Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Budget - Commercial Project

User: Jimmy7, Location: Boston, MA

Asked on: Thursday, October 17, 2024 at 9:10 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:02 am EST

Question: I have been asked to look at drawings for a proposed commercial project in order to see if it is possible to bring the cost of the electrical down. I’m not bidding this project, I was just asked to look at it in order to help the designer. The building has classrooms, office space, and a small gym. What do you look for when to comes to decreasing a budget if you had to? I’m guessing if you were to switch from copper to aluminum on the service and feeders. Any other suggestions?

Okay, that's a great task to be asked to do. Offering cost-saving suggestions without compromising safety and functionality is a valuable skill. Here's a breakdown of areas to review and potential cost-reduction strategies for the electrical portion of a commercial project, covering more than just conductor material

I. Initial Assessment & General Philosophy
Understand the Design Intent

Before suggesting changes, make sure you understand
why certain decisions were made. Were there specific client requests? Code requirements beyond the minimum? Future expansion considerations? Don't just cut costs blindly.

Prioritize Safety & Code Compliance

Cost-cutting cannot compromise safety or violate electrical codes. Any suggested changes must be reviewed and approved by the responsible design engineer and relevant authorities.

Consider Life-Cycle Costs

The cheapest upfront option might not be the cheapest in the long run. Factor in energy efficiency, maintenance, and potential future upgrades. Sometimes a slightly higher initial investment can pay off significantly over the building's lifespan.


Documentation

Keep a detailed record of all suggested changes, the reasoning behind them, and the potential cost savings. This helps with transparency and accountability.

II. Specific Areas to Review for Cost Reduction


Here’s a breakdown of key areas to examine, ranked generally from highest to lowest potential impact on cost savings

1. Service Entrance & Distribution
Conductor Material (Copper vs. Aluminum)



Copper

Generally higher cost upfront but may have a longer lifespan (corrosion resistance), and lower voltage drop, especially at larger amperages.

Aluminum

Less expensive than copper for larger conductors, especially for service entrance conductors and feeders. Requires careful selection of terminations and installation practices to prevent oxidation and loosening of connections.


Things to consider before swapping



Ampacity Requirements

Aluminum conductors may need to be larger than copper for the same ampacity, potentially impacting conduit size and installation labor.


Voltage Drop Calculations

Recalculate voltage drop with aluminum to ensure it remains within acceptable limits, especially for long feeder runs.

Termination Compatibility

Ensure all devices (panels, breakers, lugs) are rated and approved for use with aluminum conductors. Special terminations, like dual-rated lugs, might be required, adding to the cost.


Labor Costs

Aluminum can be more challenging to work with and may require specialized tools or training, potentially increasing labor costs.

Service Size & Demand Load Calculation



Is the service adequately sized but not excessively oversized?
Carefully review the load calculations to identify potential areas where the connected load can be reduced or diversified. Over-sizing the service is a common area for cost reduction. Demand Factors

Apply appropriate demand factors according to the NEC and the specific occupancy type. For example, classrooms might have a lower demand factor than office space.


Consider Load Shedding or Peak Demand Management

If the gym has high intermittent loads (e.g., HVAC, lighting), could a load shedding system be implemented to reduce peak demand and potentially lower service size? This requires a more sophisticated design but can provide long-term cost savings.

Panelboard Selection



Panel Size

Are the panelboards sized appropriately for the load, with sufficient spare capacity for future expansion but not excessively oversized? Too many empty spaces increase the cost.

Panel Type

Are there opportunities to consolidate loads onto fewer, larger panels?


Feeder Configuration

Are there opportunities to run fewer, larger feeders instead of multiple smaller ones? This can reduce conduit and labor costs.

Transformer Selection (if applicable)



Efficiency

Consider high-efficiency transformers to reduce energy losses. These have a higher upfront cost but offer significant long-term savings, especially for continuously loaded transformers.

Transformer Size

Ensure the transformer is appropriately sized for the load, not significantly oversized.


Metering



Sub-metering

Does the design include sub-metering for individual tenants or departments? This can encourage energy conservation and allow for more accurate cost allocation but adds to the initial cost. Evaluate the necessity and cost-effectiveness of sub-metering.

