Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Residential Load Calculations and 25% of Largest Motor

User: winterovereverything, Location: California

Asked on: Wednesday, October 16, 2024 at 1:23 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:00 am EST

Question: Hey Everyone,Maybe I'm a bit dense (as usual) here but what's the score for using AC units in a residential load calculation when factoring in 25% of the largest motor? I know some people say that you should always factor it in but others argue that so long as the furnace is used in the load calculation, we drop air conditioning all together and rely on loads like garbage disposals or trash compactors for our largest motors. Maybe I'm missing something, but I'd like to hear what you guys think.-WOVE

Okay, WOVE, let's break down the A/C unit situation in residential load calculations and clear up the confusion. You're hitting on a common point of debate and interpretation.

The Core Issue: Article 220.50, 220.51, 220.52 and 220.53 of the National Electrical Code (NEC)

The relevant sections of the NEC that govern this are primarily Article 220, specifically around calculating general loads, appliance loads, and motor loads. 220.50 Appliances. Appliance load calculations, and other information pertaining to appliances, can be found in Art. 220.51 through 220.
53.
220.51 Electric Clothes Dryers — Dwelling Unit(s). The feeder or service rating shall be determined in accordance with 220.51(A) through (C). The ampacity of the neutral conductor shall be determined in accordance with 220.
61.(A) Method for Determining Feeder or Service Load. Feeder or service load shall be 5 kVA or the nameplate rating, whichever is larger, for each dryer served.(B) Demand Factors. Where 4 or more dryers are served by a feeder or service, the load shall be permitted to be calculated using the demand factors in Table 220.51.(C) Commercial Dryers. Commercial dryers shall be calculated at the nameplate rating. 220.52 Electric Ranges and Cooking Appliances — Dwelling Unit(s). The feeder or service load shall be permitted to be calculated in accordance with Table 220.55. It shall be permissible to add the nameplate ratings of all household cooking appliances rated more than 1.75 kW but not more than 8.75 kW and multiply the sum by the demand factors specified in Table 220.
55. Where the nameplate rating of a household cooking appliance exceeds 8.75 kW, the maximum demand in Column C shall be used. Where the nameplate rating of a range is not specified, the nameplate rating shall be considered to be 8 kW.
Exception No. 1: The nameplate rating of household cooking appliances used to compute the maximum demand in Column C of Table 220.55 shall be permitted to be used instead of the derating factors given in Column A or B of the table.

Exception No. 2: Two or more single-phase ranges shall be permitted to be connected to a three-phase feeder in accordance with 220.55. 220.53 Kitchen Equipment — Other Than Dwelling Unit(s). It shall be permissible to size the feeder or service to kitchen equipment in accordance with Table 220.56.

Here's the Breakdown of the Debate and How to Approach It


Understanding the Goal

The purpose of a load calculation is to determine the minimum ampacity of the service entrance conductors (and feeders) needed to safely and reliably supply all the anticipated electrical loads in the dwelling. We want to avoid undersizing (which could lead to overloads and hazards) but also avoid grossly oversizing (which is costly).2.

Air Conditioning vs. Heating

This is the crucial point. NEC guidelines prevent you from double-counting loads that are unlikely to operate simultaneously at full capacity.

Article 220.60 (Noncoincident Loads)

Allows you to
omit one of two (or more) noncoincident loads. The classic example is heating and air conditioning. You typically don't run both at 100% simultaneously.

Key Consideration

Local climate. In areas with very mild winters and hot summers, the A/C load might realistically be higher and more consistent than the heating load. In that case, you'd base your calculation on the A/C and omit the heating.3.

The 25% of Largest Motor Rule

This refers to Article 430, which deals with motor circuits and overload protection. Specifically, it requires you to add 25% of the full-load current of the largest motor to the sum of all other loads.

The A/C Conundrum

The A/C unit contains a motor (the compressor). The question is,
is it the largest motor in the dwelling?4.

The Common Scenarios and How to Handle Them



Scenario 1: Furnace AND A/C Present AND Furnace Chosen as Main Load (Common in Many Climates)

If you've decided to use the furnace load (and omit the A/C load per 220.60), you still need to consider motors. Look at the furnace. Furnaces typically have a blower motor. Is the blower motor larger (in terms of horsepower or full-load amps) than the A/C compressor motor? If so, the 25% rule applies to the furnace blower motor, not the A/C. If the blower motor is smaller than the A/C compressor, then you would use the A/C compressor as the largest motor for the 25% rule.

Scenario 2: A/C is Chosen as Main Load (e.g., Very Mild Winter)

If you've decided to base your calculation on the A/C and omit the furnace, then the A/C compressor is almost certainly the largest motor. You
must include 25% of its full-load current in the total load calculation.

Scenario 3: A/C and Electric Heat

If you have electric resistance heating AND A/C, this gets tricky. You might be able to omit one (depending on local climate and realistic use), but you need to carefully consider the total load of the electric heating elements vs. the A/C. It is possible that the electric heat is a significantly larger load than the A/C, and you would use that for your calculation. Don't automatically assume you can omit the electric heat.

Scenario 4: Other Large Motors

Don't forget to look for other potential large motors. A well pump, a large permanently installed shop compressor, or even some high-end garbage disposals can have significant motors. Compare the full-load amps of
all motors to determine the largest.

Key Takeaways and a Suggested Approach



Don't Double Count

You generally can't include both A/C and heating at 100%. Choose the larger load based on local climate and anticipated use. Document your reasoning.

Identify ALL Motors

Make a list of
every motor in the dwelling (A/C, furnace blower, well pump, disposal, etc.). Get the full-load amp (FLA) rating for each. The A/C compressor and well pumps tend to be the highest rated of the bunch.

Determine the Largest Motor

Based on FLA, identify the largest motor.

Apply the 25% Rule

Add 25% of the FLA of the largest motor to the rest of the calculated load.


Use Good Judgement

The NEC is a minimum standard. If you have reason to believe a specific dwelling will have unusually high simultaneous loads (e.g., a home with a large workshop and multiple A/C units running all the time), consider increasing the service size accordingly. Consult with the homeowner to gain a better understanding of their anticipated usage.*

When in Doubt, Ask

If you're unsure, consult with a more experienced electrician or your local electrical inspector. They can provide guidance based on local interpretations and common practices.

In summary:
You're right to question the automatic inclusion of the A/C unit's motor for the 25% rule. It depends on whether you've included the A/C load in the first place, whether it's actually the largest motor, and whether you've properly considered all other potential large motor loads. Always base your decision on the specific circumstances of the dwelling and document your reasoning.Hope this helps! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question