User: Dennis Alwon, Location: Chapel Hill, NC
Asked on: Wednesday, October 16, 2024 at 5:03 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:01 am EST
Question: I read this to mean that any box smaller than 2 7/8" x 1 3/4" would follow the exception. The exception states that all conditions must be met.I have a door jamb box( for a jamb switch) that is 2 5/8" x 1 1/4". I have never seen them in metal. Could this mean that metal door jamb switches are not allowed assuming they all are smaller than 2 7/8" x 1 3/4"314.29(A)(1) Boxes 1650 cm3 (100 in.3) or Less in Size.The openings in the building surfaces, if reduced from the outer walls of the box, shall be centered not more than 25 mm (1 in.) from the centerline of the box, and shall not extend beyond the walls of the box. If rectangular, the opening shall be not less than 73 mm (2 7⁄8 in.) by 45 mm (1 3⁄4 in.) in size. If circular, the opening shall not be less than 90 mm (31⁄2 in.) in diameter.Exception:Smaller openings in building surfaces that accommodate one or more individual devices shall be permitted if all of the following conditions are met:(1)The outlet box that supplies the device(s) is nonmetallic.(2)The branch circuit wiring that supplies each device consists of a separate nonmetallic cable assembly originating outside the box, or individual sets of conductors in a single nonmetallic raceway, all of which originate outside the box. Other than the connections to a single device, these conductors are not spliced in the box or continued to another device, and no other wiring or raceways enter the box.(3)Each device is capable of removal from the building surface opening without being damaged. If a special tool is required for this purpose, the applicable circuit directory for the device records the location of the tool, together with a product code/QR code for acquiring a replacement if necessary.(4)All connections for each device to the branch circuit wiring are made with listed clamping-type wire connectors, which are supplied with the devices. The branch-circuit conductors are arranged to permit the connector(s) to be exposed after the device has been fully removed.(5)The device assemblies are listed for this application.
Your interpretation is partially correct, but let's break it down to clarify: You are correct
The exception states that all conditions (1 through 5) must be met for the smaller opening to be permitted. If any one of those conditions is not met, the exception does not apply, and the opening must meet the minimum size requirements outlined in the main section of 314.29(A)(1).
You are correct
If a metal door jamb box is smaller than 2 7/8" x 1 3/4" and any of the other conditions of the exception are not met (such as using a non-metallic box, non-metallic cable assembly, or having other splices or raceways entering the box, etc.), then it would not be compliant.
However
Your conclusion about metal door jamb switches might be premature. The passage is about
outlet boxes and building surface openings that accommodate a device. The box must be compliant with 314.29(A)(1), but it says nothing about what the device is made from. The switch itself being metal or non-metal is independent of this rule.
Regarding your specific door jamb box (2 5/8" x 1 1/4")
Size
Your box is smaller than 2 7/8" x 1 3/4".2.
Assuming you want a smaller opening
To use that smaller box size, you must meet all the conditions of the exception. This means: The box must be nonmetallic. The wiring must be a separate nonmetallic cable assembly that originates outside the box. No splices are allowed inside the box. The device must be easily removable. Connections must be made with listed clamping-type wire connectors.* The device assembly must be listed for this application.3.
Metal Boxes If the box used is metal you would be required to have an opening of 2 7/8" x 1 3/4".
In summary
The passage is not saying that metal door jamb switches are prohibited. The exception outlines the requirements that would allow for a smaller opening than 2 7/8" x 1 3/4".
Therefore, your assumption that metal door jamb boxes for switches are not allowed is not necessarily true. It depends on the type of switch, how the wiring is done, and whether the installer meets all the conditions of the exception or opts for a larger opening in the building surface. Flag for review