Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Inverter II AC Power Output Measurement

User: rashidtung, Location: Lahore, Pakistan

Asked on: Thursday, October 17, 2024 at 7:06 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:02 am EST

Question: 1. AC Power measured in the Solar Inverters2. Power measured at the Interconnections PointIn between the Point 1 and 2 we have 02 Transformer (Step up and Step Down) and a distance of 1 KM.The question is since it is a closed loop system the measurement of Power anywhere in this loop should measure the same Energy values.

You're thinking about energy conservation, which is correct in principle. However, the statement that the energy values will be the same "anywhere in this loop" is incorrect in a real-world scenario. Here's why: Losses

The two transformers (step-up and step-down) and the 1 km cable introduce losses in the form of heat. These losses are primarily due to:


Transformer Losses



Core Losses (Hysteresis and Eddy Current Losses)

Energy is lost in magnetizing and demagnetizing the transformer core. These losses are relatively constant regardless of the load.


Copper Losses (I²R Losses)

Current flowing through the transformer windings causes heat loss due to the resistance of the copper. These losses are proportional to the square of the current and thus increase with load.

Cable Losses (I²R Losses)

Similar to transformer copper losses, current flowing through the 1 km cable generates heat due to the cable's resistance. This is also proportional to the square of the current.


Other Losses

Minor losses can occur due to things like dielectric losses in the transformer insulation.

Measurement Accuracy

The accuracy of the power measurement equipment at the solar inverter and at the interconnection point is critical. Small errors in each measurement can add up to significant differences, especially over longer periods (hours, days, or months).


Phase shifts

Transformers introduce phase shifts, which are the shift in the phase of the voltage and current. Phase shifts are usually small, it can effect the measured power values.

Therefore, the power measured at the interconnection point will ALWAYS be lower than the power measured at the solar inverter.
The difference represents the energy lost in the transformers and the cable.

Here's a simplified equation

Power at Interconnection Point = Power at Solar Inverter - Transformer Losses - Cable Losses

Practical Considerations



Efficiency

Utility-grade transformers are designed for high efficiency (often 97-99% at or near their rated capacity). However, even a small percentage loss can be significant over time. Cable losses depend on the conductor size, the current flow (load), and the cable length.*

Monitoring

Many solar power systems have monitoring systems that track the power produced by the inverters and the power delivered to the grid. The difference between these values can be used to estimate the losses in the transmission system.

In summary:
While the principle of energy conservation holds true, the presence of losses in the transmission and transformation process makes it impossible for the power measured at the interconnection point to be exactly equal to the power measured at the solar inverter. These losses are an unavoidable reality in any electrical power system. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question