Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Waste Water Treatment Building

User: Hoyt2020, Location: WI

Asked on: Friday, October 18, 2024 at 7:55 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:05 am EST

Question: Working on the electrical design for a small, 2000 square foot rural WWTB. Looking for recommendations for conduit type for the Chemical Room, I see several options but looking for recommendations from someone with firsthand experience. PVC coated Rigid?Also, rest of the interior spaces. I do have a bar screen room - C1/D1 w/ RGSC. I have a UV room and blower room that I am sure will have humidity / moisture to some degree.Anything additional design wise for the electrical for this type of building? Gothca's, tips, etc. As stated, first one.Appreciate the input in advance.

Okay, let's break down the conduit selection and some design considerations for your small WWTB electrical system. It's great you're thinking this through thoroughly.

Chemical Room Conduit



PVC Coated Rigid (RMC)

This is an excellent choice for a chemical room, and generally considered the gold standard. Here's why:


Superior Corrosion Resistance

The PVC coating provides a robust barrier against a wide range of chemicals commonly found in WWTBs (acids, bases, chlorine compounds, etc.). Even if the outer PVC layer is scratched, the steel underneath is still protected by the coating's adherence and chemical resistance.

Mechanical Strength

Rigid conduit provides excellent physical protection for the conductors. Important in an area where equipment might be moved, or accidental impacts could occur.


Long Lifespan

Properly installed PVC coated rigid conduit will last a very long time, reducing maintenance and replacement costs.

Grounding

RMC provides an effective ground path. Ensure all connections are properly made and use listed grounding bushings and straps as needed.


Alternatives and Considerations (Why I still Recommend PVC Coated RMC)



Rigid Galvanized Steel (RGS)

Galvanized steel is cheaper, but it's NOT recommended for chemical rooms with aggressive chemicals. Galvanizing can corrode, especially if the coating is damaged. The corrosion products can also be problematic.


PVC Conduit

While cheaper, PVC conduit can be brittle, especially in cold temperatures. It lacks the mechanical strength of RMC. It also might not be suitable for all chemical concentrations or temperatures. (Check chemical compatibility charts!) Also, grounding PVC is more complex, requiring a separate grounding conductor in the conduit. The most common failure to me is in the threads of the connector to a metal enclosure.

Stainless Steel Conduit

Excellent corrosion resistance, but VERY expensive. Often overkill for a small plant unless dealing with incredibly harsh chemicals.

Recommendation for Chemical Room



PVC Coated Rigid Conduit (RMC) is your best bet for a balance of cost, protection, and longevity in a typical WWTB chemical room.
Make sure to: Install Properly

Use proper PVC coated conduit bodies, couplings, and supports. Torque bolts to the manufacturer's specifications. Damaging the coating during installation defeats the purpose.

Seal Penetrations

Use suitable sealant where conduit enters enclosures to prevent chemical ingress.


Grounding

Properly ground the conduit system with appropriate fittings.

Other Interior Spaces Conduit



Bar Screen Room (C1/D1 - Hazardous Location)



Rigid Galvanized Steel Conduit (RGSC) (with explosion-proof fittings)

This is the standard for Class 1, Division 1 hazardous locations. No compromise here. Make sure all boxes, fittings, and equipment are rated for the environment (explosion-proof, suitable for the gas/vapor present). You should have a qualified electrical engineer or inspector review the hazardous area classification and design.

UV Room



Rigid Galvanized Steel Conduit (RGS) or PVC Coated RMC

RGS is often acceptable here, but consider PVC Coated if there's a high chance of chemical exposure from cleaning agents or accidental spills. The UV light itself doesn't directly affect the conduit type decision, but the humidity and potential for spills/chemicals are the drivers.

Watertight Fittings

Use watertight conduit fittings and boxes to prevent moisture ingress. Condensation is common in UV rooms.


Consider Stainless Steel Enclosures

Enclosures (for starters, disconnects, etc.) exposed to UV light can degrade over time. Stainless steel enclosures may be a worthwhile investment.

Blower Room



Rigid Galvanized Steel Conduit (RGS)

RGS is generally suitable here. Humidity is a concern, so use watertight fittings and boxes.

Consider Condensation

If the blower room is subject to significant temperature swings, condensation can be a big issue. You might consider:


Heated Enclosures

To prevent condensation inside electrical enclosures.

Breather/Drain Fittings

To allow condensation to escape from conduit runs.


Proper Ventilation

Ensure adequate ventilation in the room to minimize humidity.

General Interior Spaces (Offices, Labs, Control Room)



EMT (Electrical Metallic Tubing)

EMT is acceptable in dry, non-hazardous locations. It's cost-effective and easy to install. Use compression fittings.

Rigid Galvanized Steel Conduit (RGS)

A more robust option for general areas where physical protection is desired.

Additional Design Tips and Gotchas for WWTB Electrical Systems



Hazardous Area Classification

Absolutely critical. Have a qualified professional determine the hazardous area classifications for all areas of the plant. This will dictate the type of wiring, equipment, and installation methods required. Don't guess!

Redundancy/Backup Power

Consider the consequences of a power outage. A backup generator is often essential to maintain plant operation, especially for critical processes. Automatic transfer switches are a must.


Grounding and Bonding

Proper grounding and bonding are essential for safety and to minimize electrical noise that can interfere with sensitive instrumentation and control systems. Use a dedicated grounding electrode system (ground rods).

Surge Protection

WWTBs are susceptible to power surges from lightning and utility grid disturbances. Install surge protection devices (SPDs) at the service entrance and at critical equipment.


Motor Control

Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) are common for controlling pumps and blowers, improving efficiency. Properly size and protect the VFDs and motors. Consider harmonic mitigation if using multiple VFDs.

Instrumentation and Control

Pay close attention to the wiring and shielding requirements for instrumentation and control cables. Use shielded cable and properly ground the shields to prevent noise.


Lighting



Efficient Lighting

LED lighting is the way to go for efficiency and long life.


Vapor-Tight Fixtures

Use vapor-tight fixtures in areas with high humidity.

Emergency Lighting

Provide adequate emergency lighting throughout the plant, powered by a backup source.


Corrosion Prevention



Stainless Steel Hardware

Use stainless steel screws, bolts, and other hardware to resist corrosion.


Epoxy Coatings

Consider epoxy coatings for exposed metal surfaces to provide additional protection.

Regular Inspections

Establish a routine inspection program to identify and address any signs of corrosion early on.


Documentation

Maintain accurate and up-to-date electrical drawings and documentation. This will be invaluable for troubleshooting and future modifications.

Codes and Standards

Ensure that the electrical design and installation comply with all applicable codes and standards (NEC, local codes, etc.).


Future Expansion

Plan for future expansion when designing the electrical system. Provide spare capacity in panels, conduit, and feeders.

Remote Monitoring and Control

Consider incorporating remote monitoring and control capabilities into the electrical system. This can improve efficiency and reduce the need for on-site personnel.

Key Takeaways



Chemical Room: PVC Coated RMC is the go-to.
Invest in it; it's worth it. Hazardous Locations: Follow the NEC to the letter! Moisture is your enemy. Use watertight fittings and consider heated enclosures/breathable fittings. Plan for corrosion. Use appropriate materials and coatings. Redundancy is your friend. Backup power and surge protection are essential.Finally, consult with experienced electrical engineers and contractors who have worked on WWTB projects before. Their expertise can save you time, money, and headaches in the long run. I hope this comprehensive guidance will prove helpful in your project! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question