Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: System furniture

User: hhsting, Location: Glen bunie, md, us

Asked on: Wednesday, October 16, 2024 at 9:17 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 3:59 am EST

Question: I have system furniture where two hots are #12 awg but neutral is #10 awg fsd from 20A breaker.Should the equipment grounding conductor be #10 awg or 12 awg based off of NEC 2017 Article 250.122(B)? I am confused

Okay, let's break down this confusing situation regarding equipment grounding conductor (EGC) sizing. You're dealing with a system furniture situation where the hots are #12 AWG, the neutral is #10 AWG, fed from a 20A breaker. You're unsure whether the EGC needs to be #10 or #12 AWG based on NEC 2017 250.122(B).Here's the analysis and the correct answer

Understanding the Code Sections
NEC 250.122(A)

This is the
primary rule for EGC sizing. It states the EGC must be sized according to Table 250.122, which bases the EGC size on the rating of the overcurrent protective device (OCPD) protecting the circuit.

NEC 250.122(B)

This section is the exception or "Where Circuit Conductors are Increased in Size." It's this exception that's causing your confusion. It says that if the ungrounded (hot) conductors are increased in size for any reason (voltage drop, etc.), the equipment grounding conductor shall be increased proportionally.

Analysis of Your Situation
1. Overcurrent Protection

You have a 20A breaker.2.

Normal Sizing (Based on 250.122(A) and Table 250.122)

A 20A breaker requires a #12 AWG EGC. This is the base requirement.3.

Your Specific Scenario

The neutral is #10 AWG, but the hots are #12 AWG.4.

Applying 250.122(B) Correctly



Are the hot conductors increased in size?
No, the hot conductors are #12 AWG, which is adequate for a 20A circuit. They have not been increased from what is required by the overcurrent protective device. The neutral is larger, but that doesn't trigger 250.122(B). Section 250.122(B) specifically addresses increasing the size of the ungrounded (hot) conductors. It does not address increasing the size of the neutral conductor. The neutral is considered a current carrying conductor and often increased for voltage drop or other considerations.

Conclusion

Based on NEC 2017, the equipment grounding conductor should be #12 AWG. NEC 250.122(A) and Table 250.122 dictate that the EGC be sized based on the 20A overcurrent protection. Since the hot conductors were not increased in size, 250.122(B) does not apply.

Important Considerations



The larger neutral is likely for voltage drop or harmonic mitigation reasons.
This is perfectly acceptable, but it doesn't force you to upsize the EGC. Local Amendments

Always check for any local amendments to the NEC in your jurisdiction. Some jurisdictions may have stricter requirements.

Good Practice (but not required)

Using a #10 AWG EGC wouldn't
violate the code, and in some situations, a larger EGC is beneficial for lower impedance. However, in your specific case, it's not required.



System Furniture Listing

Pay very close attention to the system furniture manufacturer's instructions and listing. The listing may contain special requirements or restrictions about conductor sizes. If the manufacturer specifies a #10 AWG EGC, then you must follow their instructions.

Recommendation


Confirm with the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction). It's always best to get clarification from your local electrical inspector.2.

Review the system furniture manufacturer's documentation. This is crucial.3.

Default to #12 AWG unless the manufacturer or AHJ dictates otherwise.

In summary, the fact that the neutral is #10 AWG doesn't automatically require you to upsize the EGC to #10 AWG. The EGC sizing is primarily based on the overcurrent device size. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question