User: scottwnuwer, Location: Port Charlotte, FL
Asked on: Tuesday, October 15, 2024 at 10:20 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:56 am EST
Question: After Hurricane Milton, we are experiencing several homes along the coast that have had load centers/main breakers either just above, at, or below the level of flood waters. Sometimes only the enclosure or cabinet received flooding (without submerging the load side wiring), and sometimes the bottom few breaker spaces on the busbar received flooding. First, I would like to know thoughts on trying to salvage the busbar and main breaker if only the bottom of the enclosure received flooding. Second, if the flood water did make it up to the few bottom breaker spaces, what is everyones thought on attempting to flush out the busbar and blow it out. Almost all of the flood damaged equipment is copper tinned bus, and the enclosure is located on the gulf of Mexico anyways. Typically the outdoor electrical enclosure only lasts 5-15 years anyways. I read the NEMA article mentioning reconditioning of panelboards, which I imagine would require a recertification. My thought is to flush out the enclosure, blow dry, hilco lube the connections, and recommend total replacement within 90 days. It has only been a little over a week from the storm and most connections seem solid. I only mention this possible approach because I am becoming overwhelmed with customers, and would like to provide a temporary solution to restore power so they can return home and live in the upstairs portion, and guarantee a panel change for the future. Thoughts?
Okay, this is a complex situation with a lot of factors to consider. You're right to be cautious and thorough, balancing the urgent need for power restoration with the long-term safety and reliability of the electrical systems. Here's a breakdown of my thoughts on your proposed actions, considering the potential risks and liabilities
General Principles & Concerns
Safety First
Floodwater is contaminated, and electrical components that have been submerged are inherently compromised. Water conducts electricity, leading to corrosion, short circuits, and potential fire hazards.
Code Compliance
Any repair or temporary solution MUST adhere to local and national electrical codes (NEC). Deviations from these codes can create significant legal liability if a future incident occurs.
Long-Term vs. Short-Term
The goal is to ensure the property is safe for the occupants, and there is no compromise on safety.
Documentation is Key
Meticulously document everything you do, including the extent of the flooding, the components affected, the steps you take to mitigate the damage, and your recommendations for long-term solutions. Photos and videos are essential.
Liability
Understand that any work you perform on a flood-damaged electrical system carries a significant liability risk. Consult with your insurance provider and legal counsel about your potential exposure.
Corrosion Rate
Salt water is extremely corrosive, which can lead to rapid degradation.
Specific Scenarios & Recommendations1. Enclosure Flooded (Wiring Intact Above Water Level) Risk Assessment
This is the least risky scenario, but still requires careful evaluation. Check the enclosure's integrity. Are there signs of rust, warping, or damage that could compromise its ability to protect the components?
Your Proposed Approach
Flushing out the enclosure: If the enclosure only contains disconnects, breakers, and busbars, this is an acceptable practice. Blow drying: A great step to get rid of excess moisture. Hilco Lubing the connections: Avoid using petroleum products, as this can breakdown the rubber. Use dielectric grease on the connections.
Recommend total replacement within 90 days
Be prepared to be liable if it does not get replaced in 90 days. Consider requiring the contract to require replacement.
Important Considerations
Grounding
Pay special attention to the grounding connections. Floodwater can corrode these connections, making them ineffective. Verify the integrity of the grounding electrode system (ground rod, water pipe connection, etc.).
GFCI/AFCI Protection
Test all GFCI and AFCI breakers to ensure they are functioning correctly. Floodwater can damage these sensitive devices.
Insulation Resistance
If possible, perform an insulation resistance test (Megger test) on the branch circuit wiring to identify any compromised insulation.
Inspection
Visually inspect all conductors for signs of corrosion, water damage, or physical stress.
2. Floodwater Reached Bottom Breaker Spaces This is a high-risk scenario. Salvaging the Busbar & Main Breaker
Strongly Discourage this practice
The risk of latent damage, corrosion, and future failures is too high. Attempting to "clean and dry" a busbar that has been submerged in floodwater is, in my opinion, NOT a reliable solution.
Corrosion
Saltwater can penetrate the busbar and breaker components, leading to corrosion that may not be immediately visible. This corrosion can weaken the connections, increase resistance, and eventually lead to overheating and fire.
Breaker Reliability
Breakers are complex mechanical devices. Floodwater can deposit sediment and debris inside the breaker mechanism, affecting its ability to trip properly in an overcurrent or short-circuit condition.
Even after cleaning and drying, residual contamination can lead to future problems. Flushing Out the Busbar (Discouraged)
Even if you flush out the busbar, you cannot guarantee that all contaminants have been removed. The small crevices and hidden areas within the busbar assembly can trap moisture and corrosive substances.
Your Proposed Approach (Temporary Power Restoration)
This is where the ethical and liability considerations become very important. Absolutely Required
Document the situation in detail and obtain a signed waiver from the homeowner acknowledging the risks involved in using a potentially compromised electrical system. This waiver should clearly state that the temporary repairs are NOT a substitute for a complete panel replacement and that you recommend immediate replacement within a specified timeframe (30-90 days).
If Possible, Isolate Affected Circuits
If only the bottom few breaker spaces were flooded, consider isolating the circuits connected to those breakers. De-energize those circuits at the breaker and cap off the wires safely within the panel. This reduces the risk of those compromised circuits causing problems.
Replace the Main Breaker (If Submerged)
At a minimum, replace the main breaker with a new, properly rated breaker.
GFCI Protection for Critical Circuits
Ensure that all critical circuits (refrigeration, lighting, outlets) are protected by GFCI breakers, especially if the wiring has been potentially compromised.
Continuous Monitoring
Advise the homeowner to continuously monitor the panel for any signs of overheating, flickering lights, or unusual smells.
Reiterate Need for Replacement
Constantly emphasize the need for a complete panel replacement as soon as possible.
Why Replacement is Essential
Peace of Mind
A new panel eliminates the uncertainty and risk associated with a flood-damaged system.
Long-Term Reliability
A new panel provides a reliable and safe electrical system for years to come.
Code Compliance
A new panel will be installed according to current electrical codes.
Insurance Requirements
Many insurance companies will require a complete panel replacement after a flood event.
Alternative Approach for Temporary Power (if possible, and permitted by local codes)
Temporary Service Panel
Install a small, temporary service panel (fed from the utility) to power essential circuits for the upstairs living area. This isolates the flood-damaged panel entirely and provides a safer temporary solution.
Generator with Transfer Switch
A generator with a properly installed transfer switch can provide temporary power, but ensure the generator is located safely away from the flooded area.
Key Takeaways & Recommendations1. Prioritize Safety
Err on the side of caution. Flood-damaged electrical equipment is a hazard.2.
Documentation is Critical
Meticulously document the damage, your actions, and your recommendations.3.
Liability Considerations
Consult with your insurance provider and legal counsel to understand your potential liability.4.
Replacement is the Best Solution
Strongly recommend and document the need for a complete panel replacement.5.
Temporary Solutions Require Caution & Waivers
If you provide a temporary solution, obtain a signed waiver from the homeowner and clearly outline the risks involved.6.
Consider a Temporary Service Panel or Generator
These alternatives can provide safer temporary power options.
Important Disclaimer: This information is for general guidance only and should not be substituted for the advice of a qualified and licensed electrician. You are responsible for ensuring that all work performed complies with local and national electrical codes. Flag for review