2. Lighting Systems
Fixture Selection



LED vs. Traditional Lighting

LEDs are almost always the better choice now due to their energy efficiency and long lifespan. However, be sure to compare pricing on different LED fixture options.


Fixture Type

Can the same type of fixture be used in multiple areas to reduce the variety of fixtures and potentially get volume discounts? Consider simpler, less expensive fixture designs where appropriate.

Lighting Levels

Review the lighting levels specified in the design. Are they appropriate for the task? Sometimes lighting levels are unnecessarily high.


Lighting Controls



Occupancy Sensors

Ensure occupancy sensors are used in areas where occupancy is intermittent (classrooms, offices, restrooms, storage rooms).


Daylight Harvesting

If there is sufficient natural light, consider using daylight harvesting controls to dim or turn off lights when natural light is available. This requires careful design and sensor placement.

Dimming Systems

Are dimming systems specified? Dimming can save energy but adds to the cost. Evaluate the necessity and cost-effectiveness of dimming.


Timer Controls

For exterior lighting, consider timer controls or photocells to ensure lights are only on when needed.

3. Wiring Methods & Materials
Conduit vs. Cable



Conduit

More expensive upfront but offers better protection for the conductors and allows for future changes. Consider using EMT (Electrical Metallic Tubing) instead of rigid conduit where appropriate.

Cable (e.g., MC Cable)

Less expensive than conduit and easier to install in some situations. Consider using MC cable in areas where it is permitted by code and where there is no need for future changes.


Flex Conduit

Minimize the use of flexible conduit, as it is more expensive than rigid conduit.

Wire Size



Minimize Wire Waste

Optimize wire runs to minimize waste. Consider using pre-cut wire lengths.

Conductor Fill

Ensure that conduit fill is optimized, but not exceeded. Using larger conduits with smaller wires is a waste of material and money.

4. Receptacles & Devices
Receptacle Spacing



Code Compliance

Ensure receptacle spacing complies with code requirements (NEC 210.52). Avoid over-spacing receptacles.


GFCI Protection

Optimize GFCI protection. Consider using GFCI breakers instead of GFCI receptacles where possible. GFCI breakers can be more cost-effective for protecting multiple receptacles.

Device Selection



Standard vs. Decorative

Use standard-grade devices (switches, receptacles) unless decorative devices are specifically required by the client.

USB Receptacles

Consider the necessity of USB receptacles. They are convenient but add to the cost.

5. Fire Alarm & Life Safety Systems
System Type

Is the fire alarm system addressable or conventional? Addressable systems are more expensive but offer more features and flexibility. Evaluate the necessity of an addressable system.

Device Placement

Ensure smoke detectors and other devices are placed according to code requirements. Avoid over-spacing devices.


Wiring Method

Consider the approved wiring method for fire alarm circuits.

6. Labor Costs
Simplification

Any design changes that simplify the installation process will reduce labor costs.


Standardization

Using the same types of materials and devices throughout the project will make the installation process more efficient.

Prefabrication

Consider prefabricating some of the electrical components off-site to reduce on-site labor costs.

III. Specific Considerations for the Project Types
Classrooms

Lighting: High-efficiency LED lighting with occupancy sensors. Receptacles: Adequate spacing but avoid over-spacing. Technology: Consider power and data requirements for smartboards and other classroom technology.

Office Space

Lighting: High-efficiency LED lighting with occupancy sensors and daylight harvesting (if applicable). Power: Adequate receptacles for workstations. Data: Consider structured cabling for data and communication.

Gym

Lighting: High-bay LED lighting with occupancy sensors. Power: Consider the power requirements for gym equipment. HVAC: Ensure adequate power for HVAC equipment. Emergency Lighting: Ensure adequate emergency lighting.

IV. Important Reminders
Document Everything

Keep a detailed record of all suggested changes, the reasoning behind them, and the potential cost savings.


Communicate

Communicate clearly with the design engineer and the client about the potential impacts of each change.

Consider the Long Term

Don't just focus on the initial cost. Consider the life-cycle costs of the electrical system.


Get Approvals:
Any suggested changes must be reviewed and approved by the responsible design engineer and relevant authorities.By systematically reviewing these areas, you can identify potential cost savings without compromising safety or functionality. Remember to focus on areas with the highest potential impact and to consider the long-term implications of each change. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question