User: ReneDionne, Location: Montreal
Asked on: Thursday, October 17, 2024 at 4:34 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:04 am EST
Question: Hello. I have some Entrelec/ABB fuse terminals that show a 6.3A max fuse that I can put in. However, on the little table that is etched on the side, under the CSA column (I am in Canada), I can clearly see 10A. I can provide a picture later, but I am just confused because this appears to be contradictory to me. I want to use a 10A fuse to distribute power to 3 discrete output PLC cards (triac) at 120 VAC. Would the be a code violation? Space is limited in my panel. Has someone ever been exposed to that situation? Thanks in advance.
Okay, let's break down this situation with the Entrelec/ABB fuse terminals and the fuse rating discrepancies. It's good you're being cautious and double-checking!Understanding the Discrepancy
6.3A Max Fuse
This is likely the overall manufacturer's maximum rating for the fuse terminal block itself. This rating considers the physical limitations of the terminal block's construction (wire size it can accommodate, heat dissipation, etc.).
10A CSA Rating
This means that specifically under Canadian Standards Association (CSA) regulations, the terminal block has been tested and certified to safely handle a 10A fuse in specific applications under specific conditions. This could be because CSA standards have different testing or acceptance criteria than the manufacturer's baseline rating.
Addressing the Code Violation Question
The Short Answer
Using a 10A fuse could be a code violation,
depending on several factors. You can't just look at the CSA rating in isolation.
The Detailed Breakdown
The "Weakest Link" Principle
In any electrical circuit, you're always bound by the lowest-rated component. If the terminal block itself has a maximum rating of 6.3A, exceeding that rating anywhere is problematic.2.
CSA Context is Key
The 10A CSA rating is valid
ONLY IF all the conditions under which the terminal block was CSA-tested are met in your application. These conditions could include: Specific wire gauge used. Ambient temperature limitations. Specific enclosure requirements. The type of load (inductive vs. resistive). Short-circuit current withstand requirements. The specific upstream protection.3. Manufacturer's Documentation is Paramount
You need to find the
complete technical documentation for the exact model of Entrelec/ABB fuse terminal block you have. This documentation should: Clearly state the maximum fuse rating. Specify the conditions under which the CSA rating applies (if any). Provide any derating factors (e.g., if multiple circuits are run through adjacent terminal blocks). Have any other markings on the product itself that specify the CSA rating and any conditions.4. Application Requirements
PLC Card Protection
The primary reason you're using the fuse is to protect the PLC output cards. You need to know the maximum current each PLC output card can safely handle (look at the PLC datasheet). If the output cards are rated less than 10A, using a 10A fuse won't protect them properly! The fuse must blow before the PLC output card is damaged.
Wire Gauge
The wire you're using to connect the fuse terminal to the PLC cards must be rated to handle at least the fuse's current rating (either 6.3A or 10A, whichever is higher based on the documentation).
Upstream Protection
What's protecting the circuit upstream of the fuse terminal block (e.g., a circuit breaker in the panel)? The fuse needs to be coordinated with the upstream protection to ensure proper selective coordination (the fuse should blow before the breaker trips in most overcurrent situations).
Recommendations
Find the Datasheet
Locate the exact datasheet for your Entrelec/ABB fuse terminal block. Look for part numbers and any other identifying marks on the terminal block itself to make sure you have the correct documentation. ABB's website is a good starting point.2.
Carefully Review the Datasheet
Pay close attention to the "Technical Data" or "Specifications" section. Look for: Maximum fuse rating. Voltage rating. Current rating (specifically, the rated current with a fuse installed). Wire gauge range. Approvals (UL, CSA, etc.) and any conditions associated with those approvals. Short circuit current rating.3.
Calculate the Load
Determine the actual maximum current draw of the three PLC output cards combined. Add a safety margin (e.g., 20%) to account for inrush current or unexpected surges. This will give you the required fuse size to protect the PLC cards.4.
Choose the Fuse
Select a fuse size that meets all of the following criteria: It's less than or equal to the maximum fuse rating specified in the terminal block's datasheet. It's less than or equal to the maximum current rating of the PLC output cards. It's sufficient to handle the calculated load current (with the safety margin). It's appropriate for the wire gauge you're using. It's properly coordinated with the upstream protection.5.
Consult an Electrical Inspector or Engineer
If you're still unsure, it's always best to consult with a qualified electrical inspector or engineer in your area. They can review your specific application and ensure that it complies with all applicable codes and standards (including the Canadian Electrical Code).
Regarding Space Constraints
If the 6.3A fuse is sufficient to protect the PLC output cards, using it is the safest option, even if it means slightly less distribution capacity. If you absolutely need to use a 10A fuse to handle the load, consider using a different type of fuse terminal block that is specifically rated for 10A and meets all applicable requirements. You might need to rearrange the panel layout slightly to accommodate a larger terminal block.* Another option might be to use individual fuses for each PLC card. This would allow you to optimize the fuse size for each card's specific current draw.
In summary: Get the datasheet. Verify the CSA conditions. Protect the weakest link (PLC cards). Consult an expert if needed. Flag for review