheaper Twist-Lock Receptacles
You find a reliable brand (e.g., Leviton) twist-lock receptacle and plug set for $15 each instead of $20.
Pancake Box
You find a thin "pancake" box for $5 instead of a deep 1900 box.
Simpler Cable Support
You find a J-hook type support that clamps to the I-beam for $3.
Revised Cost
(Receptacle/Plug) $15 (Box/Cover) $5 (Hook) $3
Total: $23/fixture Total for 50 fixtures: $1150Important Steps
Talk to your Local Electrical Inspector
This is the most important* step. Get their input and approval.2.
Shop Around
Get quotes from multiple electrical suppliers.3.
Consider Labor
Factor in the cost of labor when comparing different solutions.4.
Prioritize Safety and Code Compliance.
Good luck! This is a common problem, and there's usually a workable solution that balances cost, safety, and compliance. Flag for review