User: Electrical_Hazard, Location: Mexico
Asked on: Tuesday, October 15, 2024 at 4:14 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:55 am EST
Question: I am not a qualified and certified electrician. However I have wired places including this place and it works.Living in another country rather than my country of origin which was USA. and experiencing a different way of doing things where rather than ground with a copper rod in the ground near the circuit box instead everything is grounded through the building's neutral. So there are only 2 wires coming from the external circuit breaker into the apartment. So the blue wires were connected to metal posts sticking out into the space from the outlets AS standard construction here in this country is to have these ground posts on the outlets rather than holes like in America.When I wired the boxes in here I found that the blue lines were connected both to the return ports for the cords in the outlets and also what I considered to be the 'ground' posts. This seemed unsafe to me because there was one of the 2 lines from the wire connected where it could be touched by anyone simply touching that outward facing ground post.In the USA we don't have a ground post sticking out of our outlet that you can touch but only a jack/port/hole where the power cords ground post will go into. So when I replaced all the old outlets I used 2 hole outlets (no ground) and didn't include the ground according to the local convention I was seeing. Basically took the bonding neutral posts off everywhere in my place so nothing grounds, similar to the old 1930s style I found in my grandparents' house in America before we updated there, since there was no official 3rd ground line available. Of course you may think this is unsafe because what if one of the items should somehow have a worn cable sleeving and then become hot right?Everything worked fine with a few irritating surges that turned on touch switched lights which may have come from a compressor on a fridge. I figure this has nothing to do with my wiring and only to do with a fridge compressor coming on and causing a surge that overpowers the touch switches. There was one strange incident in the building when the power of only our area of the building (10 apartments) once went out last year. Only happened once. No explanation but when I looked around the power was on elsewhere. Lasted a short while but someone must have fixed it. At the time it happened no one was actively doing anything in my apartment.When I wired the place I traced back all wires to their source wire thru the plaster or soft block walls here, and replaced most of the cables but not quite all. I even pulled the cables out of the temporary cement floor spaces where they were and replaced with new cables. All the hot are hot and all the neutral are neutral but I need to test. Everything worked here for a year and a half with just those weird couple things I mentioned to say otherwise the touch lights and then the one time the power went out around this stairwell, which was totally abnormal. I don't want to be the weakest link hereSo I want to test each outlet to make sure the main is the main and return is return. at every one of the umpteen outlets in the place here. Before the electrician from the company comes to do some replacements to add ground posts which are recommended by the local company. So what to do to test this? Simple amp meter how can I test this?
Okay, I understand your situation and concerns. You've encountered a very different wiring system than what you're used to in the US, and you've adapted it in a way that makes you uneasy. It's good that you're taking steps to understand and potentially improve the safety of your apartment's electrical system.
First and foremost, a disclaimer
I am an AI and cannot provide electrical advice. Working with electricity can be dangerous, and even fatal, if not done correctly. What I'm about to describe involves working with live wires, and doing it wrong can lead to shock, fire, and electrocution. Please consider hiring a qualified electrician for any electrical work, especially if you're unsure about any aspect of it.
Your Situation & Concerns No Dedicated Ground
The biggest issue is the lack of a dedicated grounding conductor. Connecting "ground" to the neutral is a practice that can create dangerous situations if the neutral connection is compromised.
"Ground" Posts Connected to Neutral
This is the source of your worry, and rightfully so. If the neutral wire breaks somewhere upstream, any appliance connected to those "ground" posts could become energized with the full line voltage, making them a shock hazard.
Two-Wire Outlets (No Ground)
You removed the connection to the neutral, which is better than having the ground posts connected to the neutral, but the issue is now any shorts from the line to the chassis of the appliance (say a broken fan wire) will not trip the breaker and the chassis of the appliance could energize.
Surges and Electrical Events
The touch switch issues and the power outage are potentially related to wiring problems, voltage fluctuations, or other issues in the building's electrical system.
Why This Setup is Problematic (Simplified) Fault Current Path
In a properly grounded system, if a fault (short circuit) occurs, the current flows through the ground wire back to the source, tripping the circuit breaker and cutting off power. Without a dedicated ground, this fault current might not have a clear path, potentially flowing through you if you touch a faulty appliance.
Neutral Problems
If the neutral wire becomes loose or disconnected upstream, the current can try to find its way back to the source through other paths, including the "ground" connections, potentially energizing appliance chassis.
Surges
Without a proper ground, surge protection is limited, and surges can more easily damage sensitive electronics.
Testing the Outlets (Polarity Check)
You want to verify that the "hot" and "neutral" wires are correctly connected to the outlets before the electrician comes in. Here's what you can do
Tools You'll Need (Important Safety Gear):
Multimeter
A digital multimeter is essential. Make sure it's in good working order and rated for the voltage in your country.
Non-Contact Voltage Tester (NCVT)
A "voltage pen" that detects voltage without touching the wires is highly recommended for basic safety. Use this to ensure that what you think is dead is actually dead.
Safety Glasses
Always protect your eyes.
Insulated Gloves
Wear rubber insulated gloves rated for the voltage you'll be working with.
Appropriate Clothing
Wear clothes that are not loose and have no metal.
Voltage Tester for Multimeter
a hot stick tester for confirming voltage on the multimeter that you have
Testing Procedure (Use Extreme Caution)
Turn Off the Circuit Breaker
Absolutely crucial! Before touching any wires, turn off the circuit breaker that feeds the outlet you're testing. Double-check that the power is off using your Non-Contact Voltage Tester (NCVT). Just touching the tester to the socket is enough to tell you if there is electricity.2. Open the Outlet
Carefully remove the outlet cover plate and gently pull the outlet out of the box.3.
Visual Inspection
Look for any obvious signs of damage: loose wires, burnt insulation, melted plastic, etc.4.
Voltage Measurement (AC Voltage)
Set your multimeter to measure AC voltage (VAC). Start with a range higher than your country's voltage (e.g., 200V or 250V). Carefully touch the multimeter probes to the two terminals of the outlet (where the wires are connected).
If the power is truly off, the multimeter should read close to 0 volts. If it doesn't, stop immediately and re-check the breaker and the voltage tester. Turn the breaker on If the power is turned on correctly, the multimeter should read the voltage expected of the country in question Turn the breaker off Disconnect the wires to test individually without confusion5. Wire Identification (Polarity)
After insuring the breaker is off and testing with a no contact voltage tester, set the multimeter to measure continuity and confirm that the neutral wire is continuous with the neutral wire at the electrical service panel.6.
Reassemble Carefully
Once you've verified the polarity, carefully put the outlet back into the box and replace the cover plate.
Important Considerations Don't Assume
Never assume that the wiring is correct or that the labels are accurate. Always test.
Work in a Well-Lit Area
Good lighting helps prevent mistakes.
Take Your Time
Electrical work is not something to rush.
When in Doubt, Ask a Professional
If you're not comfortable with any part of this process, or if you find something that doesn't seem right, call a qualified electrician.
What About Ground Posts?
The electrician from the company suggests adding ground posts. This is a good first step but may require additional wiring such as running ground wires through the walls.
In summary
Your current setup is potentially unsafe. You've taken a step in the right direction by removing the connection to the neutral, but there's still no proper grounding. The testing procedure I've described will help you verify the wiring of the outlets, but it's only a small part of the overall safety picture.*
The best course of action is to have a qualified electrician evaluate your apartment's electrical system and make recommendations for improvements. Flag for review