User: Dan Mulligan, Location: Tennessee
Asked on: Friday, October 18, 2024 at 3:18 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:07 am EST
Question: We have an apartment building with a 1600-amp service. The sprinkler main comes through the slab in steel pipe for 18" and changes to PVC for the rest of the sprinkler piping. The Building Official feels the 18" of pipe needs to be bonded with 3/0. The code he is using is 250.104(B). Does 18" of pipe qualify as a piping system and if it does and needs to be bonded, would it need to be sized based on the service size? The Building Official's argument is there is 10' of pipe underground and if someone were to come in contact with a live wire like an extension cord and the sprinkler main, the bond wire has to be big because the sprinkler main is big. We don't think it needs to be bonded at all because it is not likely to become energized. And even if we had a full steel sprinkler piping system the bond would be the equipment grounding conductor for the circuit that is likely to energize the piping system, in this case the 120-volt sprinkler bell.
This is a tricky situation that touches on several aspects of the NEC. Let's break down the arguments and address the code sections.
Understanding 250.104(B): Bonding of Other Metal Piping Systems
NEC 250.104(B) states (in essence) that metal piping systems, including sprinkler piping, that are likely to become energized shall be bonded to the service equipment, the grounding electrode conductor, or the grounding electrode system. The size of the bonding jumper is determined by Table 250.102(C)(1), which is based on the size of the service conductors.
Arguments Against Bonding with 3/0
Short Length and Material Change
Your primary argument is the 18" section doesn't qualify as a "piping system." It is a very short section before a change to PVC. The PVC portion is non-conductive and largely negates the potential for the steel pipe to carry significant current or become a significant hazard. This is a strong point.
Unlikely to Become Energized
You correctly point out the low likelihood of the sprinkler piping system becoming energized. It's not a regularly used conductive surface in contact with electrical equipment.
Alternative Bonding Perspective
Your statement about bonding to the equipment grounding conductor (EGC) of the circuit likely to energize the system is also relevant. If the only electrical connection to the sprinkler system is the 120V sprinkler bell, then the EGC for that circuit should be sufficient.
The Building Official's Reasoning
"Piping System" Definition
The official is interpreting the 18" plus the underground portion as constituting a "piping system."
Potential for Energization
The official is focusing on a worst-case scenario, such as someone using a faulty extension cord and contacting both the pipe and ground.
Service Size Based Bonding
The official is applying the "bonding to the service equipment" rule and using Table 250.102(C)(1) to determine the bonding jumper size, resulting in the 3/0 requirement.
Safety First
Their primary concern is safety, erring on the side of caution.
Analysis and Recommendations
The "Piping System" Argument
This is the key point of contention. The NEC doesn't provide a specific definition of "piping system." However, common sense suggests that 18" of steel pipe before a substantial run of PVC is arguably NOT a significant "piping system" as intended by 250.104(B). A literal interpretation might support the official, but a performance-based approach might not.
2.
Risk Assessment
Document and present a risk assessment to the official. Consider these factors:
Limited Conductivity
The PVC run significantly reduces the potential for current flow through the 18" section.
Location
Is the 18" pipe accessible to the public? Is it protected?
Likelihood of Contact
How likely is it that someone would simultaneously contact the pipe and a live electrical source?
Mitigation
Is the sprinkler bell circuit GFCI protected? This significantly reduces the risk of electrocution in a fault situation.3.
Alternative Bonding Solution (Compromise)
If you can't convince the official to waive bonding altogether, propose a compromise:
Bond to the EGC
Bond the 18" section to the equipment grounding conductor of the sprinkler bell circuit. Explain that this provides adequate fault current protection for the most likely energization scenario. Use a bonding jumper size appropriate for that circuit (likely much smaller than 3/0).
Supplementary Bonding (if desired)
If the official is still concerned, offer to install a smaller supplementary bonding jumper (e.g., #6 AWG) to the nearest grounding electrode or building steel. This provides some additional protection without being based on the service size.4.
Documentation
Document all discussions and proposed solutions in writing. If the official insists on the 3/0 bonding, request a written interpretation or clarification of their reasoning, citing the specific code section they believe is being violated.5.
Second Opinion
Consider getting a second opinion from a qualified electrical engineer or a different building official.
Code Justification
250.4(A)(5)
This section emphasizes that grounding and bonding should be done in a manner that limits the voltage imposed by lightning, line surges, or unintentional contact with higher voltage lines and that facilitates the operation of the overcurrent protective devices. The focus is on a practical approach to safety.
In Summary:
The Building Official's interpretation is overly conservative. While their concern for safety is understandable, the requirement for a 3/0 bonding jumper seems excessive given the specific circumstances. Present a well-reasoned argument, emphasizing the limited nature of the steel pipe section, the low probability of energization, and alternative bonding solutions that provide reasonable safety without unnecessary cost and complexity. Document everything and, if necessary, seek a second opinion. Flag for review