User: 3oFElectric, Location: Tennessee
Asked on: Wednesday, October 16, 2024 at 11:11 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:01 am EST
Question: Got a prospective client wanting to upgrade his main panel.The panel is located in the garage but is recessed into the wall in a sort of cubby. I've attached photos of the panel's current location.If I replaced the panel and left it in the same location, would I be in violation of workin space given its recessed 4 inches in this cubby?Also, just as an FYI the work bench beneath the panel is going to be removed so there will be a 36 inch working space in front of the panel.
Okay, let's analyze the panel's location and working space requirements based on the NEC (National Electrical Code). Keep in mind that local jurisdictions can amend the NEC, so verifying with your local AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction) is always the best practice before starting any work.
NEC Requirements for Working Space (Generally from NEC 110.26)
Depth of Working Space
This is the most relevant issue given your panel's recessed location. The depth of the working space in front of the panel is determined by the voltage to ground and presence of exposed live parts on the opposite side of the working space. In a typical residential scenario with a 120/240V panel and no exposed live parts on the opposite side, the minimum depth is usually
3 feet (36 inches). Your client removing the work bench satisfies this requirement. Width of Working Space
The width of the working space must be the width of the equipment or 30 inches, whichever is greater. The working space must allow at least a 90-degree opening of the equipment door(s) or hinged panels.
Height of Working Space
The working space must be clear and extend from the grade, floor, or platform to a height of 6 1/2 feet (2.0 m) or the height of the equipment, whichever is greater.
Illumination
Adequate illumination is required for the working space.
Headroom
Sufficient headroom needs to be provided for working on the panel.
Analysis of Your Situation
Recessed Panel & Depth
Yes, the 4-inch recess likely violates the working space requirements because it reduces the required 36" space. While the workbench being removed is helpful, the 4-inch recess effectively reduces the working space depth. The code requires the entire depth to be clear and unobstructed. Even though you have 36" after the recess, the code dictates a 36" space be clear starting from the front of the panel.2. Violation? The NEC addresses obstacles and obstructions in the required work space in NEC 110.26(A)(3). It says in part "equipment shall be so arranged that the workspace required by this section shall not be used for storage." While not explicitly "storage," the recess effectively makes the workspace smaller.3. Existing vs. New Panel: Because you are replacing the panel, the existing non-compliant location does not "grandfather" the new panel. An upgrade will require the panel to meet current code.
Solutions & Recommendations
Bring the Panel Flush with the Wall
The best solution is to bring the new panel flush with the surrounding wall. This could involve: Modifying the framing of the wall to eliminate the recess. Using extension collars (if available and approved by the panel manufacturer) to bring the panel's front cover flush with the wall. (This is less common).
Moving the Panel
If the cubby is simply not viable, you may need to relocate the panel to a different location within the garage.
Consult with the AHJ
Before you do anything, contact your local electrical inspector or AHJ. They are the final authority and can tell you if they will accept any particular solution or if they require you to move the panel completely. They may have seen this type of situation before and have specific guidance.
In Summary
The 4-inch recessed installation of the new panel will likely be considered a violation of NEC 110.26 due to the reduction of required working space. The best solutions are to bring the panel flush with the wall or relocate it entirely.
Always get approval from your local AHJ before starting the project. They can provide the final word and ensure your work meets local requirements. Flag for review