User: DaneD, Location: MA, USA
Asked on: Tuesday, October 15, 2024 at 3:32 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:57 am EST
Question: Running into an issue with the AHJ over a pre-existing UG feed in PVC. Our customer has a barn with a 60A sub panel with a 6/2 UG wire feed through 100 feet of 1 1/2" PVC conduit back to the house main (40A breaker), sub panel has neutral/ground bond. Our design is to remove the 6/2 UG wire from the conduit and run 4 XHHW-2 6 AWG aluminum cable feed from the main panel to the sub panel in the barn, remove the bond in the sub panel, and add a GEC at the barn. Sounds reasonable right? AHJ agreed to this part of the solution.The new 4.6 Kw PV system will be a 12 panel array with Enphase micros split into 2 strings. This requires 4 more 12G copper XHHW-2 wires for the 2 strings, plus an additional 12G copper XHHW-2 wire for the PV system ground. So in total, the 1 1/2" conduit will have four 6 AWG and five 12 AWG wires. There will be a junction box on the exterior of the house where the wiring will be separated, solar to the Enphase combiner and the 4 #6 wires into the house to the main for the barn power. The junction box will have continuous feeds, this is only to separate the 2 sources appropratly.We have done similar configurations in the same jurisdiction in the past without any issues, however the new AHJ is refusing to sign off on this citing that 2 different power sources cannot be enclosed in the same PVC. I can't find anything in our code saying this is not allowed. Homeowner does not want to dig up the sod for an additional PVC run. Is there something in the NEC I am mising? The AHJ isn't providing any specific code that does not allow this.
You're on the right track. The AHJ's objection seems unfounded, and you're right to question it. Here's a breakdown of why you're likely correct and how to proceed with the AHJ
Understanding the Situation
Barn Subpanel
Your plan to upgrade the feeder with properly sized aluminum conductors, remove the neutral-ground bond at the subpanel, and install a ground rod is textbook correct for a detached structure with a subpanel.
PV System
Adding the PV system is also fine. The PV system needs to be wired correctly and grounded.
Common Conduit
Sharing the conduit for both AC power and PV conductors is generally permissible,
provided all conductors are insulated for the highest voltage present in the raceway. In your case, since you're using XHHW-2, which is rated for 600V, this is likely satisfied. Junction Box
A properly installed junction box to separate the circuits is a standard practice.
Why the AHJ is Likely Wrong (and How to Respond)
The AHJ is likely mistaken. Here's why, and how to address their concerns:1. No Explicit Prohibition in NEC for Mixed Systems
There is no blanket NEC rule preventing AC power conductors and PV source/output circuit conductors from sharing a raceway if specific conditions are met. However, the key is compliance with specific sections of the NEC.2.
Key NEC Sections to Focus On (2023 NEC edition)
(Check your local jurisdiction for adopted code year)
300.3(C)(1) Conductors of Different Systems This section states that conductors of different systems shall be permitted in the same raceway, cable, trench, or enclosure where they are insulated for the maximum voltage of any conductor in the raceway. 690.31(B) Wiring Methods on, Under, and Inside Buildings. Wiring methods on or in buildings shall comply with 300.11, 300.15, and other applicable articles of this Code. 690.4(B) Systems with grounded and ungrounded circuit conductors. Systems with grounded and ungrounded circuit conductors shall comply with 300.3(C)(1).
3. Overfilling Conduit Considerations You must perform a conduit fill calculation using Chapter 9, Table 1 and Table 4 of the NEC. A 1 1/2" PVC conduit might be tight with the 4 #6 Al and 5 #12 Cu wires. This is the most likely area where you might have an issue. Use a wire fill calculator to ensure you are within the fill limits (typically 40% for existing conduits). If it is overfilled, this is a legitimate reason for rejection. It is very close to the limit. Important Note
Aluminum conductors are generally larger than copper conductors for the same ampacity. Be certain of the exact outer diameter of the specific conductors you plan to use (check the manufacturer's specifications).
Your Response to the AHJ1. Respectful Inquiry
Start by politely asking the AHJ for the specific NEC section they believe prohibits this installation. Frame it as a request for clarification to ensure you're meeting all requirements.2.
Present Your Case
If the AHJ can't cite a specific code section (or cites one that doesn't clearly apply), present your argument, referencing the NEC sections listed above.3.
Conduit Fill Calculation
Provide the conduit fill calculation showing that the conductors fit within the 40% fill limit. This is crucial.4.
Written Documentation
If possible, put your argument in writing (email is fine). This creates a record of your communication and can be helpful if you need to appeal the decision.5.
Appeal if Necessary
If the AHJ remains unconvinced and cannot provide a valid code reference, explore the appeals process outlined by your local jurisdiction.
Potential Complications and Considerations Local Amendments
Be aware that your local jurisdiction may have amended the NEC, adding restrictions. Review your local codes carefully.
AHJ Interpretation
Sometimes, AHJs have a particular interpretation of the code, even if it's not explicitly stated. Try to understand their reasoning and address their underlying concerns.*
Practical Considerations
While code-compliant, stuffing a conduit to its maximum fill capacity can make pulling wires difficult. It also makes future maintenance or modifications harder. Consider the long-term implications.
In summary: The AHJ's objection is likely incorrect, provided you're using properly insulated conductors, perform an accurate conduit fill calculation, and comply with all other applicable NEC requirements. Address their concerns with clear, code-based explanations. Be polite but firm in your understanding of the code. Flag for review